I finished watching season 3 for the first time since it originally aired a couple of days ago. I can't figure out why this season got so much hate from fans at the time. I really liked it and wish they had kept Erica around for season 4, but the writers seemed intent on keeping Gary heartbroken forever.

Season 3 is my favorite. While every season was good, 4 lost something when Erica and Henry left.

What's your favorite episode?