View Full Version : Did Darlie Routier have sex in prison?


ogapogadots
03-08-2024, 11:35 PM
Do you think the female "stars" from UM, who got arrested and sent to prison for their crimes, ever engage in inappropriate sexual behavior behind bars? Like with a prison guard? Or did you ever read or hear about someone from UM who got in trouble for having sex? Susan Smith, for example, was eventually caught having sex with a male prison guard. And Susan also had sex with another female prisoner I think and perhaps got in trouble for that too, not sure. I don't think she was on UM.

But that segment with voluptuous Darlie in the kitchen made me think of this! Im a clean cut person who never got into trouble, but if I was a male prison guard and some attractive female prisoner was hitting on me - I think I would be the type to go after her especially if I was in a bad relationship or single.

Yes, I think Darlie had sex in prison, but maybe just during a phase, not like all the time. Obviously Bobbie Parker had sex with the prisoner who she stupidly was working with and while they lived together for years on the run. I think Bobbie had to serve some jail or prison time after they got caught! I wonder if she had sex with a prison guard this time around - where the roles are some-what reversed: shes behind bars, lol. Who else had sex?

DALLASTEXAN!!
03-09-2024, 01:59 AM
Do you think the female "stars" from UM, who got arrested and sent to prison for their crimes, ever engage in inappropriate sexual behavior behind bars? Like with a prison guard? Or did you ever read or hear about someone from UM who got in trouble for having sex? Susan Smith, for example, was eventually caught having sex with a male prison guard. And Susan also had sex with another female prisoner I think and perhaps got in trouble for that too, not sure. I don't think she was on UM.

But that segment with voluptuous Darlie in the kitchen made me think of this! Im a clean cut person who never got into trouble, but if I was a male prison guard and some attractive female prisoner was hitting on me - I think I would be the type to go after her especially if I was in a bad relationship or single.

Yes, I think Darlie had sex in prison, but maybe just during a phase, not like all the time. Obviously Bobbie Parker had sex with the prisoner who she stupidly was working with and while they lived together for years on the run. I think Bobbie had to serve some jail or prison time after they got caught! I wonder if she had sex with a prison guard this time around - where the roles are some-what reversed: shes behind bars, lol. Who else had sex?

yeah IDK, I'm going to lean no on Darlie because she is such a high profile inmate. definitely wouldn't be worth for a guard working at a prison to be doing that with any inmate, much less someone as popular as Darlie. I recently saw a documentary on the Susan Smith prison sex scandal and the guard that had the relationship with her lost just about everything.

ogapogadots
03-09-2024, 02:51 AM
Good point on Darlie being well known and on death row. She is watched moreso than if she was at a medium security prison. On UM there are many men who got caught, arrested, and sent to prison where as for women it is less. I will have to research other female fugitives who later ended up in prison....

1. Lady and her husband (or boyfriend) who killed an old couple that ran a small convenience store in a tiny town. She was later arrested while working at a convenience store/gas station! How convenient! Maybe she has and/or had sex in prison. I say no. But some quiet looking women can be rowdy under the sheex.

Guess I should have said "If women had sex OR oral sex in prison". That may increase the list of female fugitives as some prisoners may just do oral sex instead of the full sex act.


yeah IDK, I'm going to lean no on Darlie because she is such a high profile inmate. definitely wouldn't be worth for a guard working at a prison to be doing that with any inmate, much less someone as popular as Darlie. I recently saw a documentary on the Susan Smith prison sex scandal and the guard that had the relationship with her lost just about everything.

Clockwork
03-09-2024, 02:10 PM
I like the honesty in this thread. My gut tells me that yes she has had sex in prison. There is no way Darlie has been celibate since 1996. I can see how a young Darlie could hook you in. She didn't have three children just because a stork delivered them, let's just say. She looked desirable on the surface for sure. That is a big risk and you have to ask why a guard would do this, but I am willing to bet at least one did.

Also, I know at one point she was engaged is this correct? I seem to remember that. If that is the case, would she be allowed to see him privately? As in a conjugal visit?

