View Full Version : TVs actors you didn't like in one role but liked in another--and vice versa


dee2364
10-12-2020, 04:15 PM
I know this is sacrilegious but I never liked Audrey Meadows as Alice in The Honeymooners. As much of a pompous blowhard Ralph was and deserved to be put down, I never sided with Alice because I thought Meadows played Alice a little bit too cocky, judgmental and snide. Worst of all, she came across as cold to me. Trixie would always yell at Ed but you could sense that she was a fun loving girl who probably enjoyed going out with him and having a lot of laughs when he wasn't being frustrating because Joyce Randolph gave off a a feeling of warmth. Audrey Meadows not so much.

On the other hand, I loved her on Too Close for Comfort. She was a perfect foil for Henry (Ted Knight) even though she was playing more or less the same type of role. On that show, she would put down Henry but I never felt like she was vicious or arrogant.

Torgo
10-12-2020, 04:23 PM
Loved Kevin James as Doug on King Of Queens, disliked him as Kevin on Kevin Can Wait.

icecream
10-12-2020, 06:35 PM
Thomas Haden Church
like- Wings
dislike- Ned and Stacey

Julia Louis-Dreyfus
like- Seinfeld
dislike- The New Adventures of Old Christine

Soleil Moon Frye
like- Punky Brewster
dislike- Sabrina the Teenage Witch

Craig T. Nelson
like- Coach, The District, Monk
dislike- Parenthood

Lauren Graham
like- Gilmore Girls, Zoey's Extraordinary Playlist
dislike- Parenthood

Jessica Biel
like- 7th Heaven
dislike- The Sinner

Cloris Leachman
like- Raising Hope
dislike- The Facts of Life

Katey Sagal
like- 8 Simple Rules for Dating my Teenage Daughter
dislike- Married with Children

Sally Struthers
like- Gilmore Girls
dislike- All in the Family

Dianne Wiest
like- Life in Pieces
dislike- Law and Order

Vincent DoNofrio
like- Law and Order: Criminal Intent
dislike- Emerald City

Matt Leblanc
like- Man With a Plan
dislike- Friends

Jane Leeves
like- Frasier
dislike- Hot in Cleveland

Elinor Donahue
like- The Andy Griffith Show
dislike- Father Knows Best

Steven Weber
like- Wings
dislike- Without a Trace

Amber Tamblyn
like- Joan of Arcadia, Without a Trace
dislike- The Unusuals

Brad Garrett
like- Everybody Loves Raymond, Seinfeld
dislike- Single Parents, Til Death

Robin Williams
like- Mork and Mindy
dislike- The Crazy Ones

Michael J. Fox
like- Family Ties, Designated Survivor
dislike- The Michael J. Fox Show

Jerry Van Dyke
like- Coach, The Middle
dislike- My Mother the Car

Tony Shalhoub
like- Wings, Monk, BrainDead
dislike- We Are Men

Poppy Montgomery
like- Without a Trace, Reef Break
dislike- Unforgettable

Kurtwood Smith
like- Resurrection
dislike- That 70s Show

Lucy Hale
like- Privileged
dislike- Pretty Little Liars

Renee Olstead
like- Still Standing
dislike- The Secret Life of the American Teenager

Delta Burke
like- DAG, Touched by an Angel
dislike- Designing Women

Beth Behrs
like- The Neighborhood
dislike- 2 Broke Girls

Melissa Joan Hart
like- Sabrina the Teenage Witch
dislike- Melissa and Joey

Jake McDorman
like- Limitless
dislike- Murphy Brown revival

Will Estes
like- Blue Bloods
dislike- 7th Heaven

70s show watcher
10-13-2020, 05:13 AM
howard hessman liked wkrp disliked one day at a time he played a real loser on that show

dee2364
10-13-2020, 10:50 AM
@catsrule: Wow, that's an impressive list! Can you share a reason that made you flip on one of these actors, like the other posters? I'm curious!

dee2364
10-13-2020, 10:53 AM
howard hessman liked wkrp disliked one day at a time he played a real loser on that show

I didn't care for him on Head of the Class, either, even though I loved him on WKRP.

