https://tvline.com/2021/08/29/ed-asner-dead-mary-tyler-moore-show-lou-grant/

Veteran TV actor Ed Asner, best known for playing Lou Grant on The Mary Tyler Moore Show and winner of a record-setting seven Emmy awards, has died at the age of 91.

The news was confirmed by Asner’s family on Twitter: “We are sorry to say that our beloved patriarch passed away this morning peacefully. Words cannot express the sadness we feel. With a kiss on your head – Goodnight dad. We love you.”

A theater actor who first guest-starred on The Outer Limits, Mission: Impossible and Route 66, Asner landed the role of irritable TV news director Lou Grant on CBS’ The Mary Tyler Moore Show, which debuted in 1970. Asner’s gruff persona was the perfect counterweight to star Mary Tyler Moore’s sunny disposition, and the show turned out to be a hit, running for seven seasons and becoming one of the most acclaimed TV series of all time. Asner won three consecutive Emmys for Outstanding Supporting Actor in a Comedy Series for his work as Lou Grant in 1971-73.

After Mary Tyler Moore went off the air, Asner reprised his role on the CBS spinoff Lou Grant, a drama series that saw Grant working as the city editor of a Los Angeles newspaper. Lou Grant had a healthy five-season run from 1977 to 1982, and Asner was nominated five times for Outstanding Lead Actor in a Drama Series, winning twice.

Asner also picked up a pair of Emmys for his roles in the miniseries Roots and Rich Man, Poor Man, making him the male actor with the most Emmy wins ever with a total of seven. He continued acting on TV through the ’80s and ’90s, starring as a school principal in NBC’s The Bronx Zoo and headlining the ABC sitcom Thunder Alley. Asner didn’t slow down in his later years, either, putting in guest appearances on ER, The X-Files, Curb Your Enthusiasm, The Good Wife and Modern Family.

He had Spunk! Thanks for your talent & your entertainment!

He was also on ABC’s the middle. 2012 The paper Route.

Rest in Peace, Mr. Grant!

One of the best MTM's was the pilot, and he contributed greatly to that. As did Cloris. As did Valerie.

RIP Lou!

Hope MeTV does a marathon.

Other than child actors Lisa Gerritsen and Robbie Rist, am I correct the only regular cast member left is Betty White?

Other than child actors Lisa Gerritsen and Robbie Rist, am I correct the only regular cast member left is Betty White?

John Amos & Joyce Bulifant are still with us.

RIP to a Legendary Man in the Entertainment industry

Hello Everyone,

It's with great sadness yours truly announces that Ed Asner has died at age 91.

Best known for his role of Lou Grant on the hit '70s sitcom "The Mary Tyler Moore Show" and its subsequent '70s drama spin-off, "Lou Grant," Yitzhak Edward "Ed" Asner was born on November 15, 1929 in Kansas City, Missouri and raised in Kansas City, Kansas.

A life-long Jewish man, Ed Asner began his career, per Variety, as a character actor on various films and TV shows such as 2 episodes of the hit '50s CBS Adventure Series "Route 66." He also served as President of Screen Actors Guild from 1981-1985; his Hour-long Drama "Lou Grant" was cancelled by CBS in 1982 not due to poor ratings (contrary to its official announcement by CBS) but because of Ed Asner's liberal politics which at the time CBS (as I like to jokingly call it the original Conservative Bull**** Network before FOX News took that title) hated.

In later years, Ed Asner continued to promote liberal causes close to his heart; his son, Matt, was formerly married to Entertainment reporter Jules Asner, who's since married film director Steven Soderbergh.

He fathered 4 grown children total--including one who had severe Autism, a Mental Illness affecting 1 in 50 kids born in the U.S. alone--an Illness of which I myself live with; he also was a grandfather of a child with Autism.

Late in life, Ed Asner portrayed the protagonist in Disney/Pixar's film "Up!"

Say hello to Mary, Gavin, Ted, and Cloris for me in the afterlife, Ed!

And remember, folks, if you want somebody to be your friend, you've got to be a friend to them. God Speed, Ed Asner!!!

John Amos & Joyce Bulifant are still with us.

John is 81 and Joyce is 83.

Sad to.hear of his passing ! :(I been enjoying watching Lou Grant on Mary Tyler Moore , I recently got Decades on my Spectrum provider ! ;)

Rest in peace , Mr. Grant !

