View Full Version : What ruined Major League Baseball the most
Steroids (https://bleacherreport.com/articles/123268-a-brief-history-of-how-steroids-destroyed-americas-pastime)
Pl2w9JRns6g
Free agency (https://bleacherreport.com/articles/1924495-is-dragging-out-free-agency-good-or-bad-for-major-league-baseball)
ZrH88QoxUn0
Interleague play (https://www.sbnation.com/2011/5/20/2177721/interleague-play-2011)
rihhSTtxM2E
Playoffs (http://thetartan.org/2022/3/21/sports/mlb)
fNzHGQtV7Qk
Analytics (https://troymedia.com/business/analytics-is-destroying-any-entertainment-value-in-baseball/)
Emoojd-ojns
rusty spike 10-05-2023, 12:06 PM I always thought their player strikes were detrimental to the "National Pastime".
biffbronson 10-06-2023, 04:17 AM I like interleague play, but only on a very limited basis. And when it makes sense historically, like the Braves playing in Boston where their franchise originated.
AMackII 10-06-2023, 08:38 PM I think Steroids ruin the MLB completely in the first place because it impact some of the players
LANGUAGE WARNING
SaNy1NOzoRM
Major League Baseball had a tough week. The week started with Rob Manfred being embarrassed by overreacting to the Trevor Bauer situation (https://www.outkick.com/espn-stephen-a-smith-ask-rob-manfred-about-diversity-instead-of-trevor-bauer/). The week got progressively worse for Major League Baseball...as ratings (https://www.sportsmediawatch.com/2023/10/mlb-wild-card-viewership-declines-espn-sweeps/) and attendance (https://www.cbssports.com/mlb/news/2023-mlb-playoffs-rays-see-historically-low-attendance-for-game-1-of-al-wild-card-series-vs-rangers/) for the Wild Card Round were disastrous.
We reveal and react to MLB ratings for the postseason. We question why Rob Manfred started the MLB Playoffs during the middle of the afternoon on Tuesday. We explain the biggest problem in Major League Baseball...while also explaining why Major League Baseball will never be a TV-friendly product.
Dude111 10-11-2023, 03:45 PM Yes quite NWS :D (Volume low)
LANGUAGE WARNING
_h0-k90VbVA
Dude111 10-15-2023, 05:26 PM I say Steroids!!
Duster76 10-17-2023, 11:47 PM The big fix for baseball isn't evident at least not at this time, there are a few little things that can be done as the sports prepares for another jump the shark moment.
Fix the over the air presentation, this is not football, the sport doesn't need an analyst to discuss every event that takes place. All the clutter of information is a turn off to the casual fan that may be interested in sitting through a few innings without being inundated with graphs, charts, pitch speed, location issues, and that's just the beginning. The games were shorter this year, but the presentation of the game is so overloaded with stats that it seems just as slow.
End the season earlier. It's Alice through the looking glass at this point, the postseason has been expanded to what I consider to be an absurd point, the American League had 8 teams finish above .500, six made the postseason. only one (Seattle) won more than 85 games and didn't make the postseason. In the National League nine teams finished above .500 with 84 wins being enough to get a postseason berth. And it's going to get a lot worse, when baseball expands to 32 teams at the end of 24 or 25 the postseason will be top 8 in each league, and four best of seven rounds. You don't need 162 games when the standards are that low. If a team cracks .500 they'll be in. The season should end Labor Day weekend or the weekend after with the playoffs starting in September. Baseball is no match for football why make matters worse by running the postseason up against both the NFL going full throttle and college football as it gets into its premium match-ups.
I say Steroids!!
jc03xIiomOY
The steroid era of baseball took place from the late 1980s through the early 2000s, where home runs increased to record levels. The sudden spike was due to PEDs, or performance enhancing drugs. Steroid testing did not begin until 2003. In 1998, McGwire hit 70 home runs to set the MLB mark, and just 3 years later, Barry Bonds hit 73. Bonds would go on to hit 762 for his career and rack up 7 MVP awards, both MLB records. These achievements would become tainted in the years that followed. In a time where guys were hitting 50, 60, and 70 home runs a season, many players were overlooked, including when they eventually made it to the Hall of Fame ballot. This video will highlight some of the most under appreciated hitters that played during the steroid era.
