for me, it's a tie between the Mann family haunting and Don Decker aka Rainboy.

Tie between Clarence Roberts and Stanley Gryziec.

Billy the Kid

Dexter Stefonek

Doyle Wheeler-Donovan Jacobs & The Freedom 2 with the “peculiar-bizarre” miniupdate of the elderly canadian couple

I don't think I have a most watched. Not that I can recall. There are a ton I never watch, though. Anything silly: paranormal and aliens.

I don’t specifically watch any certain segments. I just watch whatever is playing on the streaming channel. But my least favorites are the UFOs and lost treasures.

Michael Rosenblum & the one with Bob Russell, Bob Dozier, Suzanne Russell & Kristin Tomlin

the ones that i see mentioned the most are cindy james, db cooper, tara calico, danny casolero....

i'm sure i'm missing quite a few out.

Underground tunnel bank robbers in L.A love that segment.

Off the top of my head, probably D.B. Cooper, Clarence Roberts, Lost Dutchman's Mine, the Ohio prostitute murders and Jule/Dottie Caylor. Most of my favorite/most memorable segments come from the early seasons.

No. 1: Bonnie Wilder. Tied for 3rd: Don Kemp, Gryziec, Judge John Fairbanks, Salvatore Caruana, Robert Leeds

In recent years, I have been drawn more and more to the Judge Fairbanks segment. Something about that charming town of Newport and how this guy was able to get away with taking their money as long as he did. And knowing that there was so much more behind what this guy was and how he was operating...it continues to intrigue me.

Tom Young/Keith Reinhard, Tennessee ATV murders, A.J. Breaux, Dakotas Double Death, Dexter Stefonek, Philip Fraser...I pretty much find any segment shot on-location in an off-the-beaten-path area to be quite conducive to repeat viewings.

Bonnie Wilder, because I work retail and sometimes it's nice to sympathize with a thief LOL

Usually the unsolved disappearances or homicides: Tom Roche, Deborah Poe, Elizabeth Campbell, Su-Ya Kim and Amy Billig.

I skip through/over some of the lost love & treasure segments, but otherwise watch Seasons 1-4 in their entirety (catching only the MLK Jr Assassination, Dave Bocks and Danny Casolaro segments from the later seasons)

I've probably watched Kevin Ives and Don Henry more times than any other segment if I had to guess. Bobbi Oberholtzer/Annette Schnee is a close second.

Bobbi Oberholtzer/Annette Schnee is a close second.

I'd argue this is in the running for creepiest segment of all time. It's generally unsettling from the get-go. From there it's nightmare material through the end.

I just hate, hate, HATE that the killer, after FINALLY being captured, tried and convicted ended up dying in prison after just a few months earlier this year.

I'd argue this is in the running for creepiest segment of all time. It's generally unsettling from the get-go. From there it's nightmare material through the end.

I just hate, hate, HATE that the killer, after FINALLY being captured, tried and convicted ended up dying in prison after just a few months earlier this year.

The reenactment of the guy trying to rape Bobbi is nightmare fuel. And the music throughout the scenes where both women try running and he shoots at them.

I hate that the guy barely faced justice and that he was rescued that night from freezing on the mountain. It would have been great karma for him to have frozen after committing such horrible crimes. I know that's cruel of me to say, but he killed two women who had done nothing to him. He was a true monster.

The reenactment of the guy trying to rape Bobbi is nightmare fuel. And the music throughout the scenes where both women try running and he shoots at them.

I hate that the guy barely faced justice and that he was rescued that night from freezing on the mountain. It would have been great karma for him to have frozen after committing such horrible crimes. I know that's cruel of me to say, but he killed two women who had done nothing to him. He was a true monster.
I agree, I watched a little bit of the coverage when they indicted the guy, and IIRC it was heavily focused on the DNA investigation. did they ever say if he was a suspect during the early stages of the investigation? It sucks that law enforcement could have investigated him based on his whereabouts.

I have done this thing where I travel and will obsess about a segment that is in that location. One that I watched over and over for like a year straight was the Ohio Trucker Serial Killer. In that time I had very limited access to OG UM segments, but I did somehow have access to this one, I think maybe it was on Youtube and was not being taken down for some reason. Around that same time I was also watching FBI files and there were at least 2 episodes that featured an interstate trucker who was a serial killer.

The Kathrine Korzilius segment sent me down a year-long rabbit hole of research. At this point, I can honestly say I have seen over 100 times.

Other most-watched segments include the John Wilks Booth segment and Delia Fazzai (The British woman who found her daughter that she was forced to put up for adoption) just because these episodes always seem to be on FreeVee.