I was just watching The Mary Tyler Moore Show earlier today. He's a fantastic actor and will be sorely missed. It's hard to believe that Betty White is the only major cast member from The Mary Tyler Moore Show still alive. Rest In Peace

:rip:

Ri5SdndWazs

Dave Sundstrom Video Description: Ed Asner died on August 29, 2021. The actor, who starred as Lou Grant on the classic TV shows, "The Mary Tyler Moore Show" and "Lou Grant", was just 91 years old at the time of his passing. Here are my memories of this wonderful actor. Rest in Peace, Ed Asner!


BPZkjOG7eDU

Retro Ontario Video: RIP Edward. In addition to everything else he did, Asner was the spokesperson for Granada TV Rentals. What an alien concept in 2021 eh?


LesYHjlrU4M

Retro Ontario Video: RIP Edward. Here's Ed Asner in a spot for the Will Rogers Institute.


Xrk7eRslwm4

Saturday Morning Rewind Video: The many Voices of Ed Asner (UP / Granny Goodness / Spider-Man / Freakazoid & MORE!)


Variety https://variety.com/2021/tv/news/ed-asner-dead-lou-grant-mary-tyler-moore-1235051373/

https://tvline.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/08/ed-asner-died.jpg?w=620&h=420&crop=1

Seven-time Emmy-winning actor Ed Asner, who starred as Lou Grant on both sitcom “The Mary Tyler Moore Show” and hourlong drama “Lou Grant” before a late-career rejuvenation through his poignant voicework in 2009 animated film “Up,” has died. He was 91.

His publicist confirmed the news to Variety, writing that he died on Sunday surrounded by family. Asner’s official Twitter account posted a message from his family, saying “Goodnight dad. We love you.”

1432034864384000007

Asner had worked for many years as a character actor in series television and movies before hitting paydirt and stardom as the tough-talking TV newsroom head Lou Grant on “The Mary Tyler Moore Show,” which brought him three supporting actor Emmys. When the sitcom called it quits, he returned as the same character in a harder-hitting hourlong series, which earned him two leading actor Emmys and a total of five noms. The actor picked up two additional Emmys for his work on the miniseries “Rich Man, Poor Man” and “Roots,” and won a total of seven.

More recently he appeared on “Grace & Frankie,” “Cobra Kai” and provided voices for “American Dad!”

Within the industry he was respected for his activism on liberal causes that were close to his heart and for his service as Screen Actors Guild president from 1981 to 1985. In recent years he had been vocal in his opposition to the current SAG-AFTRA leadership regime. In December Asner was one of 10 actors who filed a class-action lawsuit against the union over changes made to its health care plan.

“There have been few actors of Ed Asner’s prominence who risked their status to fight for social causes the way Ed did,” said SAG-AFTRA president Gabrielle Carteris. “He fought passionately for his fellow actors, both before, during and after his SAG presidency. But his concern did not stop with performers. He fought for victims of poverty, violence, war, and legal and social injustice, both in the United States and around the globe.”

During his time in office at SAG, Asner was criticized for making political statements about U.S. involvement in El Salvador. His outspokenness may have cost him his $60,000-per-episode salary on newspaper-centered series “Lou Grant,” which CBS controversially cancelled after five seasons, as well as other lucrative offers. He nonetheless continued to criticize the industry’s labor standards and fight for unionism.

Asner also fought a tempestuous battle for the commingling of SAG and the Screen Extras Guild to which there was opposition from within the ranks, most loudly vocalized by actor Charlton Heston, which brought the two thesps to the brink of libel action.

Asner had rarely been active in politics or union activities, but he was vocal during the crippling 1980 SAG strike, the results of which prompted him to run for the office, which he won the next year. His battles included improving the employment and compensation conditions for actors as well as uniting SAG and SEG, which eventually came to pass; he also championed a SAG-AFTRA merger, but changed his view by 2012, when members approved the combination after Asner and other union activists failed to persuade a judge to grant a court order preventing the vote.

But he drew fire with his public pronouncements against U.S. involvement in El Salvador, which many saw as an abuse of his SAG office. While he was president an award to a former SAG president, Ronald Reagan, was rescinded because of the now U.S. president’s dissolution of the air traffic controllers’ union — although Asner himself did not vote on it. He also protested South Africa’s apartheid policies while in office.