Players relevant to the video: Mark McGwire, Barry Bonds, Carlos Delgado, David Ortiz, Jim Thome, Manny Ramirez, Albert Belle, Sammy Sosa, Jim Edmonds, Albert Pujols, Scott Rolen, Edgar Martinez, Willie McCovey, Willie Stargell, John Olerud, Larry Walker, Jason Giambi, Rafael Palmeiro, Jose Canseco, Jeff Bagwell, Ken Griffey Jr., Jeff Kent, Andres Galarraga, Dante Bichette, Vinny Castilla, Ellis Burks, Ken Caminiti, Kenny Lofton.
0:00 Intro
1:04 Carlos Delgado
2:55 Manny Ramirez’s Shadow
4:51 Hall of Famers’ Shadow
6:33 John Olerud
8:21 Mark McGwire’s Shadow
11:11 Barry Bonds’ Shadow
13:05 Big Cat
15:21 Blake Street’s Shadow
16:37 Cleveland’s Shadow
18:02 Conclusion
LANGUAGE WARNING
SaNy1NOzoRM
LANGUAGE WARNING
bNgWJ4ij5ps
Major League Baseball concluded their Divisional Rounds last week...with MLB ratings continuing their downward trend. MLB ratings for the Wild Card Round were down double-digits...with MLB ratings for the Divisional Round being saved by one series from potential record lows.
We reveal and react to MLB ratings for the playoffs. We discuss the marketing problem in Major League Baseball...by comparing the lack of marketing in MLB to the NBA and NHL. We also explain why Rob Manfred doesn't help MLB with the scheduling of games...and question why Rob Manfred puts MLB in a position to compete against the NFL.
JRifMoOhOxI
In this video we deep dive into the broadcasting rights of MLB. Why are there blackouts? Why does this matter? What can solve it?
00:00 Intro
00:42 The RSN Golden Era
1:47 A Cord-Cutting Nightmare
4:00 The Blackout Era (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cfb-v4xM_3Q)
6:37 Death of RSNs (https://www.sitcomsonline.com/boards/showthread.php?t=431814) = Death of MLB?
9:27 Streaming Wars: A New Hope?
y-_PyKSQEds
Dude111 05-08-2024, 01:38 PM Greed :(
dvqlL7gLIJM
In today’s video I want to answer the question what killed the popularity of Major League Baseball (https://www.google.com/search?q=What+killed+the+popularity+of+Major+League+Baseball%3F&sca_esv=137e48d954afa8b7&sca_upv=1&sxsrf=ADLYWIIs9-4zxoyClxJ-SbKv2IQfAPkwTA%3A1716189423351&ei=7_hKZrmMFdmLwbkP1ZaCoA4&ved=0ahUKEwj5v8jn15uGAxXZRTABHVWLAOQQ4dUDCBA&uact=5&oq=What+killed+the+popularity+of+Major+League+Baseball%3F&gs_lp=Egxnd3Mtd2l6LXNlcnAiNFdoYXQga2lsbGVkIHRoZSBwb3B1bGFyaXR5IG9mIE1ham9yIExlYWd1ZSBCYXNlYmFsbD8yBRAhGKABMgUQIRigATIFECEYoAEyBRAhGKABMgUQIRigATIFECEYqwIyBRAhGKsCMgUQIRirAkj5G1CYDVivFnABeAGQAQCYAewQoAGFG6oBBzUtMi45LTG4AQPIAQD4AQGYAgSgAuIbwgIEECMYJ8ICCBAAGIAEGKIEmAMAkgcJMS41LTIuOC0xoAfnFA&sclient=gws-wiz-serp)?
I don’t just mean attendance, or television ratings, I mean overall relevance. For a game that was at one time rated the most popular sport in America.
The reason why people don't know the name Shohei Ohtani, but everyone has heard of Babe Ruth...
What made baseball popular in the first place?
When was the peak of popularity?
When and why did it lose popularity?
Dead2009 05-20-2024, 09:50 AM Who voted for free agency? Lol. The only aspect of FA that I agree ruined baseball is the teams with unlimited spending like the Dodgers.