We have cases of mostly female guards busting an inmate out of prison. Well, we know they were likely intimate. And these are just the cases we know about. Certainly it happens behind the scenes with other guards covering it up.

DALLASTEXAN!!
03-09-2024, 04:00 PM
I like the honesty in this thread. My gut tells me that yes she has had sex in prison. There is no way Darlie has been celibate since 1996. I can see how a young Darlie could hook you in. She didn't have three children just because a stork delivered them, let's just say. She looked desirable on the surface for sure. That is a big risk and you have to ask why a guard would do this, but I am willing to bet at least one did.

Also, I know at one point she was engaged is this correct? I seem to remember that. If that is the case, would she be allowed to see him privately? As in a conjugal visit?

We have cases of mostly female guards busting an inmate out of prison. Well, we know they were likely intimate. And these are just the cases we know about. Certainly it happens behind the scenes with other guards covering it up.
While not impossible, I don't know why there is any reason to believe that it happened, and it seems weird to me to conjecture something like this based on her reputation or her appearance. She has a much higher chance of being caught and punished for that. It would further destroy her steadfast innocence campaign. Any guard who engages in that activity has everything lose than and literally nothing to gain. Most of the cases in UM were with a select few out there that fall in love with an inmate and think that they can make it work via long distance or prison break.

If she is on death row for murdering her children, I would think that she is getting held to account for what she did. I find it difficult to believe that she is getting preferential treatment other than the media seems to want to keep her case under review while we probably have innocent prisoners out there who don't get any coverage.

DALLASTEXAN!!
03-09-2024, 04:27 PM
Good point on Darlie being well known and on death row. She is watched moreso than if she was at a medium security prison. On UM there are many men who got caught, arrested, and sent to prison where as for women it is less. I will have to research other female fugitives who later ended up in prison....

1. Lady and her husband (or boyfriend) who killed an old couple that ran a small convenience store in a tiny town. She was later arrested while working at a convenience store/gas station! How convenient! Maybe she has and/or had sex in prison. I say no. But some quiet looking women can be rowdy under the sheex.

Guess I should have said "If women had sex OR oral sex in prison". That may increase the list of female fugitives as some prisoners may just do oral sex instead of the full sex act.

Are you talking about the cheryl holland and eddie wooten segment? That's an interesting comparison to Darlie because that was also a brutal crime committed by a loved one. and Cheryl's sister like so many family members came to Cheryl's defense and tried to put the blame elsewhere.

I don't think there is any reason to believe that darlie had a relationship with a guard, but we know there is corruption out there and it is relevant to so many UM cases.

ogapogadots
03-09-2024, 05:58 PM
In Darlie's situation it can be the exact opposite! She has nothing to lose thus she gives up and gives into temptation. I think Darlie had sex. And who is to say that she refused sex for the first very long 20 years of her prison sentence to keep up a good front for future appeals AND then she had sex with a prison guard or multiple ones.

Perhaps if Darlie is allowed conjugal visits from her husband, then yes she had sex. But that does not count in this question, since its legal. Im just asking about illegal hookups. Im surprised I did not think of Audrey Marie Hilley right away. She was cheating on her husband before she went to prison. I think Hilley did not have sex behind bars, only as she was granted weekend passes to visit her husband. Otherwise, yes I think she would be the type since she cheated before on her 1st husband. (Im not counting when she had a weekend pass and ran away - of course then she could have had sex with a man she met at some random bar. But i dont think that happened as she died due to being outside in the extreme cold! And she was allowed to visit with her new husband at a nearby motel, I remember seeing the movie about Marie Hilley with Judith Light from "Who's The Boss?" playing her.)

While not impossible, I don't know why there is any reason to believe that it happened, and it seems weird to me to conjecture something like this based on her reputation or her appearance. She has a much higher chance of being caught and punished for that. It would further destroy her steadfast innocence campaign. Any guard who engages in that activity has everything lose than and literally nothing to gain. Most of the cases in UM were with a select few out there that fall in love with an inmate and think that they can make it work via long distance or prison break.