icecream
10-13-2020, 01:48 PM
@catsrule: Wow, that's an impressive list! Can you share a reason that made you flip on one of these actors, like the other posters? I'm curious!A lot of the examples I gave I like the one show, but have never cared for the other show. For Soleil Moon Frye, I had never seen Punky Brewster until Peacock launched this year, instantly became a fan. Sabrina I like the high school/ABC era a lot more than the college/WB era. Roxie, Morgan, and the guy who lived with them and Sabrina were a lot less likable than Jenny, Valerie, and Libby. (Libby was mean but that part was acted well.) The Facts of Life was a good show its first seven seasons when Charlotte Rae was the star. But Cloris Leachman was a poor replacement when Charlotte left, the girls were old enough to be on their own then with Blair and Jo all grown. Her senile grandma character on Raising Hope was played really well though. I am a Without a Trace fan, but Steven Weber's character was someone who had it in for Jack Malone. Fortunately that arc didn't last long. Dianne Wiest was funny on Life in Pieces, but unlikable on Law and Order. Fred Dalton Thompson and Steven Hill I much preferred in the DA role there. Will Estes's 7th Heaven role was not someone I cared for. But he is integral to Blue Bloods.

Edward216
10-13-2020, 11:20 PM
I've never liked actress Nancy Travis on any sitcom I've seen her in. Except I like her as Vanessa on Last Man Standing, I actually think she's got good chemistry with Tim Allen who plays her husband Mike on the show. I can't explain it, maybe it's the writing and the character I don't know. Because other than Last Man Standing I've always thought she was annoying and uninteresting in anything else I've seen her in.

Ed.

bmasters9
10-14-2020, 05:52 PM
Bob Newhart:

Love: The Bob Newhart Show (1972-78)
Dislike: Newhart (1982-90)

RetroGuy2000
10-14-2020, 06:20 PM
The Facts of Life was a good show its first seven seasons when Charlotte Rae was the star. But Cloris Leachman was a poor replacement when Charlotte left, the girls were old enough to be on their own then with Blair and Jo all grown.

YES.


Also, here are my likes/dislikes:

Nicholas Brendon - loved him on Buffy as Xander; hated him as Kevin Lynch on Criminal Minds.

Courteney Cox - loved her as Monica on Friends, disliked her as New Girlfriend on Family Ties (she couldn't hold a candle to Ellen).

icecream
10-24-2020, 08:22 PM
Judith Light
like- Who's the Boss?
dislike- Manhunt: Deadly Games- what an awful mother she plays here :eek:

favoriteshow
10-25-2020, 03:14 PM
Sarah Chalke
like-Scrubs
dislike-Becky #2 on Roseanne

Judy Reyes
like-Scrubs
dislike-Claws (TNT). Actually I didn't give that show much chance, but didn't have a positive impression of the silent character she portrays.

icecream
11-19-2020, 02:38 PM
Peggy Rea
like- Grace Under Fire
dislike- The Waltons. Rose replacing Olivia is when The Waltons started to jump the shark.

AMackII
11-19-2020, 02:46 PM
Bob Newhart:

Love: The Bob Newhart Show (1972-78)
Dislike: Newhart (1982-90)

In my opinion, I think Bob Newhart was great in both The Bob Newhart Show & Newhart than he was in Bob & George and Leo

Willbo
11-19-2020, 03:28 PM
I loved Bob Newhart on both of his shows but especially Newhart.

cnnbcbs
11-20-2020, 11:36 PM
I loved Bob Newhart on both of his shows but especially Newhart.

Couldn't get into Bob, but I thought his chemistry with Judd Hirsch in George snd Leo was superb

Neil Patrick Harris
Like: Doogie Howser MD, Stark Raving Mad
Dislike: How I Met Your Mother

Fred Savage
Dislike: Wonder Years
Like: The Grinder

Katey Segal
like: Superior Donuts
Dislike: everything else

icecream
01-06-2021, 03:03 PM
Keiko Agena
like- Gilmore Girls
dislike- Prodigal Son- This show is otherwise well cast, but she is way out of place here.

cnnbcbs
01-06-2021, 03:44 PM
Patricia Heaton
Liked: Carol's Second Act
Disliked: everything else.

GentlemanJim
01-06-2021, 03:49 PM
Amanda Bearse

Loved: Jean Haywood-Hotel
Loathed: everything else

icecream
01-24-2021, 08:08 PM
Dick Sargent
like- Family Ties guest appearance
dislike- Bewitched

AMackII
01-24-2021, 08:21 PM
Malcolm Jamal Warner

Like: The Cosby Show
Loath: Reed Between The Lines & The Resident

Christopher
01-24-2021, 08:26 PM
Marcia Cross - Love her on Melrose Place and Desperate Housewives. She gets to show off her acting abilities in these shows. Everwood and Quantico she was boring.