Penny Lane 05-20-2024, 12:59 PM The outrageous money these athletes make nowadays. Back in the late 60's Detroit Tigers legend Al Kaline was offered $90,000.00 which he thought was ridiculous. He said no one was worth that much! I don't know if he accepted it but he was absolutely right! Millions of dollars?! Geez, look how ticket prices have soared not to mention food concessions.
Al Kaline:heart:
Karl Ravech: Baseball doesn’t need saving (https://awfulannouncing.com/mlb/karl-ravech-baseball-saving-young-players.html)
"The game is in great shape."
weZJaOqlAHQ
Saying "baseball is dying" (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=weZJaOqlAHQ&lc=Ugzezbi7pkgpWBBLWHJ4AaABAg) is untrue, but its ability to generate national superstars seems to have taken a hit.
biffbronson 09-09-2024, 07:46 AM Al Kaline:heart:
310607
LANGUAGE WARNING
JnrqpVKC6eI
Rob Manfred Took over as Commissioner of Major League Baseball (https://www.mlb.com/official-information/about-mlb/commissioners) in 2015 and since then A LOT has happened, and this has given people extremely strong opinions on him. Manfred has endured everything, attendance declining, a world wide pandemic, a world series winning scandal and many rule changes, but how has he done now that he’s well into his 9th season as commissioner (https://www.espn.com/blog/sweetspot/post/_/id/54710/ranking-the-commissioners-selig-no-1) and we have plenty of data to check out.
Lets go over 5 of the biggest controversies and decisions that Manfred has made, and grade how he handled these situations, and of course this is MY OPINION. I'm not going to say what I’m thinking before doing research, I’m really going to dig deep into his scandals and see exactly how he handled each of them before I can say he sucks as commissi…. I mean, decide if I think he sucks or not. The 5 things we are going to be looking at are, the Astros Cheating Scandal, the 2020 Pandemic Season, the 2021-22 Lockout, The Oakland A’s Relocation and of course, the rule changes and how that has affected viewership and baseball as a whole.
b_R8-OJDX4M
Hello and welcome to my channel! In this video, we go over how Rob Manfred has recently RUINED Baseball!
w4zipgcOiTk
MLB commissioner (https://www.espn.com/blog/sweetspot/post/_/id/54710/ranking-the-commissioners-selig-no-1) Rob Manfred has just announced that he will cancel the first few weeks of baseball this year as the owners have failed to reach an agreement with the players' union on a new collective bargaining agreement. Rick Strom breaks it down.
ajfD1DqfBZU
After Rob Manfred said there would definitely be a 2020 MLB season, now he is expressing a lack of confidence. Lets take a look back at Manfred’s tenure so far as Major League Baseball Commissioner (https://www.baseball-almanac.com/articles/major_league_baseball_commissioners.shtml), and see if he’s done a good job or not.
bRP0ecmR-Ts
Robert Manfred is RUINING Major League Baseball.. (2022 MLB Recap Lockout blah blah)
fQNV-rWC044
The current commish (https://www.reddit.com/r/baseball/comments/1ars358/drellich_rob_manfred_is_done_as_commissioner_in/) is ruining the game that we all love.
m-F-q20HyTA
In this video, I discuss some of the new rule changes for Major League Baseball in 2020, including the 3-Batter Minimum which requires a pitcher to face at least 3 hitters before being removed unless the inning ends or the pitcher is injured. Also, position players cannot pitch now unless the game is in extra innings or the run differential is over 5.
LuY7hSDxjRU
Daily San Diego Padres Content!!! We are three guys who were born and raised in Southern California as Padres' fans. Looking forward to getting Padres content out to the Friar Faithful!!!