Such controversies drew fire from Heston, an avid Reaganite, and a duel began that almost wound up in court. Asner was elected to another two-year term in 1983, winning by a landslide, after which he stepped down in 1985, throwing his support to Patty Duke. He continued to defend his political activism, calling it not a “luxury, but a necessity,” throughout his life.

He remained active in TV movies and miniseries beginning in the mid-’70s, winning Emmys for such blockbusters as “Rich Man, Poor Man” and “Roots.” He also starred in such praised telepics as “A Small Killing,” and “A Case of Libel.” He also made the occasional movie during the ’70s and ’80s such as “Skin Game,” “Fort Apache the Bronx,” “Daniel” and, later, “JFK.”

His 1987 series on ABC, “Bronx Zoo,” was short lived and, at the time, Asner gave voice to concerns that his left-leaning politics were out of favor and possibly costing him work, telling Variety that he knew of a couple of cases in which he’d lost work “but I’m sure that was the tip of the iceberg.” He noted that ABC tested another Asner series, “Off the Rack,” by asking viewers, “What do you know of Ed Asner’s politics and how would it affect your liking the show?” Almost unanimously respondents said they knew nothing of Asner’s beliefs nor did they care.

Asner worked steadily on the bigscreen during the 1990s and 2000s with credits including “Academy Boyz,” “Hard Rain,” “The Bachelor,” “Above Suspicion,” “Elf” and Enchanted Cottage.”

During the same period he regularly popped up on TV. For CBS he recurred on “Hearts Afire” and short-lived series “The Trials of Rosie O’Neill” (drawing a supporting actor Emmy nomination for the latter), was a regular on brief Tom Selleck sitcom “The Closer” in 1998 and appeared as Pop in a 1993 production of “Gypsy” that starred Bette Midler. He also starred in a short-lived ABC sitcom, “Thunder Alley,” reprised the role of Lou Grant in an uncredited role on “Roseanne” and guested on “Dharma and Greg,” “Mad About You,” “The X-Files” and “Curb Your Enthusiasm.”

He also recurred as a judge on “The Practice” and as the chairman of the network’s parent company on “Studio 60 on the Sunset Strip” and had a story arc on “ER” as a curmudgeonly old doctor who runs a storefront clinic.

In 2002 he starred as the pontiff in a movie for Italian television, “Pope John XXIII.”

He received an Emmy nom for supporting actor in a miniseries or movie in 2007 for Hallmark telepic “The Christmas Card” and an Emmy nom for guest actor in a drama series in 2009 for a spot on “CSI: NY.”

In 2011, the actor played Warren Buffett in the HBO telepic “Too Big Too Fail” and recurred on the CMT sitcom “Working Class.”

Asner also spent a great deal of time doing voice work for animated series including “Fish Police,” “Batman,” “Captain Planet and the Planeteers” (he drew a Daytime Emmy nomination), “Gargoyles,” “Freakazoid,” “Spider-Man” (another Daytime Emmy nom), “WordGirl” (a third Daytime Emmy nom) and “The Boondocks” — preparation, perhaps, for his fine voice work on 2009’s “Up,” which won two Oscars, including for best animated feature.

The success of that film spurred interest in Asner, who was a very busy actor in the succeeding years, with roles on “Law & Order: SVU,” “The Middle,” “Hawaii Five-0,” “The Sarah Silverman Program,” “Hot in Cleveland” and “Royal Pains,” to name a few. He also recurred on the brief 2011 CMT laffer “Working Class” and on A&E’s “The Glades” and did voice work on “The Cleveland Show.”

The actor appeared on “The Tonight Show With Jay Leno” in a recurring segment entitled “Does This Impress Ed Asner?”

The youngest of five children, Edward Asner was born in Kansas City. At Wyandotte High School he was all-city tackle and an editor of the school paper.

He spent two years at the U. of Chicago, followed by a stint in the Army. When he returned to Chicago he joined Paul Sills in the Playwrights Theater Group, which became the Compass Players and the Second City Group. He acted in 26 plays with the group over the next two years.

