Sorry if this had been touched on, but I read on fb that Beverly Noe was released from prison already . After murdering 3 women ?!
Wendy Camps sister has a fb page that she updates. The page also had a picture of the skeletal remains which was so sad. I do believe I have seen it before.
She also replied to a question about how Wendy’s son felt about his mother and such (she was murdered sometime after seeing him or attempting to).... Wendy’s sister said he is in denial and doesn’t believe his family murdered his mom even though her remains were found on the family property. She also said he is a bedridden drug addict.
This case just never seemed to get its justice. Wendy’s ex husband got off and his grandma got out the easy way. What a messy bunch of people !
Anyways Here is the fb link https://m.facebook.com/RememberingWendyCamp/posts/?ref=page_internal&mt_nav=0

Sorry if this had been touched on, but I read on fb that Beverly Noe was released from prison already . After murdering 3 women ?!
Wendy Camps sister has a fb page that she updates. The page also had a picture of the skeletal remains which was so sad. I do believe I have seen it before.
She also replied to a question about how Wendy’s son felt about his mother and such (she was murdered sometime after seeing him or attempting to).... Wendy’s sister said he is in denial and doesn’t believe his family murdered his mom even though her remains were found on the family property. She also said he is a bedridden drug addict.
This case just never seemed to get its justice. Wendy’s ex husband got off and his grandma got out the easy way. What a messy bunch of people !
Anyways Here is the fb link https://m.facebook.com/RememberingWendyCamp/posts/?ref=page_internal&mt_nav=0

It is extremely troubling that she is already out of prison. These victims suffered very brutal deaths. So Chad Noe was never charged? This whole family is pure evil.

You have got to be joking!

Where's the justice in that? :(

It is extremely troubling that she is already out of prison. These victims suffered very brutal deaths. So Chad Noe was never charged? This whole family is pure evil.

No he was never charged . He also is on Facebook and he trolls the sister of Wendy camp . He also brags about being on U.M. And how his family killed his ex ..... arrogant and I know he set them up. Wendy had all those broken bones and was tied up, stabbed and shot. He had to help kill them and most def move the bodies.

I hope it's a compassionate release because Grandmother Noe has an incurable fatal rot somewhere....

Here is a tidbit - Max Cook the DA involved in the Beverly Noe plea deal and release, once vouched for character of Judge Donald Thompson the penis lump judge. Cook declined to investigate Thompson.

No he was never charged . He also is on Facebook and he trolls the sister of Wendy camp . He also brags about being on U.M. And how his family killed his ex ..... arrogant and I know he set them up. Wendy had all those broken bones and was tied up, stabbed and shot. He had to help kill them and most def move the bodies.

What a [CENSORED] douche.

Last night I sat in bed drafting a damning speech in a private message to Chad (we’re not friends obviously, so would have gone to his “other” inbox or whatever), but I wasn’t gutsy enough to hit send. Has anyone here reached out to him? Just curious

This has to be one of the most infuriating cases ever because very little justice has been served. It was pretty obvious from the get go that Ida and Beverly murdered the three women. The "we dropped them off at Walmart" story never made any sense for a second.

The fact that they killed them, buried them, walked over them for years is beyond disgusting. Chad's a free man, Ida never faced any justice, and yeah Beverly finally got sent to prison but she did 5 years. 5 years of prison for everything they did is just a travesty.

I remember this case well the mother they killed was disabled that really burned me up. They all lied right into the camera yet all the signs pointed to them doing it. What a senseless deaths. It's sad to fathom that someone you could be in a relationship with lay up with every night and conceive a child with could do something like this to you. This is why I am content being single because who you love/like could get you killed. RIP to those lost lives.

I just looked up the recent updates on this case and I can't believe she got off after 5 years. That is unbelievable to me.

She murdered 3 people, including a child, and got away with it for two decades and she ends up serving less time than the amount of time it took to find the bodies? Unreal. Simply unreal. She should have died in prison.

So Chad got away with it and his mom got about as close to a slap on the wrist as you can get for being convicted for murder. Ida at least got cancer, so nature/God/Karma got her good.