Bea Arthur - Love her on Maude. She was perfect. I can't stand her on The Golden Girls. She was too mean and a lot of times it was unnecessary.

Betty White - Like her on Mama's Family and Hot in Cleveland. I don't care for her overrated character on The Golden Girls. She was too stupid a lot of times.

Christina Applegate - Up All Night is the only show of hers I didn't like. It wasn't funny. Everything else she did was great.

Tiffani Amber Thiessen - I like her in 90210. I hate Saved By The Bell.

Shannen Doherty - I like her on Charmed. I didn't like her on 90210.

Christopher Meloni - Love him on SVU and Oz. I didn't care for him on his short lived shows after he left SVU.

Zoneboy
01-25-2021, 04:22 AM
Bill Cosby:

Like - I Spy, Fat Albert And The Cosby Kids.
Dislike - The Cosby Show

Ed O'Neill:

Like - Married, With Children
Dislike - Modern Family

William Shatner:

Like - Star Trek, TJ Hooker, Barbary Coast
Dislike - **** My Dad Says, TekWar

Lee Majors:

Like - The Six Million Dollar Man, The Big Valley, The Fall Guy
Dislike - The Raven

Michael Landon:

Like - Bonanza, Little House on The Prairie, Highway to Heaven
Dislike -

Bernie Kopell:

Like - Get Smart, When Things Were Rotten
Dislike - The Love Boat

Robert Urich:

Like - S.W.A.T, Vegas$, Soap
Dislike - Love Boat, the Next Wave, Spenser: for Hire

Bill Bixby:

Like - My Favorite Martian, The Incredible Hulk, The Magician, The Courtship of Eddie's Father
Dislike - Goodnight Beantown

Dick Van Dyke:

Like - Diagnosis, Murder
Dislike - The Dick Van Dyke Show

Andy Griffith:

Like - The Andy Griffith Show, Salvage 1, Matlock
Dislike -

Eddie Albert:

Like - Green Acres
Dislike - Switch

Tom Bosley:

Like - Happy Days, Wait Till Your Father Gets Home, Murder, She Wrote
Dislike - Father Dowling Mysteries

Larry Hagman:

Like - Dallas
Dislike - I Dream of Jeannie

Patrick Duffy:

Like - Dallas, The Man from Atlantis
Dislike - Step By Step

Conrad Bain:

Like - Maude
Dislike - Diff'rent Strokes

icecream
01-29-2021, 04:45 PM
Kylie Bunbury
like- Big Sky. Not much new has premiered on the scripted side this season. But Big Sky is worth watching.
dislike- Pitch, Under the Dome. Pitch was such a mediocre show, ridiculous how many writers and commenters at TVLine wanted a remake of it. Under the Dome was great the first two seasons. But the writers destroyed it in season 3 with Kylie and Marg Helgenberger's additions.

Meilleur
02-16-2021, 09:34 AM
Here are a few more:

Nia Long
Like: The Fresh Prince of Bel Air, Third Watch
Dislike: NCIS: Los Angeles


Nancy McKeon
Like: The Division
Dislike: The Facts of Life


Cloris Leachman
Like: The Facts of Life
Dislike: Lassie


Molly Ringwald
Like: The Facts of Life, Townies
Dislike: Secret Life of The American Teenager, Riverdale


Courtney Thorne-Smith
Like: Melrose Place, According To Jim
Dislike: Ally McBeal, Two and a Half Men


Katey Sagal
Like: 8 Simple Rules
Dislike: Married With Children, Sons of Anarchy



Taraji Henson
Like: Person of Interest
Dislike: Empire


Don Knotts
Like: The Andy Griffith Show
Dislike: Three's Company


Kylie Travis
Like: Central Park West (CPW)
Dislike: Models Inc.


