Which one did you like better?

I like Abby and all, but I loved Carol. She was so cool! :D

Carol started to bug me after a while....... Abby rawks.

Carol.

I guess I really don't have to answer this but I will anyways.........





ABBY OH MY GAWD SHE RAWKS MY SAWKS LIKE A MONKEY




goooo Maura....i luff yoo....

Well, I never really watched ER that much... maybe one or two at the most until it came on to tnt in syndication. Now I've seen up until the middle of the seventh season with the exception of the very first four episodes and I can honestly say that after watching the first five and then remembering that Doug, Carol, Benton, and Mark go off the show I was wondering if it'd be any good after they all left. I loved Carol and Doug as characters and a couple but I also really love Mark. Benton grew on me after a while.

Anyway... that was drawn out.... my answer is Carol all the way. She was a great character on the show. I was sad to see George Clooney and Julianna Margulis leave the show. I haven't gotten to the one where Mark dies but I'm sure it will be so dramatic and bring me to tears. :-(

Carol annoys me.... I'm an Abby fan all the way.

Carol was cool, but she got a little cranky towards the end...Abby is my definite favorite...I love Maura Tierney...oh yeah, and CARBY all the way.....:lol:

ABBY. Carol had the most annoying voice. GAAAAWD.

Yeah! She was always whining about something...

I like Carol better. I know I'm the minority here, but I can't stand Abby. I like Maura Tierney though. She's a god actress.

dude... i'm related to jullianna marguilis... [carol] MWAHA!!! oKay... i seriously am

see, my uncle's cousin is her dad... i COULD meet her, if my uncle was still alive, but he isn't. GRRRRR!!!!

I miss Lucy Knight...

:lol:

Originally posted by IownTheDivision69
dude... i'm related to jullianna marguilis... [carol] MWAHA!!! oKay... i seriously am

see, my uncle's cousin is her dad... i COULD meet her, if my uncle was still alive, but he isn't. GRRRRR!!!!

If you were related to her, you'd think that you could atleast SPELL her name right. Sheesh.

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA :lol:

I would have to say they are equal in my mind. I like Carol, I thought she was a good character and her and Doug were so perfect together, I was very sad when they both left the show. I think Abby is cool, I like that she is with Carter now, at first it was weird having a new person there, but she is definitely part of the gang now.

Originally posted by TJL
I miss Lucy Knight...

:lol:

Yes she was the best..... :(. RIP Lucy

ABBY!!!!!

Abby rocks!!! carol was annoying! i hated her. but abby rocks all the way. to all u abby fans out there: Hey!!!:)

Abby

Abby- Maura Tierney definetly
no questions about it
she rocks

i like Abby better

My favorite was Carol.

I always liked Carol, but I'm gonna have to go with Abby as my favorite.

Originally posted by TJL
I miss Lucy Knight...

:lol:

Me too! On my local NBC they show one episode on Sat. and one on Sun., and they just aired the first of the two parter where Lucy died. Garsh darn that episode! Too bad Kellie didn't stick around.

Originally posted by Snoopy
I like Carol better. I know I'm the minority here, but I can't stand Abby. I like Maura Tierney though. She's a god actress.

Whoa, I said the same exact thing about Maura and Abby on another thread a few minutes ago. I like Carol better too. She started getting a little... ehhhh toward the end, but I liked her a lot otherwise.

Carol! Abby was coo at first but then she started getting on nerves with her being so, so, I can't even find the words to describe it. That whole thing with her brother and mother, she seriously got on my nerves about that. She soooo lost the coo points.

I like Abby, she's got a good head on her shoulders even though her mother and brother don't!

Hi, I'm new. Well Sort of. I'm new to the ER section.Jumping right in....I like Abby.

Carol was beautiful but Abby is beautiful and funny so i'd have to say ABBY

I like Abby better; Carol is getting annoying

i love abby, shes funny, and a great actress...maura ROX!:D

CAROL ALL THE WAY! Luv ya Julianna :D

Abby!!!

I was watching the reruns of earlier seasons on TNT and I was kinda glad Carol left to be with Ross...her character became whiny..I like Abby better

Im definately an ABBY fan. I thought her and Carter were so cute together and it hurt my heart that it didnt' work out the way we had all hoped.

Carol was cool---but got annoying after she had the twins.

Although both Carol and Abby had times where I loved and hated them, I would have to go for Abby on this one. Plus, I was and will always be a Luby fan.