67y4BaoJJzc
The MLB may not play this season and baseball may never recover.
eq8P5Tqn_Ro
2380rhzVezo
Rob Manfred is ruining baseball's growth and appeal to casual fans, and we will suffer for it long term.
xy11SkhY3n0
BuJEe0mjzCQ
On this episode of Big Apple Baseball Banter, Elias and Ben rant and discuss the pure incompetence of the MLB Commissioner (https://www.hummbabybaseball.com/documentaries/ranking-the-mlb-commissioners) Rob Manfred.
bBAS1RA_3B8
It's official. The MLB will be entering a lockout in 2022. After multiple attempts to bridge the gap, baseball is entering a dark time. Neither side is budging and it looks like it's gonna be a while before baseball is played. A lot of this falls on the MLB commissioner (https://www.bleedcubbieblue.com/2022/3/12/22969182/mlb-commissioners-role-part-5-bud-selig-rob-manfred), Rob Manfred. This is a video detailing on how Manfred is crippling his own sport, and why it might be time for a change of the guard.
LANGUAGE WARNING
_h0-k90VbVA
892X_jRuiLY
MLB has some serious postseason problems that are seemingly getting worse and just straight up being ignored. Even a dream matchup between Aaron Judge and the Yankees versus Shohei Ohtani and the Dodgers may not be enough for fans to ignore the glaring issues.
CTriuhnJ9TY
Major League Baseball has always had an intriguing relationship with the postseason. In a sport where games are played almost every single day for 7 months, the playoffs can end a team's season in as little as 2 games. It may just be one of the most unpredictable postseasons in sports and upsets can very easily happen when a team gets hot. So, with an unpredictable playoff, what does that mean for the best team in baseball? Is this sport moving in a direction that continuously makes it difficult for the best team to win it all? In this video, we will look back through baseball's playoff history to find some of the best teams in baseball and their journey to try and prove that they are truly the best, as well as look towards the future to try and figure out what's next.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Chapters:
Introduction: 0:00
What is the Best Team?: 2:15
The World Series Era: 3:23
The Championship Series Era: 7:55
The Division Series Era: 14:09
The Last Thirteen Years: 16:41
Where Do We Go From Here?: 20:35
I think Steroids ruin the MLB completely in the first place because it impact some of the players
EwOx2IA_BCk
This is a look at MLB's Steroid Era.
7yNIFO4ODCo
Topics:
0:00 A true balance of good & bad
0:36 Extra Inning Courtesy Runners
2:50 National League Designated Hitters
4:40 Banning the Defensive Shift
6:25 Replay Challenge for Managers
8:06 A's & Rays in MiLB stadiums
11:42 Great Uniform Fiasco of 2024
13:25 Pitch Timer
14:50 Breakup with ESPN Partnership
15:55 Introduction of ABS system
17:09 Sticking with WBC Tournament
18:35 Conclusions
Dude111 03-04-2025, 02:55 AM I think Greed is ruining it also.......
KaUAbltaoLA
Pitch framing (https://www.google.com/search?q=Has+Pitch+Framing+RUINED+baseball%3F&oq=Has+Pitch+Framing+RUINED+baseball%3F&gs_lcrp=EgZjaHJvbWUyBggAEEUYOTIGCAEQRRg90gEINjE1ajBqMTWoAgywAgHxBUdQ8Th84Jb8&sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8) is a baseball skill where a catcher receives a pitch in a way that makes a borderline pitch more likely to be called a strike by the umpire. This is achieved through subtle, fluid movements of the glove to create the illusion of the ball entering the strike zone when it was slightly outside, and by catching the ball with a glove facing the center of the plate. Elite framers like Patrick Bailey are highly valuable to their teams, as they consistently turn potential balls into strikes, significantly impacting at-bats and run prevention, and their skill is now quantifiable using advanced metrics like Statcast data.
biffbronson 08-29-2025, 02:18 AM I always thought their player strikes were detrimental to the "National Pastime".
My vote in the poll was for "Other," -- Player Strikes.
'Detrimental' is an accurate word in this case.
Duster76 08-30-2025, 12:13 PM KaUAbltaoLA
What nonsense, pitch framing has been part of the game all of my life, there's nothing new about it.
Duster76 08-30-2025, 12:40 PM The big picture at least on the surface, baseball is doing just fine. Attendance is good with the exception of a few teams, and there have always been teams that lagged behind. TV ratings are up, there are no teams worth less than a billion, and there is a line of cities interested in getting an expansion team. If there is any downside, the sport is no longer in contention for most popular, that goes to the NFL, and number two is college football, so it's either third or fourth in popularity fighting with the NBA for that spot. So this is really a discussion about personal feelings.