If she is on death row for murdering her children, I would think that she is getting held to account for what she did. I find it difficult to believe that she is getting preferential treatment other than the media seems to want to keep her case under review while we probably have innocent prisoners out there who don't get any coverage.

ogapogadots
03-09-2024, 06:10 PM
Yes, that's her - Cheryl Holland. Thank you.

1) What about Diane Brodbeck who helped a murderer escape from prison and lived with him for some time? Do you think she had sex after she was arrested? I say no, Diane probably did not have a long sentence and wanted to get out of prison asap. Yes, she cheated on her husband by initially writing the killer letters, helping him escape, and then living with him. So Diane is the cheating type. However, I still say no to her having sex in jail or prison.

2) Did the infamous Ms. Liz Carmichael have sex in her prison?


Are you talking about the cheryl holland and eddie wooten segment? That's an interesting comparison to Darlie because that was also a brutal crime committed by a loved one. and Cheryl's sister like so many family members came to Cheryl's defense and tried to put the blame elsewhere.

I don't think there is any reason to believe that darlie had a relationship with a guard, but we know there is corruption out there and it is relevant to so many UM cases.

ogapogadots
03-09-2024, 06:15 PM
a) Do you think the very beautiful and exotic looking Liza Montgomery had sex in prison? (the LasVegas bad-check thief)

b) Do you think Miss Liz Carmichael made love in prison?

I like the honesty in this thread. My gut tells me that yes she has had sex in prison. There is no way Darlie has been celibate since 1996. I can see how a young Darlie could hook you in. She didn't have three children just because a stork delivered them, let's just say. She looked desirable on the surface for sure. That is a big risk and you have to ask why a guard would do this, but I am willing to bet at least one did.

Also, I know at one point she was engaged is this correct? I seem to remember that. If that is the case, would she be allowed to see him privately? As in a conjugal visit?

We have cases of mostly female guards busting an inmate out of prison. Well, we know they were likely intimate. And these are just the cases we know about. Certainly it happens behind the scenes with other guards covering it up.

cordwainer1453
03-10-2024, 05:55 PM
Remember when we just talked about the Unsolved Mysteries cases here............?

ogapogadots
03-10-2024, 07:01 PM
(This is from an actual UM segment; I specifically made sure of that prior to or beforehand. Youv'e just watched too many Rescue 911 and\or Reno 911 segments.) She obviously murdered her 2 kids due to her crazy selfish behavior. Thus I wanted to see if she was still acting selfish and crazy behind bars. Obviously she cant murder someone while currently/presently behind bars. So my next curious question was if she had sex.

[QUOTE=cordwhiner1453;6253482]Remember when we didn't just talked about the Unsolved Mysteries cases here............[/endQUOTE]

EighthStreet
03-11-2024, 10:26 AM
I'm sorry, what?

Labonte18
03-11-2024, 10:36 AM
Do you think the female "stars" from UM, who got arrested and sent to prison for their crimes, ever engage in inappropriate sexual behavior behind bars? Like with a prison guard? Or did you ever read or hear about someone from UM who got in trouble for having sex? Susan Smith, for example, was eventually caught having sex with a male prison guard. And Susan also had sex with another female prisoner I think and perhaps got in trouble for that too, not sure. I don't think she was on UM.

But that segment with voluptuous Darlie in the kitchen made me think of this! Im a clean cut person who never got into trouble, but if I was a male prison guard and some attractive female prisoner was hitting on me - I think I would be the type to go after her especially if I was in a bad relationship or single.

Yes, I think Darlie had sex in prison, but maybe just during a phase, not like all the time. Obviously Bobbie Parker had sex with the prisoner who she stupidly was working with and while they lived together for years on the run. I think Bobbie had to serve some jail or prison time after they got caught! I wonder if she had sex with a prison guard this time around - where the roles are some-what reversed: shes behind bars, lol. Who else had sex?

