View Full Version : Examples of GI’s incisive commentary


Schmo
08-06-2019, 04:00 PM
I grew up watching GI on weekday afternoons when I came home from school. That left me with the impression that children were the target audience. But then I just remembered a particular episode where Gilligan dreamed he was the absolute ruler of some country, only to find out he was a “puppet” of some general, played by a character actor using a stereotypical Latino accent. Does anyone remember the name of that episode and who played the general? That led me to think the series may have had other moments of sublime social commentary. What were they?

Babalu
08-07-2019, 05:52 AM
https://m.media-amazon.com/images/M/MV5BMTc5N2M5YjUtMDZmYS00YjI1LWFhNzktMjlhYjk0Y2NkMTkwXkEyXkFqcGdeQXVyNzU5NjE0Mzc@._V1_.jpg

Agent 36-24-36

GentlemanJim
04-11-2020, 02:33 PM
That led me to think the series may have had other moments of sublime social commentary. What were they?

From about the time I started watching afternoon reruns when I was in JR high school, I seriously started wondering why the castaways wanted so badly to be rescued. I know there are "loved ones" left behind, and I'm sure that for a month or two I would miss them...but I believe after a while I would one day come upon the realization that I was living in paradise, kick back, and make the most out of the "dilemma". No taxes, no crime, no pollution, no social strife threatening to take away whatever I might find enjoyment with....those castaways were not really suffering.

I've often wondered if there was not some form of intentional satire along those lines from the shows creator.

I also vaguely recall biting sarcasm on behalf of the russian cosmonauts about repressive governments, in such a way that one familiar with the big picture might start to question "the American Way" as perhaps being not quite as free as we are told it is.

And the episode where the Howells adopt Gilligan, and school him as to the pitfalls of the unwashed masses, I think had a little more truth than many would care to admit (as far as what the privileged believe).

I also suspect that the episode where the radioactive seeds grew vegetables that enhanced different qualities in the different people consuming them had some editorial intent as well, but I'm a little undecided what that message might be. Perhaps an introspective on vanity.

And lastly, that so many transient visitors were able to come and go from the island while the castaways remained marooned, kinda hints that the sense of community that the castaways developed was a barrier to their rescue...sort of a "we are captive to what we believe" type thing.

CosmicCharlie
05-29-2020, 11:01 PM
The castaway's had a much more interesting living situation and adventures than most land lubbers ! And having Mary Ann & Ginger there was much better than say having Rosie O'Donnell as a neighbor ! Everyone on the island were good natured and not lowly degenerates that would detract from daily living ! As others have said the cast was keenly selected and their each unique character they played offered much to the variety of viewers ! Sherwood had a keen aim and hit his target !