The game is so different from the game of my youth, I could spend the next hour typing a list of all the things I dislike about the modern game. If I had to put my finger on the one thing that ended my following the game it would be the wild card play-in game which I think started in 2014. That finished me as a baseball fan, I might watch an inning or two of the World Series or a playoff game if its broadcast over the air but I have no interest in who wins.
Iggt86wDGE4
📺 From FREE Games to $240/Year: How Baseball Broadcasting Destroyed America's Pastime
In 1978, 44 MILLION Americans watched Game 6 of the World Series - for FREE on network TV. In 2023? Just 8.1 million watched the entire World Series finale. What happened to America's pastime?
This deep-dive documentary reveals the shocking truth behind baseball's viewership collapse. From the golden age of Dizzy Dean and Harry Caray to today's streaming nightmare of blackouts, subscriptions, and exclusive apps - discover how the pursuit of TV money killed the shared cultural experience that made baseball special.
💡 KEY REVELATIONS: • How MLB's own blackout rules prevent fans from watching their teams • Why the Cubs lost 56% of viewers after creating their own network • How Apple and Amazon are changing baseball forever • The shocking cost breakdown of watching your team today • International growth while domestic viewership dies
I9sKOO5sVLE
Let's explore the future of baseball's development pipeline and speculate what the minor leagues might look like without Single-A and a shortened draft.
Central to our conversation will be a concept I call "development offloading." To save money, MLB could entertain more reliance on college baseball to carry out the development of players.
We'll also dive into the financial world of college baseball (revenue share, NIL) and whether offloading this development is net positive or negative for players.
The NIL situation is complex. I'll emphasize that the numbers I'm using in almost all cases, unless otherwise noted, are guesstimates or educated guesses. Thanks to everybody who took the time to chat with me for this video.
0:00 Into The Future
0:32 Will Minor League Baseball Shrink?
1:07 New MiLB Tech Guidelines
1:35 This STINKS ... But Feels Inevitable
2:29 Trojan Horse: Shrink The Draft
3:05 Development Offloading
3:33 College Baseball Is A Mess
4:43 How Does NIL/Rev Share Work?
5:18 Pool A: Revenue Share
5:51 Pool B: Scholarships
6:28 Pool C: Fundraising
7:24 Example: Georgia vs Oregon State Funding
8:26 Is Development The Priority?
9:46 Development Offloading: Good or Bad
11:09 Even Further Into The Future
11:36 A CRAZY New MLB Draft Model
12:36 College Baseball Butterfly Effect
13:50 Thanks for 20k Subs!
KurtfromPitts 02-11-2026, 04:28 PM Steroids.
wNzVZ425pYc
Some World Series champions were absolute juggernauts. Others just got hot at the right time. In this video, we rank the weakest World Series winners of the Wild Card era and break down how they still found a way to win it all.
2E7kwzG0coM
The game we love is being systematically disassembled, one "pace-of-play" adjustment at a time. From local beer league softball rules to looking like a NASCAR driver at the plate, Major League Baseball has introduced some genuinely horrific rule changes over the years.
In this video, we count down the absolute top 10 WORST rule changes in MLB history—ranking everything from minor, pointless annoyances to the absolute abominations that completely ruin the integrity of a 162-game season.
We’re breaking down the death of the tactical manager, the watering down of the postseason, and the absolute insanity of starting an inning with a runner magically appearing on second base. What happened to real baseball?
Do you agree with the #1 spot, or is there a rule change that makes your blood boil even more? Drop your thoughts in the comments!
🕒 Video Timestamps
2:30 - #10: Bigger Bases (Pointless?)
3:32 - #09: The Universal DH & Loss of Strategy
5:18 - #08: The 5-Inning Minimum Win Rule (Outdated!)