Meredith MacRae
Like: My Three Sons
Dislike: Petticoat Junction


Brandy Norwood
Like: Moesha
Dislike: The Game


Wendie Malick
Like: Hot in Cleveland
Dislike: Baywatch, Dream On, Just Shoot Me

icecream
02-26-2021, 12:18 AM
James Roday
like- Psych
dislike- A Million Little Things

icecream
03-24-2021, 09:25 AM
Kaley Cuoco
like- The Big Bang Theory
dislike- 8 Simple Rules for Dating my Teenage Daughter

AntennaTV2020
03-31-2021, 06:20 PM
Alphonso Ribiero:

Like: The Fresh Prince of Bel Air
Dislike: Silver Spoons

icecream
03-31-2021, 10:43 PM
Melissa Peterman
like- Young Sheldon, Working Class
dislike- Reba, a little bit of Barbara Jean goes a long way.

icecream
06-05-2021, 02:38 PM
Sherman Hensley
like- The Jeffersons
dislike- Amen

principehomura
06-05-2021, 03:27 PM
Lisa Kudrow
Loved her as Phoebe (Friends), disliked her as Ursula (Mad About You)

icecream
06-06-2021, 04:35 PM
Kearran Giovanni
like- Major Crimes
dislike- All Rise

Sal
06-06-2021, 04:47 PM
Betty White

Like: Mary Tyler Moore Show, Golden Girls
Dislike: Everything she's done since.

Sally Field

Like: Gidget, The Flying Nun
Dislike: Her movies.

Bill Cosby

Like: The Cosby Show
Dislike: Cosby, You Bet Your Life

Ed O'Neill

Like: Married With Children
Dislike: Modern Family

Ron Howard

Like: Happy Days, The Andy Griffith Show
Dislike: Arrested Development

Bea Arthur

Like: The Golden Girls
Dislike: Maude

Don Adams

Like: Get Smart, Tennessee Tuxedo
Dislike: Check It Out, Inspector Gadget

Annie Potts

Like: Young Sheldon
Dislike: Designing Women

Bryan Cranston

Like: Malcolm In The Middle
Dislike: Breaking Bad

icecream
06-06-2021, 04:59 PM
Sally Field

Like: Gidget, The Flying Nun
Dislike: Her movies.
Even if you think most of her movies are lousy, I recommend Norma Rae. Sally was really good in her leading role here.

Sal
06-06-2021, 07:35 PM
Even if you think most of her movies are lousy, I recommend Norma Rae. Sally was really good in her leading role here.

I saw Norma Rae and I didn't like it.

Edward216
06-06-2021, 09:41 PM
I liked David Ogden Stiers in M.A.S.H. as Major Charles Winchester. But I've absolutely hated him in everything else I've ever watched him in. And that's saying something because I'm sure I haven't seen every movie or TV show he ever did.

Ed.

icecream
06-06-2021, 10:47 PM
I liked David Ogden Stiers in M.A.S.H. as Major Charles Winchester. But I've absolutely hated him in everything else I've ever watched him in. And that's saying something because I'm sure I haven't seen every movie or TV show he ever did.

Ed.Have you seen his Wings guest appearance? That was pretty funny.

Edward216
06-07-2021, 03:23 PM
Have you seen his Wings guest appearance? That was pretty funny.

No, I haven't seen that one. His guest starring role in an episode of Star Trek: The Next Generation, while it wasn't terrible, was just OK. He played an alien scientist who came aboard the Enterprise to conduct an experiment he hopes will save his home planet. In a bit of a tribute to his work on M.A.S.H., there's a blink and you'll miss it moment where a shot of a computer screen is shown with a bunch of text, and in part of a code on the screen is the number 4077. Which as we all know was the number of the M.A.S.H. unit on the series.

Ed.

icecream
06-28-2021, 09:47 PM
Bill Cosby
Like: The Cosby Show
Dislike: Cosby, You Bet Your Life
What about The Bill Cosby Show and I Spy? It would be nice if Bill Cosby was one of the new sitcoms coming to Antenna TV in September. But with his image being forever tainted now, they probably don't think the ratings would be worth it.

AMackII
06-29-2021, 03:30 AM
Patrick Duffy
Like: Dallas(Original) & Step By Step
Dislike: The Bold and The Beautiful

Joan Van Ark
Like: Knots Landing
Dislike: The Young and The Restless

Kelsey Grammer
Like: Cheers & Frasier
Dislike: Boss

icecream
07-25-2021, 11:04 PM
Tim Conway
like- Coach
dislike- McHale's Navy

Gavin MacLeod
like- The Love Boat, The Mary Tyler Moore Show
dislike- McHale's Navy

icecream
07-26-2021, 05:47 PM
Kim Fields
like- The Facts of Life
dislike- Living Single