I don't know what it is about this family how they continue to do so many horrible things and then serve such short stints in prison.

Ida and her other daughter Deborah were arrested for the murder of Deborah's husband in 1980. He was found in his car in the garage shot and stabbed to death. (A coincidence that another person who married into that family ended up being horrifically murdered?). But both were released in 1983.

Beverly and Ida were arrested for arson around 2007 but were released before you could blink twice.

And now this? A triple homicide which included a little girl who Beverly justified killing as "damaged goods." The minimum sentence for Beverly was 15 years.

Does this family have connections to powerful people in the state of Oklahoma? I know that sounds silly to ask because they basically come across as hillbillies but there has to be a reason why they keep getting released after doing such horrific things. I mean, they could have arrested Beverly long before the bodies were found. I think other murderes have been convicted on less evidence.

The news that Jonathan is a bedridden drug addict now breaks my heart. Sadly, I think his fate down such a dark road was already sealed after having been raised by Beverly. You can't grow up being exposed to that kind of crazy every day and not have it severely damage you. Look at the pathetic mess Chad turned out to be as another example.

Any posters who live near these people in Oklahoma are wise to stay away from them. If you so much as look at Beverly the wrong way, she could stab you to death 40 times with a butcher knife and probably only be given a morning of community service as punishment.

I don't know what it is about this family how they continue to do so many horrible things and then serve such short stints in prison.

Ida and her other daughter Deborah were arrested for the murder of Deborah's husband in 1980. He was found in his car in the garage shot and stabbed to death. (A coincidence that another person who married into that family ended up being horrifically murdered?). But both were released in 1983.


I had never heard the story before. Geez!

Last night I sat in bed drafting a damning speech in a private message to Chad (we’re not friends obviously, so would have gone to his “other” inbox or whatever), but I wasn’t gutsy enough to hit send. Has anyone here reached out to him? Just curious

You found his facebook?

I had never heard the story before. Geez!

Details are hard to come by since some links are now broken. But Deborah was married to a man, John Rausin, who was 30 years older than her. He walked to his car one morning to leave for work and was shot twice, stabbed ten times and his throat was slit. The manner of which he was killed was the same that would happen to Wendy and Lisa 12 years later, both of whom were also shot twice (in the heart and back of the head) in addition to the many stabbings.

After a three year long investigation, Deborah and Ida Prewitt were arrested and charged with 1st degree murder in 1983. But the case was eventually dropped. I haven't been able to find out WHY it was dropped but Wendy's sister said it was because of the flimsiest of reasons.

The moral of the story? Don't marry in to that family.

Wonder if they could get her or Chad on a federal charge or two.

Wonder if they could get her or Chad on a federal charge or two.

From what read on Chad is he testified against his mom. I assume that's what got him out of it. they were making plea deals with this family all over the place.

Would love to see an article on this

How is she released? How is that possible? She was convicted of killing THREE people! What is it with this family? How do they get off so easily? The only possible explanation is that the judge was being extorted and maybe they have pictures of him with an underage child for all I know. Because nothing else makes sense. How can this even be possible though to release her?

How is she released? How is that possible? She was convicted of killing THREE people! What is it with this family? How do they get off so easily? The only possible explanation is that the judge was being extorted and maybe they have pictures of him with an underage child for all I know. Because nothing else makes sense. How can this even be possible though to release her?

Its not actually that surprising, certainly there is no need for extortion.
The reality is soft on crime stances have become popular again in most of the country and we are going to see many people not getting prosecuted/getting light sentences/getting released without serving the full time going forward.

Its not actually that surprising, certainly there is no need for extortion.
The reality is soft on crime stances have become popular again in most of the country and we are going to see many people not getting prosecuted/getting light sentences/getting released without serving the full time going forward.

Sure, but in Oklahoma? And for triple murder cases? I can see the light on crime thing with armed robbery and such, which I still think should have a stiff sentence. But murder is for life? Wasn't she charged with 1st degree murder? So then how can she get out?