Asner left the troupe in 1955 to move to New York, where he played Peachum in “The Threepenny Opera” at the Theatre de Lys for three years at $65 a week while keeping himself solvent doing odd jobs. He made his Broadway debut in the short-lived “Face of a Hero,” starring Jack Lemmon, and continued to work onstage at the Shakespeare Festival in Stratford and the New York Shakespeare Festival’s Central Park productions before striking out for L.A.

He moved in 1961 to Los Angeles, where he worked on TV series such as “Naked City,” “Slattery’s People,” “The Fugitive” and “Ironside,” settling in to life as a character actor. His film work was also character driven in such films as “Kid Galahad,” “The Satan Bug,” “The Slender Thread,” “El Dorado,” “Gunn” and “Change of Habit” in the 1960s.


A 1970 pilot, “Doug Selby D.A.,” didn’t go anywhere but brought him to the attention of Grant Tinker, who cast him as Lou Grant on “The Mary Tyler Moore Show,” one of his first attempts at comedy. The program ran for seven high-rated seasons and ran in syndication for decades.

Asner received SAG’s Life Achievement Award in 2002, two years after winning the guild’s Ralph Morgan Award. In 2003, he was inducted into the Academy of Television Arts & Sciences Hall of Fame.

In 2013, Asner again took on a prominent role on a SAG-AFTRA controversy, serving as the lead plaintiff in a lawsuit alleging extensive mishandling of $130 million in unpaid residuals and foreign royalties. The suit was dismissed in early 2014 but the federal judge in the case indicated that the plaintiffs might be able to file again.

Asner was twice married, the second time to producer Cindy Gilmore, and twice divorced. He is survived by four children, Matthew, Liza, Kate and Charles.

I'll always remember him as Lou Grant but I loved his voice over work on Gargoyles and Batman TAS and Spiderman.

Ed Asner will always be remembered for the famous line he spoke on the first episode of The Mary Tyler Moore Show "You've got spunk. I hate spunk!" He also had a bit of a temper where in one episode he threw Ted Baxter through the newsroom doors, causing a neck injury.

After MTM ended, he reprised his role in the drama Lou Grant, one of the best journalism dramas in TV history. But the show was abruptly canceled due to Asner's political views on El Salvador. Didn't hurt his career much but he continued to work until his death, including a memorable voiceover role in the Pixar movie Up.

May he rest in peace with his fellow Mary Tyler Moore cast mates. It looks like Betty White is the only regular left.

The title of this thread is correct--Ed Asner is a LEGEND. Ed was truly one-of-a-kind. There will never be another like him. What a profound loss. He was a class act who loved keeping in contact with his fans via mail and social media up until the very end.

He'll never be forgotten. May he RIP.

He was a true TV legend. It's pretty cool that he was following us on Twitter. He was still very active with acting in recent years. RIP Mr. Asner.

https://blog.sitcomsonline.com/2021/08/remembering-legendary-ed-asner-of-mary.html

Ed Asner will always be remembered for the famous line he spoke on the first episode of The Mary Tyler Moore Show "You've got spunk. I hate spunk!" He also had a bit of a temper where in one episode he threw Ted Baxter through the newsroom doors, causing a neck injury.

After MTM ended, he reprised his role in the drama Lou Grant, one of the best journalism dramas in TV history. But the show was abruptly canceled due to Asner's political views on El Salvador. Didn't hurt his career much but he continued to work until his death, including a memorable voiceover role in the Pixar movie Up.

May he rest in peace with his fellow Mary Tyler Moore cast mates. It looks like Betty White is the only regular left.

If he had kept his political views to himself, Lou Grant could have had 2 or 3 more years.

If he had kept his political views to himself, Lou Grant could have had 2 or 3 more years.
More like if he simply hadn't been a knee-jerk anti-American propagandist. The man opposed every effort to defeat the communist threat, signed a petition to allow Ayatollah Khomeini to return to Iran, supported Julius and Ethel Rosenberg even after evidence of their guilt was confirmed, and spewed so-called "9/11 truther" propaganda.


A good actor, but as politically wrong-headed as they come.

He was a true TV legend. It's pretty cool that he was following us on Twitter. He was still very active with acting in recent years. RIP Mr. Asner.

https://blog.sitcomsonline.com/2021/08/remembering-legendary-ed-asner-of-mary.html

Really cool!