7:22 - #07: The 12-Team Expanded Postseason
10:06 - #06: The Automatic Intentional Walk
11:42 - #05: The Infamous One-Game Wild Card
13:23 - #04: 7-Inning Doubleheaders (Little League Rules)
14:53 - #03: The 3-Batter Minimum
16:50 - #02: Ads on Uniforms (The NASCAR Era)
19:00 - #01: The Ghost Runner on 2nd Base Rule
bZQApCUhg-4
In 1972, a historic shift occurred in American culture: professional football officially toppled baseball as the nation’s favorite sport. But how did a fractured, financially desperate football league dethrone "America’s Pastime"? Discover how a customized loophole from Congress, a daring network television gamble, and the concept of "League Think" allowed a trailing sport to capture the fast-paced spirit of a changing era. From intense backroom negotiations with stubborn big-market owners to the birth of a prime-time cultural phenomenon, find out how football engineered its rise to the top of the mountain—and how baseball is fighting back today.
🕒 Timestamps:
0:00 Why did football overthrow baseball?
1:58 Why baseball was more popular than football
3:25 Why the post war era helped football
4:41 The deal that changed football's economics
7:50 Why the government opposed the NFL
11:20 Why football's civil war nearly destroyed the pro league
13:23 Why Monday Night Football changed everything
16:32 How baseball is fighting back
cq_yx7TMspA
Every major sports league told you the same thing when they expanded their playoffs. More teams. More drama. More moments. More parity.
In this video I break down how playoff expansion has quietly changed the NFL, NBA, MLB, and NASCAR, why the promise leagues made to fans and the reality of what they built are two very different things, and what it actually means for the future of sports.
00:00 Intro
01:17 Chapter 1: The Promise and the Business
03:43 Chapter 2: The NFL: Where it starts to Slip
07:16 Chapter 3: The NBA: When Expansion Hits the Fans
10:02 Chapter 4: MLB: 162 Games for a couple of coin flips
12:26 Chapter 5: NASCAR: When you blow up the Championship entirely
17:19 Chapter 6: What they're really selling
If you enjoyed this video make sure to like, subscribe, and drop your thoughts in the comments. Do you think playoff expansion has helped or hurt your favorite sport? Let me know below.
Wn9nLx_YNBY
Even casual baseball fans have heard of Tommy John. In 1974, he had a successful surgery that changed professional baseball. The surgery, now called Tommy John surgery (https://www.google.com/search?q=Tommy+John+surgery&oq=Tommy+John+surgery&gs_lcrp=EgZjaHJvbWUyBggAEEUYOTIHCAEQABiABDIHCAIQABiABDIHCAMQABiABDIHCAQQABiABDIHCAUQABiABDIHCAYQABiABDIHCAcQABiABDIHCAgQABiABDIHCAkQABiABNIBDDEyODMwODRqMGoxNagCALACAA&sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8), didn’t just extend careers—it altered the philosophy of pitching and contributed to the relentless rise in strikeouts and arm injuries. From one perspective, the surgery made major league baseball less fun to watch and not more. This video reflects on the surgery that changed MLB.
q5KXSEJELhM
Watching baseball in 2026 is unlike any viewing experiencing in the past. Some aspects are better, but other things are getting worse. Way worse.
Jabroni Baseball examines how the transition from traditional cable bundles to fragmented streaming platforms has complicated access for fans. The breakdown explores the financial shifts, blackout rules, and subscription management hurdles required to follow a single team throughout the modern MLB season.
B9MluZNRRjc
Major League Baseball has lost its soul.
The fundamentals are fading, the team-first mentality is being traded for individual spotlights, and the game we grew up loving is being buried under analytics and gimmicks. From the ridiculous home run celebrations to the over-reliance on data at the expense of instinct, the modern game has strayed.
In this video, I’m cutting through the noise to talk about why the product on the field is suffering and why the league’s current direction is missing the mark. It’s not just about being "angry"—it’s about witnessing the decline of a sport that used to stand for something bigger than any one player or one metric.
In this episode:
Why the "team-first" culture is dying in the dugout.
The problem with the modern spotlight on individual ego.
Why the constant "trinkets" and performative celebrations are hurting the game.
My take on how analytics are stripping the soul out of baseball.
Why the current leadership is failing the fans and the history of the game.
If you’re tired of the gimmicks and want a serious look at what’s really happening to the game, you’re in the right place.
|