No he was never charged . He also is on Facebook and he trolls the sister of Wendy camp . He also brags about being on U.M. And how his family killed his ex ..... arrogant and I know he set them up. Wendy had all those broken bones and was tied up, stabbed and shot. He had to help kill them and most def move the bodies.

Just now seeing this. What did he do on FB to troll them? I found his page but didn't see much.

Sure, but in Oklahoma? And for triple murder cases? I can see the light on crime thing with armed robbery and such, which I still think should have a stiff sentence. But murder is for life? Wasn't she charged with 1st degree murder? So then how can she get out?

Oklahoma is a mess of a state. Paul Stamper only got 10 years for kidnapping, attempted murder, and prison escape.
Again, soft on crime.

Oklahoma is a mess of a state. Paul Stamper only got 10 years for kidnapping, attempted murder, and prison escape.
Again, soft on crime.

It just seems to strange to me. Considering it is such a close state to Texas I figured they have similar ways of thinking. Texas uses its death penalty for instance more than any other state. They don't mess around there. Whether someone agrees with the death penalty or not I don't think anyone would say Texas is soft on crime. Oklahoma always strikes me as similar to that. But I guess not, perhaps?

It just seems to strange to me. Considering it is such a close state to Texas I figured they have similar ways of thinking. Texas uses its death penalty for instance more than any other state. They don't mess around there. Whether someone agrees with the death penalty or not I don't think anyone would say Texas is soft on crime. Oklahoma always strikes me as similar to that. But I guess not, perhaps?

I can certainly understand your assumption, but no, from personal experience the states are very different.
Although they do border each other, the histories are very different. Texas was an independent breakaway republic from Mexico for about a decade before it was annexed to the US. And to this very day it is the closest thing to a proper state as envisioned by the founding fathers, ie. its a state which feels like a distinct entity rather than a subdivision of the Federal Government.
Oklahoma on the other hand was one of the last states admitted to the Union in the lower 48, the only later ones were Arizona and New Mexico. Much of Oklahoma was indian territory until that point in time, and even today it has a bizzare mixture of tribal government which overlays much of the state. Related to this, gambling is a major industry there with its attendent ills.
While Texas has the reputation of being tougher on crime (this is somewhat historical, but still true in a relative sense) Oklahoma was never law and order state (everyone has heard of the Texas Rangers, but no such entity from Oklahoma has that reputation).
And while both do have significant natural resource wealth, somehow in Texas that became a springboard to large cities, industries, and prosperity, while in Oklahoma it seems to have been more of a dutch disease sort of issue.

Supporting or not supporting the death penalty does not make one Soft on Crime. That's a politician's hollow phrase, no offense.

After I saw this segment I did a bit more reading. Most of why she was released is due to the plea deal. There was never enough evidence to actually convict her, and for whatever reason she decided to plea with them on it, which probabally included a deal to get 15 years for a triple murder. When you have a 15 year sentence, getting out in 5 is not out of the question.

https://www.hutchinsmaplesfuneralhome.com/obituary/beverly-noe

I'm sure this has been posted in a different thread, but she died in October of this year. Her obituary also lists Jonathan as one of her children.

https://www.hutchinsmaplesfuneralhome.com/obituary/beverly-noe

I'm sure this has been posted in a different thread, but she died in October of this year. Her obituary also lists Jonathan as one of her children.

I have no guilt in saying this but the world is a better place with her gone. Good riddance. Glad to know she is gone and can no longer hurt any more people.

Obituaries are always written by a family member so it gives you the impression of a good hearted person who was beloved. You don’t get to read about her lifetime achievements of prison for murders, prison for arson and raising a useless sack of crap son who has sex with a nurse in the same hospital room as his comatose wife.

Evil bitch, burn.

I hope she burns in Hell. Slowly.

I have no guilt in saying this but the world is a better place with her gone. Good riddance. Glad to know she is gone and can no longer hurt any more people.

Obituaries are always written by a family member so it gives you the impression of a good hearted person who was beloved. You don’t get to read about her lifetime achievements of prison for murders, prison for arson and raising a useless sack of crap son who has sex with a nurse in the same hospital room as his comatose wife.

omg they had Jonathon written as her son. thats fanciful. Wendy's family is probably pissed. She stole her grandson from his mother through murder.

