Just watched the segment with Todd Kelley, and Christie Mutzfield. What other love triangle cases were featured on UM?

Just watched the segment with Todd Kelley, and Christie Mutzfield. What other love triangle cases were featured on UM?
Ann Sigman
Sammy Wheeler

Larry Costine/Melissa Jo Sermons

Larry Costine/Melissa Jo Sermons

Never seen this one. Is this on the forbidden site?

Never seen this one. Is this on the forbidden site?

I was also curious...Amazon ep. guide says season 6 episode 10

I was also curious...Amazon ep. guide says season 6 episode 10

Awesome. Thanks alot, Jon!

You could argue that Eric Tamiyasu was in a love triangle, I suppose...

You could argue that Eric Tamiyasu was in a love triangle, I suppose...

Most definitely. I feel like there was a couple of love triangles going on there. Granted the sheriff didn't think so :rolleyes:

Never seen this one. Is this on the forbidden site?

It's presented as more of a missing persons segment with the theory that Jo murdered Larry and then took of (because she was missing at the time), but her family was insistent that she would have never done that. They don't name names, but heavily imply that an ex-boyfriend was involved (and it turns out, he was).

It's presented as more of a missing persons segment with the theory that Jo murdered Larry and then took of (because she was missing at the time), but her family was insistent that she would have never done that. They don't name names, but heavily imply that an ex-boyfriend was involved (and it turns out, he was).

Yeah, I just watched it. I actually seen this before but didn't recall the names. Thanks

Just watched the segment with Todd Kelley, and Christie Mutzfield. What other love triangle cases were featured on UM?

I have watched that one a few times and I feel bad for Christie. Todd's parents would not let her attend the funeral over speculations around Todd's death. I did like how the sheriff came to her defense and said, nope, speculation!

Another love triangle was in Nebraska (I think) and it involved the police chief and two women, one who was slightly physically disabled. Anyone remember that one?

Another love triangle was in Nebraska (I think) and it involved the police chief and two women, one who was slightly physically disabled. Anyone remember that one?
Anna Anton and Greg Webb. https://unsolvedmysteries.fandom.com/wiki/Greg_Webb

Anna the super religious barfly is a fascinating character.

I have watched that one a few times and I feel bad for Christie. Todd's parents would not let her attend the funeral over speculations around Todd's death. I did like how the sheriff came to her defense and said, nope, speculation!

Another love triangle was in Nebraska (I think) and it involved the police chief and two women, one who was slightly physically disabled. Anyone remember that one?

While I don't think Christie killed Todd, I don't blame his parents. Her story was inconsistent and I believe she was present at the murder, and probably even help cleaned the crime scene. Granted, this all could've been out of fear but I don't blame his parents for thinking that she was holding back information.

I think she went back the next day to call the authorities because she knew he was dead, but wanted to make it seem like a surprise.

While I don't think Christie killed Todd, I don't blame his parents. Her story was inconsistent and I believe she was present at the murder, and probably even help cleaned the crime scene. Granted, this all could've been out of fear but I don't blame his parents for thinking that she was holding back information.

I think she went back the next day to call the authorities because she knew he was dead, but wanted to make it seem like a surprise.

Huq was definitely responsible for the murder, but I have always had trouble believing her account of the events as well (this is from the unsolved.com):

Christie says she dropped Todd back at his house right around 3 a.m. The coroner determined that he was murdered just 15 minutes later. At 4:30 a.m., Mahfuz called Christie from his parentsÂ’ house, 10 miles away. Two hours later, he showed up in her bedroom. According to Christie, she broke off their relationship for good, not knowing what he had done.

It seems much more likely that she was there the whole time, than all the zipping back and forth in the early morning hours. At the very least she saw what happened.

The Circleville letters case. A love triangle brought that on.

Huq was definitely responsible for the murder, but I have always had trouble believing her account of the events as well (this is from the unsolved.com):

Christie says she dropped Todd back at his house right around 3 a.m. The coroner determined that he was murdered just 15 minutes later. At 4:30 a.m., Mahfuz called Christie from his parentsÂ’ house, 10 miles away. Two hours later, he showed up in her bedroom. According to Christie, she broke off their relationship for good, not knowing what he had done.

It seems much more likely that she was there the whole time, than all the zipping back and forth in the early morning hours. At the very least she saw what happened.

Exactly, but the main thing that tells me she is lying is:

"It was getting kind of late, and I told him I had to go home, ’cause I hadn’t really been home in quite a while, and I knew my father would be upset, so we left. He said he was going to stay up all night and he wanted to get something to drink. Christie says that at 2:30 a.m., she and Todd drove into town"

What sense does it make to go home at 2 in the morning because your father would be upset that you haven't been home in a while? I'm assuming he'd be sleep by the time you walked in. It would've made sense just to spend the night and go home in the mor.......wait, I'm sure that was her plan until Mahfuz came and murdered Todd.

She was definitely lying

While I don't think Christie killed Todd, I don't blame his parents. Her story was inconsistent and I believe she was present at the murder, and probably even help cleaned the crime scene. Granted, this all could've been out of fear but I don't blame his parents for thinking that she was holding back information.

I think she went back the next day to call the authorities because she knew he was dead, but wanted to make it seem like a surprise.

Interesting thoughts!!

One more thought about Todd Kelly’s murder: I used to think Christie Mutzfield’s motives were more sinister (putting the two men against each other and so forth), but the last time I watched it I came away with the impression that wasn’t actually the case.

It seems more likely that if she helped Huq in any way, it was because she was under duress. If she was there, she saw this psychopath murder her lover right in front of her, which is a really ****ed up thing the live through, it’s understandable that she would help him out of fear for her own life.

Of course that means she lied, but had she told the truth it would have had no effect on justice in this case because everyone knew it was Huq from the beginning. That said, I do understand Todd’s family’s reaction to her

If it's theorized Brad Bishop disappeared with a woman after abandoning his car would that be considered a love triangle?

Michael Johnston and Rochelle Robinson.

Larry Costine/Melissa Jo Sermons

Caught this on my UM binge today on Pluto TV.

Michael Johnston and Rochelle Robinson.

Ooh, good catch. I wish they'd solve that one!

The ghost in the shower in the Woods' home 😄👻

Anna Anton and Greg Webb. https://unsolvedmysteries.fandom.com/wiki/Greg_Webb

Anna the super religious barfly is a fascinating character.

While it turns out that Anna had some layers to her that weren't discovered until much later, the main point of her story was still rather tragic. In order to avoid being murdered by her psycho drug dealing husband, she moves all the way to a Podunk town in the middle of nowhere....only to be murdered by a new love.

Although I was kind of amused by how the mayor of Lyons said at the beginning of the segment how nobody moves to Lyons. Just the fact that an outsider moving to her town was enough to immediately set off some red flags.