According to Nick Story Wiki

Here is a Classic Christmas Schedule from 1986..

NICK
at
NITE

8:00pm The Donna Reed Show-A Very Merry Christmas
8:30pm Mister Ed-Ed’s Christmas Story
9:00pm My Three Sons
9:30pm The Monkees-The Monkees Christmas Show
10:00pm-11:00pm I Spy-The Lotus Eater
11:00pm-12:00AM Route 66
12:00AM The Donna Reed Show-A Very Merry Christmas
12:30AM Mister Ed-Ed’s Christmas Story
1:00AM My Three Sons
1:30AM The Monkees-The Monkees Christmas Show
2:00AM-3:00AM I Spy-The Lotus Eater
3:00AM-4:00AM Route 66
4:00AM-6:00AM Red Salute (1935)




Here is a Classic Christmas Schedule 1987..

NICK
at
NITE

8:00pm Car 54, Where Are You?-Christmas at 53rd
8:30pm Mister Ed-Ed’s Christmas Story
9:00pm My Three Sons-The Love God
9:30pm The Donna Reed Show-A Very Merry Christmas
10:00pm Rowan and Martin’s Laugh-In
10:30pm The Monkees-The Monkees Christmas Show
11:00pm The Ann Southern Show-The Elopement
11:30pm-12:30AM I Spy-A Room With a Rack
12:30AM Car 54, Where Are You?-Christmas at 53rd
1:00AM Mister Ed-Ed’s Christmas Story
1:30AM The Donna Reed Show-A Very Merry Christmas
2:00AM Rowan and Martin’s Laugh-In
2:30AM The Monkees-The Monkees Christmas Show
3:00AM-4:00AM I Spy-A Room with a Rack
4:00AM-6:00AM Yanks Ahoy (1943)




Here is a Classic Christmas Schedule 1989..

NICK
at
NITE

8:00pm Bewitched-A Vision of Sugar Plums
8:30pm Mister Ed-Ed’s Christmas Story
9:00pm Green Acres
9:30pm Car 54, Where Are You?-Christmas at 53rd
10:00pm The Best of Saturday Night Live-Christopher Lee
10:30pm SCTV-Alice the Wonder Dog/William F Buckley
11:00pm Rowan & Martin’s Laugh-In
11:30pm My Three Sons-Marriage By Proxy
12:00AM The Donna Reed Show
12:30AM Make Room For Daddy
1:00AM Bewitched-A Vision of Sugar Plums
1:30AM Mister Ed-Ed’s Christmas Story
2:00AM Car 54, Where Are You?-Christmas at 53rd
2:30AM Rowan and Martin’s Laugh-In
3:00AM My Three Sons-Marriage By Proxy
3:30AM The Donna Reed Show
4:00AM Make Room For Daddy
4:30AM The Ann Southern Show
5:00AM Lassie
5:30AM Dennis the Menace





Here is another Classic TV Christmas Schedule from 1990..

NICK
at
NITE

8:00pm Mister Ed-Ed’s Christmas Story
8:30pm Bewitched-A Vision of Sugar Plums
9:00pm Green Acres-An Old Fashioned Christmas
9:30pm The Donna Reed Show-A Very Merry Christmas
10:00pm The Best of Saturday Night Live-Elliot Gould
10:30pm The Many Loves of Dobie Gillis-Deck the Halls
11:00pm Alfred Hitchcock Presents-Santa Claus,Tenth Ave Kid
11:30pm The Patty Duke Show-The Christmas Present
12:00AM My Three Sons
12:30AM The Many Loves of Dobie Gillis-Deck the Halls
1:00AM Make Room For Daddy-The Country Girl
1:30AM Mister Ed-Ed’s Christmas Story
2:00AM Bewitched-A Vision of Sugar Plums
2:30AM The Donna Reed Show-A Very Merry Christmas
3:00AM America 2-Night
3:30AM Alfred Hitchcock Presents-Santa Claus,Tenth Ave Kid
4:00AM The Patty Duke Show-The Christmas Present
4:30AM My Three Sons-Going Steady
5:00AM The Many Loves Of Dobie Gillis-Deck The Halls
5:30AM Make Room For Daddy-The Country Girl
6:00AM Lassie




Here is another Classic Christmas TV Schedule 1994..

NICK
at
NITE

8:30pm The Mary Tyler Moore Show-Christmas hard luck kid
9:00pm The Dick Van Dyke Show-Alan Brady Show Presents
9:30pm Bewitched-A Vision of Sugar Plums
10:00pm The Lucy Show-Together For Christmas
10:30pm The Bob Newhart Show-Twas Pie before Christmas
11:00pm Taxi-Get me through the Holiday’s
11:30pm Mork and Mindy-Mork’s First Christmas
12:00AM The Mary Tyler Moore Show-Not a Christmas Story
12:30AM Dragnet-The Christmas Story
1:00AM-2:00AM The White Shadow
2:00AM The Lucy Show
2:30AM Taxi
3:00AM The Bob Newhart Show
3:30AM The Mary Tyler Moore Show
4:00AM-5:30AM The White Shadow





Lastly Here is another Classic Christmas Schedule from 1998..

NICK
at
NITE

9:00pm The Brady Bunch
9:30pm The Wonder Years (1988)
10:00pm Happy Days
10:30pm Laverne & Shirley
11:00pm I Love Lucy
11:30pm Bewitched
12:00AM-2:00AM A Very Brady Christmas (1988)
2:00AM The Brady Bunch
2:30AM The Wonder Years (1988)
3:00AM Happy Days
3:30AM Laverne & Shirley
4:00AM I Love Lucy
4:30AM Bewitched
5:00AM The Mary Tyler Moore Show