This is on Oxygen tonight. Fatal Family Feuds S1E5.

This is on Oxygen tonight. Fatal Family Feuds S1E5.

I just watched this and it's hard not to feel angry, even after everything we already knew.

First of all, the reason given (in this episode) for Beverly's release from prison was because she was old and in failing health. WTF Oklahoma? Who cares if her health is failing? Leave the killer behind bars until she takes her last breath. Why was she shown any mercy? She didn't show any mercy for the three victims who were shot and stabbed. They also bring up the fact that little Cynthia had duct-tape wrapped around her mouth. You are not going to do that to someone who is already dead. Think about how disturbing that is.

I thought it was interesting that Ida's granddaughter (and Chad's cousin) was interviewed. She said growing up that most of the family members felt Ida and her other daughter Deborah had in fact killed Deborah's husband in 1980. They also were hoping that Ida would finally confess her knowledge of Wendy, Cynthia and Lisa's murders while on her deathbed but...Ida being the POS human being she was, never said a word.

Is Oklahoma really this clueless when it comes to law enforcement? Are criminals just allowed to do whatever they want? We already knew that Beverly would stand Wendy up several times when she was supposed to have court appointed visits with Jonathan. Then Wendy's sister mentions that Beverly took Jonathan into hiding for an entire year and Wendy had no idea where he was. This was all on the heels leading up to the triple murder. Again, how was any of this legal? If you disappear with the child for that long and ignore court ordered visitations, why do you still get to make the decisions on when and if Wendy can visit with her own child? Why is there no accountability for Beverly ignoring the law?

Ugh. It just sounds even more-so now that the phone call conveniently allowing that short visit with Jonathan (to set up the murders) should have been a bigger red flag than it already seemed to be. Beverly already lied to the police that Leon was sexually abusing Jonathan to make sure Wendy couldn't regain custody. And now after being in hiding for a year, she suddenly returns and is fine with a visit? Poor Wendy was so desperate to see her son that she probably ignored all the warning signs.

Everything about this saga is truly infuriating.

I just watched this and it's hard not to feel angry, even after everything we already knew.

First of all, the reason given (in this episode) for Beverly's release from prison was because she was old and in failing health. WTF Oklahoma? Who cares if her health is failing? Leave the killer behind bars until she takes her last breath. Why was she shown any mercy? She didn't show any mercy for the three victims who were shot and stabbed. They also bring up the fact that little Cynthia had duct-tape wrapped around her mouth. You are not going to do that to someone who is already dead. Think about how disturbing that is.

I thought it was interesting that Ida's granddaughter (and Chad's cousin) was interviewed. She said growing up that most of the family members felt Ida and her other daughter Deborah had in fact killed Deborah's husband in 1980. They also were hoping that Ida would finally confess her knowledge of Wendy, Cynthia and Lisa's murders while on her deathbed but...Ida being the POS human being she was, never said a word.

Is Oklahoma really this clueless when it comes to law enforcement? Are criminals just allowed to do whatever they want? We already knew that Beverly would stand Wendy up several times when she was supposed to have court appointed visits with Jonathan. Then Wendy's sister mentions that Beverly took Jonathan into hiding for an entire year and Wendy had no idea where he was. This was all on the heels leading up to the triple murder. Again, how was any of this legal? If you disappear with the child for that long and ignore court ordered visitations, why do you still get to make the decisions on when and if Wendy can visit with her own child? Why is there no accountability for Beverly ignoring the law?

Ugh. It just sounds even more-so now that the phone call conveniently allowing that short visit with Jonathan (to set up the murders) should have been a bigger red flag than it already seemed to be. Beverly already lied to the police that Leon was sexually abusing Jonathan to make sure Wendy couldn't regain custody. And now after being in hiding for a year, she suddenly returns and is fine with a visit? Poor Wendy was so desperate to see her son that she probably ignored all the warning signs.

Everything about this saga is truly infuriating.

