The episode where Muffy first appeared as a contestant on The Chase is now. I had seen her comeback appearance in the season 4 premiere, but hadn't seen this episode in awhile. It is episode 3 of season 3, with the description on my guide saying A national puzzle league and an internet trivia league. Muffy of course after her Chase episodes as a contestant went on to become one of the experts on more recent GSN originals Best Ever Trivia Show and Master Minds.

Muffy didn't even make it to the final chase. That might be why I didn't remember this episode much.

I DO remember this episode of The Chase because that was the first time I saw Muffy and she was a great player and although she didn't make it to the Final Chase the first time she came back for a second chance on The Chase and won that time. Muffy also appeared on Who Wants To Be A Millionaire with Chris Harrison where she also was amazing. If Muffy keeps this amazing game show talent up she will be a female Ken Jennings
Bestie

Who the hell is Muffy?

She was on a show called Master Minds with Ken Jennings and another quizzster and sadly Ken was so good she would be left in the dust. I like Muffy ? Marrocco and wished Ken would go and she could shine on Master Minds.

O.K., thanks. I watched the show a few times a couple months ago on GSN.