More like if he simply hadn't been a knee-jerk anti-American propagandist. The man opposed every effort to defeat the communist threat, signed a petition to allow Ayatollah Khomeini to return to Iran, supported Julius and Ethel Rosenberg even after evidence of their guilt was confirmed, and spewed so-called "9/11 truther" propaganda.


A good actor, but as politically wrong-headed as they come.

He was strong in his convictions, and we all have the right to our political opinions. He and I would not agree, but that does not take away from the fact that he was a wonderful person and actor and will be sorely missed.

I like his Twitter description as "gruff." Boy, that's the Lou Grant we all know and love. AND Ed Asner!

May he rest in peace. He was on a few episodes of Christina Applegate's show, Dead To Me recently on Netflix.

Asner had rarely been active in politics or union activities, but he was vocal during the crippling 1980 SAG strike, the results of which prompted him to run for the office, which he won the next year. His battles included improving the employment and compensation conditions for actors as well as uniting SAG and SEG, which eventually came to pass; he also championed a SAG-AFTRA merger, but changed his view by 2012, when members approved the combination after Asner and other union activists failed to persuade a judge to grant a court order preventing the vote.

But he drew fire with his public pronouncements against U.S. involvement in El Salvador, which many saw as an abuse of his SAG office. While he was president an award to a former SAG president, Ronald Reagan, was rescinded because of the now U.S. president’s dissolution of the air traffic controllers’ union — although Asner himself did not vote on it. He also protested South Africa’s apartheid policies while in office.

Such controversies drew fire from Heston, an avid Reaganite, and a duel began that almost wound up in court. Asner was elected to another two-year term in 1983, winning by a landslide, after which he stepped down in 1985, throwing his support to Patty Duke. He continued to defend his political activism, calling it not a “luxury, but a necessity,” throughout his life.

His 1987 series on ABC, “Bronx Zoo,” was short lived and, at the time, Asner gave voice to concerns that his left-leaning politics were out of favor and possibly costing him work, telling Variety that he knew of a couple of cases in which he’d lost work “but I’m sure that was the tip of the iceberg.” He noted that ABC tested another Asner series, “Off the Rack,” by asking viewers, “What do you know of Ed Asner’s politics and how would it affect your liking the show?” Almost unanimously respondents said they knew nothing of Asner’s beliefs nor did they care.


Yeah, being a far left liberal in Hollywood lost him work...:rotflmao::rotflmao::rotflmao:

He was strong in his convictions, and we all have the right to our political opinions. He and I would not agree, but that does not take away from the fact that he was a wonderful person and actor and will be sorely missed.

I like his Twitter description as "gruff." Boy, that's the Lou Grant we all know and love. AND Ed Asner!

Well, I won't dismiss anything truly good that he did.

From the Wikipedia page on him (Wikilinks and reference links removed);
Asner was on the Entertainment Board of Directors for The Survivor Mitzvah Project, a nonprofit organization dedicated to providing direct emergency aid to elderly and impoverished Holocaust survivors in Eastern Europe. Asner was a member of the Comic Book Legal Defense Fund, a free speech organization that is dedicated to protecting comic book creators and retailers from prosecutions based on content.


*Snip*



Asner also sat on the advisory board for Exceptional Minds, a non-profit school and a computer animation studio for young adults on the autism spectrum.

Asner was a supporter of Humane Borders, an organization based in Tucson, Arizona, which maintains water stations in the Sonoran desert for use by undocumented migrants, with the goal of preventing deaths by dehydration and exposure. He was the master of ceremonies at that organization's volunteer dinner in fall 2017.


https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ed_Asner

Any debate over his political views should be taken to the politics board. This is definitely not the place for it.

TV Insider https://www.tvinsider.com/1011330/ed-asner-tv-episodes-marathon-metv-decades-mary-tyler-moore-show/

MeTV and Decades are paying tribute to a TV legend as they honor the late great Ed Asner with special programming slates.

Kicking off Friday, September 3 on Decades, viewers can tune in for a special presentation of a rarely-seen interview with Asner on The Dick Cavett Show during which he discussed Lou Grant and his life before Hollywood. The following day on September 4, Decades invites viewers to enjoy a weekend binge of 84 episodes from The Mary Tyler Moore Show library spanning through Sunday.

https://www.tvinsider.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/08/mary-tyler-moore-show-cast-830x570.jpg

Meanwhile, beginning September 5 on MeTV, viewers can tune in for four episodes of The Mary Tyler Moore Show as well as a special episode of The Alfred Hitchcock Hour starring Asner. Below, see the full breakdown of times, episodes, and more for “Decades TV Network Remembers Ed Asner” and “MeTV Celebrates Ed Asner.”