I know Leon said that he didn't trust the family and that is why the other two went with Wendy that day. And if Leon had come with them my guess is he is dead too.

This is why I never rule out crooked courts or police departments that frame people. Look at how far they will go to aid and help a trashy family like the Noe's?

I know Leon said that he didn't trust the family and that is why the other two went with Wendy that day. And if Leon had come with them my guess is he is dead too.

This is why I never rule out crooked courts or police departments that frame people. Look at how far they will go to aid and help a trashy family like the Noe's?

I don't approve of crooked courts or police departments helping powerful and rich people who have all the advantages, but it happens all the time. I hate it but it doesn't surprise me in the least. But Beverly Noe? Ida Prewitt? Nothing adds up here.

The population of Shamrock, Oklahoma today is 31 people. At the time of the triple murder, the population hovered around 100. If you look it up on Google Maps, you'll see it's nothing but a couple blocks of small homes and trailers. There's no stores, no restaurants, not even a workable gas station. There's a museum that's about the size of a one car garage and a little church that looks big enough to hold maybe 25 people.

Beverly wasn't a wealthy person. She was a psycho hillbilly who lived in this 'blink and you'll miss it' town who knowingly and consistently broke the law and everything she did was ignored by police over and over and over. I think there's an argument for her to be arrested long before the bodies were even discovered. This is just something I'll never understand.

Just a thought about this segment. This is perhaps the most accurate assessment a family member (Jackie Johnson, Wendy's mother) ever made on the show https://youtu.be/IO0D3GI7xzc?t=1525

Does this family have connections to powerful people in the state of Oklahoma? I know that sounds silly to ask because they basically come across as hillbillies but there has to be a reason why they keep getting released after doing such horrific things. I mean, they could have arrested Beverly long before the bodies were found. I think other murderes have been convicted on less evidence.


As I recall, the Noe-Prewitt family has basically been a redneck crime family for god-only-knows how long.

Supposedly that’s why the family fought so hard to get custody of Johnathan. You know the saying “Little pitchers have big ears?” Well, they also have big mouths with which they might repeat the stuff they happen to overhear.

Sure, but in Oklahoma? And for triple murder cases? I can see the light on crime thing with armed robbery and such, which I still think should have a stiff sentence. But murder is for life? Wasn't she charged with 1st degree murder? So then how can she get out?

It just seems to strange to me. Considering it is such a close state to Texas I figured they have similar ways of thinking. Texas uses its death penalty for instance more than any other state. They don't mess around there. Whether someone agrees with the death penalty or not I don't think anyone would say Texas is soft on crime. Oklahoma always strikes me as similar to that. But I guess not, perhaps?

Speaking as an Okie, I understand the bafflement. Oklahoma isn’t a liberal peacenik state when it comes to law and order. We lead the nation when it comes to number of women in prison, are third when it comes to men, and are in second place when it comes to the death penalty, beaten only by Texas. All this in addition to being the meth capitol of the US. Oklahoma is NOT soft on crime.

Normally the state would be panting with desire to lock them up for life, more than happy to give them the needle.

FYI, I tell people that Oklahoma is akin to Canada: we’re a mild version of our crazy southern neighbor. We’re the buckle of the Bible Belt, one of the reddest of red states.

As I recall, the Noe-Prewitt family has basically been a redneck crime family for god-only-knows how long.

Speaking as an Okie, I understand the bafflement. Oklahoma isn’t a liberal peacenik state when it comes to law and order. We lead the nation when it comes to number of women in prison, are third when it comes to men, and are in second place when it comes to the death penalty, beaten only by Texas. All this in addition to being the meth capitol of the US. Oklahoma is NOT soft on crime.

Normally the state would be panting with desire to lock them up for life, more than happy to give them the needle.

FYI, I tell people that Oklahoma is akin to Canada: we’re a mild version of our crazy southern neighbor. We’re the buckle of the Bible Belt, one of the reddest of red states.

Well apparently, the Okie's did worse than any bunch of liberals in any peacenik state would've done when it came to the Noe's.