I'd say.. Who cares? You're half right about Susan Smith.. She was boinking about every guard who would, but if she did with another inmate, there was no discipline for it. And, quite frankly, I'd call that her business. Consenting adults and all. You can see her entire prison record below. From education to work credits to where she's been moved.

https://public.doc.state.sc.us/scdc-public/inmateDetails.do?id=%2000221487

Now.. That being said.. Look at the above.. There's one piece of very interesting information on there. Not the mutilation, not the "Character Based Programs" shes been in recently.

It's the parole date. November 4th. Now, that's when she's ELIGIBLE, and.. I suspect that as time gets even closer than the 9 months away it is now.. And the media reports on it.. There'll be enough of an outcry to prevent it, but..

Her ex-husband hasn't been heard from in about 15 years. He's been living quietly, last i heard he had remarried and had another child. Wonder if this will bring him out of the woodwork.

Killarney Rose
03-11-2024, 11:51 AM
I would hope that it would bring more than him out.

DALLASTEXAN!!
03-11-2024, 12:01 PM
(This is from an actual UM segment; I specifically made sure of that prior to or beforehand. Youv'e just watched too many Rescue 911 and\or Reno 911 segments.) She obviously murdered her 2 kids due to her crazy selfish behavior. Thus I wanted to see if she was still acting selfish and crazy behind bars. Obviously she cant murder someone while currently/presently behind bars. So my next curious question was if she had sex.

[QUOTE=cordwhiner1453;6253482]Remember when we didn't just talked about the Unsolved Mysteries cases here............[/endQUOTE]

In reply to Ogapogadots post replying to Cordwhiner…I don’t understand why you are bringing in Reno 911 and rescue 911? Some of the posts on this thread are more Reno 911esque. Yes these are UM segments. But some of the suggestions being made are off topic in my opinion. We know that Susan smith did have unprofessional relationships while in prison. That doesn’t have any relevance to Darlie or anyone else.

ogapogadots
03-11-2024, 01:38 PM
Hi, I was just joking about the Reno 911, sorry. I used to watch that show. You are right, I was going off topic on Susan Smith. I used her as an outside example about Unsolved Mysteries' Darlie segment. I remember seeing a summer special maybe 4 years ago about Darlie. She still maintained her innocence. I like that UM began as a special that aired only 3 or so times per year in 1987 before changing to Stacks regular seasons. Too bad Lifetime or NBC could have continued UM for another few years by only having 3 specials per year. And bring back a host like Virginia Madsen or Keeley Shay Smith!

Or even if it was a rare thing like every 3 years there is one year where we can get 3 UM specials. If not that, have a reunion special every 10 years, like in 2012 and 2022. (In 2012 have Dennis Farina, Virginia Madsen, and Keeley all host it together as a reunion special and all segments that had updates...). If no network desires this, have UM use their YouTube channel or another channel.

[QUOTE=ogapogadots;6253519](This is from an actual UM segment; I specifically made sure of that prior to or beforehand. Youv'e just watched too many Rescue 911 and\or Reno 911 segments.) She obviously murdered her 2 kids due to her crazy selfish behavior. Thus I wanted to see if she was still acting selfish and crazy behind bars. Obviously she cant murder someone while currently/presently behind bars. So my next curious question was if she had sex.



In reply to Ogapogadots post replying to Cordwhiner…I don’t understand why you are bringing in Reno 911 and rescue 911? Some of the posts on this thread are more Reno 911esque. Yes these are UM segments. But some of the suggestions being made are off topic in my opinion. We know that Susan smith did have unprofessional relationships while in prison. That doesn’t have any relevance to Darlie or anyone else.

freakbook
03-11-2024, 01:58 PM
Man...what? Instead of asking this ridiculous question you should be asking why she murdered her innocent children

You had some sick fantasy and brought it here. This thread should be locked. Completely disrespectful and unnecessary. While we joke around, and even had a "UM crush" thread, as "fans" of the show we forget that these are real cases that some of their friends/family could be reading