DECADES

Friday, September 3

9/8c – The Dick Cavett Show featuring a 1980 interview with Ed Asner

Saturday, September 4

12/11c – #DECADESWeekendBinge of 84 episodes of The Mary Tyler Moore Show, airing thru Monday, September 6th at 6am ET


MeTV

Sunday, September 5

2pm ET/PT – The Mary Tyler Moore Show – “Love Is All Around”

2:30pm ET/PT – The Mary Tyler Moore Show – “Once I Had a Secret Love”

3pm ET/PT – The Mary Tyler Moore Show – “Lou Dates Mary”

3:30pm ET/PT – The Mary Tyler Moore Show – “The Last Show”

1am ET/PT – The Alfred Hitchcock Hour – “To Catch a Butterfly”


shA_TsV-PFs

FoundationINTERVIEWS: Ed Asner on the "Mary Tyler Moore" cast...EMMYTVLEGENDS.ORG

It's great MeTV is showing the pilot (Love is All Around). It's rare that a TV pilot is a great episode but this one is. Cloris and Ed are really outstanding!

When Bess blurts out something Phyllis (Cloris) wanted to say, Phyllis gets this priceless look on her face: "That was mother's news."

Of course with Ed there's the famous spunk line, and later watch Lou trying to type after a trip to the local bar.

On the final show there's a classic scene at the end, with a classic song sung in farewell. And it would be great to see the curtain call, not normally seen in syndication--we'll see!

Great tribute to Ed--thanks MeTV!

We are losing so many beloved celebrities from the past. Prayers to the loved ones. RIP

TV Insider https://www.tvinsider.com/1011330/ed-asner-tv-episodes-marathon-metv-decades-mary-tyler-moore-show/

MeTV and Decades are paying tribute to a TV legend as they honor the late great Ed Asner with special programming slates.

Kicking off Friday, September 3 on Decades, viewers can tune in for a special presentation of a rarely-seen interview with Asner on The Dick Cavett Show during which he discussed Lou Grant and his life before Hollywood. The following day on September 4, Decades invites viewers to enjoy a weekend binge of 84 episodes from The Mary Tyler Moore Show library spanning through Sunday.

https://www.tvinsider.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/08/mary-tyler-moore-show-cast-830x570.jpg

Meanwhile, beginning September 5 on MeTV, viewers can tune in for four episodes of The Mary Tyler Moore Show as well as a special episode of The Alfred Hitchcock Hour starring Asner. Below, see the full breakdown of times, episodes, and more for “Decades TV Network Remembers Ed Asner” and “MeTV Celebrates Ed Asner.”

DECADES

Friday, September 3

9/8c – The Dick Cavett Show featuring a 1980 interview with Ed Asner

Saturday, September 4

12/11c – #DECADESWeekendBinge of 84 episodes of The Mary Tyler Moore Show, airing thru Monday, September 6th at 6am ET


MeTV

Sunday, September 5

2pm ET/PT – The Mary Tyler Moore Show – “Love Is All Around”

2:30pm ET/PT – The Mary Tyler Moore Show – “Once I Had a Secret Love”

3pm ET/PT – The Mary Tyler Moore Show – “Lou Dates Mary”

3:30pm ET/PT – The Mary Tyler Moore Show – “The Last Show”

1am ET/PT – The Alfred Hitchcock Hour – “To Catch a Butterfly”


shA_TsV-PFs

FoundationINTERVIEWS: Ed Asner on the "Mary Tyler Moore" cast...EMMYTVLEGENDS.ORG


It's so sad when you realize that everyone in that photo is no longer with us and half of them passed away this year. :(


R.I.P. Ed Asner

That photo is really a keeper. What a great cast!

Sad loss, may he rest in peace :rip:

R.I.P.

Sort of interesting that he was so left wing, and he was beyond liberal, yet his most famous character and other characters he comes across as someone who would have told the hippies to get off his lawn with a shotgun and would call you a pansy who needed a job or join the Army. That type. But his politics were so stridently leftist.