Canada is terribly soft on crime. It's embarrassing how those people up there believe in "reform" and second chances. Worse than the Californians and New Yorkers. I've tried to talk to my relatives up there about it and I end up walking away from the conversation shaking my head, feeling like they're a hopeless case. They can't seem to care much about anything that doesn't affect them personally. I always thought I was the inhuman alien until I went up to Canada a few times. Really don't know what's wrong with them up there.

Jonathan Noe today - his mugshot

https://i.postimg.cc/XXdZpxcS/one.jpg (https://postimg.cc/XXdZpxcS)

2021 Story below - He was charged with two felony assault charges, attempted auto theft & knowingly concealing stolen property (he had over $100,000 worth of stolen checks)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uGvZ-Xf6xAo

Jonathan Noe today - his mugshot

https://i.postimg.cc/XXdZpxcS/one.jpg (https://postimg.cc/XXdZpxcS)

2021 Story below - He was charged with two felony assault charges, attempted auto theft & knowingly concealing stolen property (he had over $100,000 worth of stolen checks)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uGvZ-Xf6xAo

Sadly, the apple doesn't fall far from the tree.

Sadly, the apple doesn't fall far from the tree.

Indeed. It's incredibly sad this happened but it's not surprising. He was raised by Beverly Noe. There is no recovery from that.

In the 2023 TV series "Hometown Tragedy" (link to the episode below), members of the Noe family were interviewed, and Jonathan's cousin says Jonathan knew at a very young age that his mother and sister were buried on one of the Noe properties, despite Jonathan's protestations that he didn't believe Beverly had anything to do with it.

Bottom line: Jonathan knew the truth but said nothing. The Noe cousin also reported that Beverly endured a gruesome and agonizing death near the end of her life. Those infuriated by Beverly's lenient sentence for her three murders may find solace in this.

The link to the episode is below.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SoqQhKy9LSk

In the 2023 TV series "Hometown Tragedy" (link to the episode below), members of the Noe family were interviewed, and Jonathan's cousin says Jonathan knew at a very young age that his mother and sister were buried on one of the Noe properties, despite Jonathan's protestations that he didn't believe Beverly had anything to do with it.

Bottom line: Jonathan knew the truth but said nothing. The Noe cousin also reported that Beverly endured a gruesome and agonizing death near the end of her life. Those infuriated by Beverly's lenient sentence for her three murders may find solace in this.

The link to the episode is below.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SoqQhKy9LSk
Nice find !!

Yeesh. As a kid, the cousin said Jonathan actually said the words, “we probably shouldn’t play here because my mom and sister might be buried here.” Being raised by Beverly, Jonathan does not have any sense of right and wrong. That’s going to make it extremely difficult to function in society.

Sounds like Ida’s granddaughter-in-law was pretty brave to call Beverly up after Grover’s arrest and tell her, “You know for damn sure Grover didn’t kill those girls. It was you.” And her husband told her that he wished she hadn’t said that because now he’s going to have to stay up all night with a gun guarding their front door. You hear these kinds of stories all the time from these Podunk towns out in the middle of nowhere; where the hicks do unspeakable things and residents keep quiet out of fear for their own lives. In this case, it was members of their own family.

It seems like Wendy’s family was failed on every level along the way. Even before the murders, I don’t understand why Jonathan was allowed to be in full custody with the woman who had a long criminal record and had kidnapped him for a year prior.

This story premiered on Cold Case Files last month. I watched the episode yesterday. They mention at one point about Unsolved Mysteries coming to Oklahoma to film the segment. It’s also mentioned that Wendy was a UM fanatic who never missed an episode.

Wendy’s mother correctly immediately assumed that the three were dead and the Noe family was responsible. Aisha, on the other hand, held out hope and even believed Beverly’s original story about dropping the three off at the Walmart in Chandler. It wasn’t until she saw Ida’s infamous interview on UM (where Wendy was apparently “griping” and “b*tching”) that she knew they were responsible.

Sadly, the apple doesn't fall far from the tree.
This case always angered me
Chad and his blinks eyes. "I figured I would have two kids." Nice and classy!!