I agree, I watched a little bit of the coverage when they indicted the guy, and IIRC it was heavily focused on the DNA investigation. did they ever say if he was a suspect during the early stages of the investigation? It sucks that law enforcement could have investigated him based on his whereabouts.

He was nowhere on the radar in the early stages of the investigation. And he never would have been identified if his blood hadn't got on Bobbi's mitten. According to 48 hours, a call was made to the Breckenridge Police in 2005 that named the actual killer. But the call was short and details were scarce.

What really annoys me (and this appears to be the massive elephant in the room) is that nobody ever thought to look into why Phillips wasn't looked at after being rescued from that snowbank within hours of the murders. Being up in that area on a bitter cold night when next to no other people would have been out and about with bruises and blood on him...he explained it away as slipping in the snow and falling face first into his bumper. In reality, it was all defense wounds from trying to restrain Bobbi.

I realize that his rescue became a feel-good story for the locals but it just seems irresponsible not to take a second look as to why he was out there in a critical area at this critical time. Not a single media source has ever addressed this issue. And it makes me feel he might have been arrested much sooner; possibly in the 80's but definitely by the mid-90's when DNA testing was really making a breakthrough.

He was nowhere on the radar in the early stages of the investigation. And he never would have been identified if his blood hadn't got on Bobbi's mitten. According to 48 hours, a call was made to the Breckenridge Police in 2005 that named the actual killer. But the call was short and details were scarce.

What really annoys me (and this appears to be the massive elephant in the room) is that nobody ever thought to look into why Phillips wasn't looked at after being rescued from that snowbank within hours of the murders. Being up in that area on a bitter cold night when next to no other people would have been out and about with bruises and blood on him...he explained it away as slipping in the snow and falling face first into his bumper. In reality, it was all defense wounds from trying to restrain Bobbi.

I realize that his rescue became a feel-good story for the locals but it just seems irresponsible not to take a second look as to why he was out there in a critical area at this critical time. Not a single media source has ever addressed this issue. And it makes me feel he might have been arrested much sooner; possibly in the 80's but definitely by the mid-90's when DNA testing was really making a breakthrough.

100

The Kathrine Korzilius segment sent me down a year-long rabbit hole of research. At this point, I can honestly say I have seen over 100 times.

Other most-watched segments include the John Wilks Booth segment and Delia Fazzai (The British woman who found her daughter that she was forced to put up for adoption) just because these episodes always seem to be on FreeVee.
I thought the John Wilkes Booth segment is one of the best that UM ever produced. I'm not a believer that he got away, but I thought the segment was well done. I have a similar take on the Rudolf Hess segment. I really enjoy to watch both of these segments and the old western segments as well. As I have gotten older I have also appreciated the Agatha Christie segment a lot more than I used to.

As I have gotten older I have also appreciated the Agatha Christie segment a lot more than I used to.

I LOVE that segment. It's a good break from the heaviness of murder and devastation, but still an engaging mystery.

I LOVE that segment. It's a good break from the heaviness of murder and devastation, but still an engaging mystery.

It's such a comfort segment! My favorite part is the reenactment of her drinking in bed while enjoying reading her newspaper because it lists her husband as a suspect in her disappearance.

I skip through/over some of the lost love & treasure segments, but otherwise watch Seasons 1-4 in their entirety (catching only the MLK Jr Assassination, Dave Bocks and Danny Casolaro segments from the later seasons)

I have been doing the same thing over the last year or so. Every other night I'll do dishes and clean my kitchen and I'll pop on some head phones and watch every episode starting with the specials and then right around thru season four. I've cycled thru about 3 times now. It's low key my favorite thing to do.

In recent years, I have been drawn more and more to the Judge Fairbanks segment. Something about that charming town of Newport and how this guy was able to get away with taking their money as long as he did. And knowing that there was so much more behind what this guy was and how he was operating...it continues to intrigue me.

I saw this case for the first time a few years back. I thought the same. Seemed like one of those towns where everyone knew everyone. Shocked he got away with it for as long as he did.

Probably Resurrection Mary.

It's such a comfort segment! My favorite part is the reenactment of her drinking in bed while enjoying reading her newspaper because it lists her husband as a suspect in her disappearance.

Haha that IS the best part of the segment. Definitely meme worthy.

I don’t know about a single segment. But I disproportionately watch the last 5 or so episodes of season 1. Don Smith, Tim McClure, Gus Hoffman, hot jock. Those segments I have seen more times than I can count

wow; ur very beautiful.

The Lost Dutchman Gold Mine, Queen Mary ghost ship