If Scott Baio was matched up against Willie Aames in Fox's Celebrity Boxing, who do you think would win? What about Scott vs Kirk Cameron?

I think Scott would take out Willie and Phillip pretty easy. While I love Scott, I think Kirk would punch him out in the first round. Sorry Scott.

If it was a free for all fight (like the Ultimate Fighting Champion matches) with all 4 in the ring at once I would bet on Kirk. He had the height advantage that would give him reach. He also had more upper body strength, even his legs were like tree trunks.

In individual matches:

Phillip Vs Willie = Phillip Willie Vs Scott = Scott
Phillip Vs Scott = Scott Willie Vs Kirk = Kirk
Phillip Vs Kirk = Kirk

Scott Vs Kirk = Kirk

Did I miss any options?

This reminds me of Sienfeld when Jerry and George debated on who would win in a fight - Batman or Superman?

I agree with the consensus that Kirk would win against all 3. Scott would win against the other 2.

If the fight was boxing, either Kirk or Scott would win - probably Kirk.

If the fight was karate or kick boxing, either Kirk or Phillip would win - probably Kirk.

If it was wrestling, Kirk or Willie would win - probably Kirk.......

So I voted for Kirk

I met Phillip McKeon at a charity softball game a few years back. He is a pretty big guy. He was always tall, but now he's not scrawny anymore. I wouldn't want to fight him. I voted for him. It would be either him or Kirk.

I had to vote for Scott, even though I adore Kirk. After all, Scott played Chachi Arcola, Fonzie's little cousin on Happy Days. Fonzie was a legend-- he could have won any fight hands down. So, I'm basing my decision on that.

Fonzie:..."Aaaayyhhhh!"

I can't believe Kirk Cameron beat up my Scott Baio. We'll I'll have to nurse poor Scott back to health.

I think it would come down to Scott or Kirk. I think Kirk would win. I'd pay to see the fight.

I picked Scott Baio... He would take them all out!

Assuming this fight was in the 80’s, Kirk would win in individual fights against each of the others.

What about if it was in the 80’s?