Who did you all like better?

They're both good but I like Vicki better. ;) I thought she was great in the early part of the show. Unfortuantly Vicki and Maggie both got dumbed down after awhile :( But my favorite is Victoria. Too bad they never solved their first plotline: Who are her parents?

Below is a collage of Vicki screen captures I made LOL

Maggie is better InMO. She's pretty, and great...

I liked Maggie better Vicky was too into the past and Barnabas.

I always enjoyed Maggie the best of the two. Victoria seemed a bit aloof and remote to me, while Maggie was more personable...

I liked Maggie too. Victoria didn't stay too long on the show.

Both she and burke Devlin left early on.

I liked Maggie. I had a crush on her when I watched DS for the first in '83 when I was 12.:D I liked Victoria a lot too, but the character just seemed a little too bit wishy-washy. No wonder Alexandra Moltke did not return after she found out she could not play an evil character. I'll bet a fans would've loved that. I guess it was Dan Curtis' fault from what I understand.

Maggie was hot. So she gets my vote!!!!! :lol: Seriously, though, I agree that both characters were dumbed down but at least KLS got to play "Josette." Thus, the role she played was a tad bit more varied than what Alexandra Moltke got to play.

Signed,
Respectfully,
Dutch

They're both good but I like Vicki better. ;) I thought she was great in the early part of the show. Unfortuantly Vicki and Maggie both got dumbed down after awhile :( But my favorite is Victoria. Too bad they never solved their first plotline: Who are her parents?

Below is a collage of Vicki screen captures I made LOL

now that I think about it, they never did resolve who her parents were. I wish they had considering that was pretty much one of the base storylines to the whole show in the first episodes.

now that I think about it, they never did resolve who her parents were. I wish they had considering that was pretty much one of the base storylines to the whole show in the first episodes.

Did anybody watch the DS Reunion DVD? I think Alexandra said that if she had stayed there would've been a plot where we find out that she is Elizabeth's lost daughter, and her and Carolyn would've been sisters or something along that line. So many people had said Joan Bennett and Alexandra looked alike. They said Joan even thought Alexandra looked like her daughter and thought she had came to the set to visit her, but it was Alexandra.

Also if the show wasn't canned by ungrateful ABC we would've seen BArnabas and Julia get married. I know Sam Hall had scripts written for it happen. They should've gotten married. I mean they shacked up at The Old House long enough! :lol:

I liked Vicky best as the Governess and Maggie when she was slinging hash at the Collinsport Inn:)

Maggie. I found Victoria boring a lot of times, but she was great too. It's really hard to decide.

Did anybody watch the DS Reunion DVD? I think Alexandra said that if she had stayed there would've been a plot where we find out that she is Elizabeth's lost daughter, and her and Carolyn would've been sisters or something along that line. So many people had said Joan Bennett and Alexandra looked alike. They said Joan even thought Alexandra looked like her daughter and thought she had came to the set to visit her, but it was Alexandra.

Also if the show wasn't canned by ungrateful ABC we would've seen BArnabas and Julia get married. I know Sam Hall had scripts written for it happen. They should've gotten married. I mean they shacked up at The Old House long enough! :lol:

I've always felt that Alexandra would've been Elizabeth's long lost daughter. Too bad they didn't complete the storyline.

I liked both equally.

They were both good actresses, but Maggie seemed to have more screen
time than Victoria did.

I gotta for for Vicky. She was just so stunning. Alexandra was such a hottie I thought, and man did he have great hair:happyface :happyface :happyface :happyface

I can't choose; I liked them both.

Same here - Alexandra Moltke Isles and Kathryn Leigh Scott were both terrific, as were their characters. I can't decide, either!!

Definitely Vicki. Even though she was not a great actress, Alexandra Moltke had a presence that just worked as the ingenue who was at the center of the action. When she left, DS just lost it's heart.

Maggie. I loved her. She was so sweet and pretty! And maybe because she was an outsider, not a Collins. Lived with her Dad who was an artist in a cottage and they weren't very rich! Vicky wasn't a Collins either, but still I liked and even now thinking back I like Maggie better! (Vicky was a teacher and more proper, and Maggie was a waitress if I remember correctly) I relate better to Maggie than to Vicky! :)


https://encrypted-tbn2.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcSzLmds_e9GFcAnTR7-734br_GcIe3neshas0WyxzmSunNdnu,