View Full Version : Frank Casteel Dead at 71


Zoneboy
05-31-2019, 07:21 AM
Link (https://newschannel9.com/news/local/frank-casteel-convicted-of-1988-signal-mountain-murders-dies-in-prison)

CHATTANOOGA, Tenn. — Online state records confirm that Frank Casteel, the man convicted in 1997 of killing three ATV riders on Signal Mountain, has died in prison. The Tennessee website for felony offender information lists Casteel as deceased. He was 71 years old.


Casteel was convicted in 1997 in the deaths of Richard Mason, Earl Smock and Kennith Griffith in July, 1988.

The men were last seen on their way to ride ATVs to one of Signal Mountain's favorite swimming spots, the Blue Hole. But they never returned home.

Police began an intensive search, and ultimately found their ATVs covered in blood nine miles from the entrance of the swimming hole, but no sign of their bodies. The bodies were found four days after officials recovered the ATVs, all with shotgun wounds.

It took nearly 10 years to connect the dots in the case, using several pieces of evidence and a sound recording of Frank Casteel.

Casteel's mistress, Marie Hill, also came forward to police about letters she had received during their relationship which was around the same time of the murder. The letters were sent to her anonymously. The letters were from Casteel's wife, Suzie, with hopes to break-up Frank and his mistress's relationship.

Police arrested Casteel arrested on April 15, 1997. His defense was that he and his wife were out camping on some of the land he owned on Signal Mountain the night of the murders, and did not hear any gunshots. But prosecutors said Casteel was angered by the sound of ATVs on what he believed was his property in the middle of the night.

A jury later convicted Casteel of the murders, and he was eventually sentenced to life in prison.

The criminal court of appeals ordered a new trial after his 1998 conviction, stating that some evidence should not have been allowed in trial.

A second jury convicted Casteel again in 2003, and he spent the rest of his life behind bars. He had been eligible for parole in 2024.

NewsChannel 9 is working to learn more information about Casteel's death. This story will be updated.

TheCars1986
05-31-2019, 07:33 AM
Maybe I'm confusing this with the Rhode Island murders, but wasn't there some sort of local groundswell to free Casteel because people believed he was innocent?

dynoguy88
05-31-2019, 07:41 AM
I wonder if this means Casteel's insufferable son will finally stop his crusade to convince people his father didn't kill the three men.

justins5256
05-31-2019, 09:24 AM
Maybe I'm confusing this with the Rhode Island murders, but wasn't there some sort of local groundswell to free Casteel because people believed he was innocent?

Yes. I believe his son was leading the charge.

sdb4884
05-31-2019, 10:47 AM
Good, burn in hell you bastard.

Fletch
05-31-2019, 11:02 AM
Good riddance.

PracTz
05-31-2019, 11:17 AM
Does anyone know if he was still married at the time of his death to Mrs. Casteel who was the one who sent poison pen letters evidently detailing the murders to his then-mistress in order to try to scare the mistress away from 'her man' but the mistress wound up not only dumping him but ALSO going to the authorities with the letters! THEN Mrs. Casteel screamed at his sentencing 'No! No! He's INNOCENT!' but, this time, no one believed her.
If they stayed married, I wonder if Mrs. Casteel actually thinks she somehow 'won'?

5thcorps
05-31-2019, 12:48 PM
I'm glad to see this vile piece of trash finally below ground. His son's awful defense of him made me sick. :mad:

StackTime
05-31-2019, 01:18 PM
Good riddance to this piece of trash. Not quite in the Oba Chandler league, but not far behind.

At any rate, one of the replies mentioned his wife, and it got me curious.

If I recall correctly several eyewitnesses saw a woman near a car on the side of the road near the murder site (or maybe the dump site) the night of the murders, trying to divert traffic. Was this ever explained - who it was, what they were doing, and why?

tsaun
06-02-2019, 04:44 PM
Good riddance to this piece of trash. Not quite in the Oba Chandler league, but not far behind.

At any rate, one of the replies mentioned his wife, and it got me curious.

If I recall correctly several eyewitnesses saw a woman near a car on the side of the road near the murder site (or maybe the dump site) the night of the murders, trying to divert traffic. Was this ever explained - who it was, what they were doing, and why?

Ugh, Oba Chandler

Another scumbag who proclaimed his innocence but was 100% guilty.

Glad the state of Florida took care of him.

xxxxmattxxxx69
06-02-2019, 06:04 PM
Him and Edward Harold Bell can go straight to hell. Maybe some other dirtbags from UM can go under this year too

Drakken
06-03-2019, 08:06 PM
Couldn't have happened to a nicer guy.

TheCars1986
06-07-2019, 01:46 PM
I've been doing somewhat of a deep dive into this case recently and it looks like Casteel's son has his own Youtube channel. Just yesterday he uploaded a video (not sure if it's police video, or video for Casteel's defense) of the area that the 3 men would have traversed through (including Casteel's property) to get to the swimming hole they intended to go to. There's nothing graphic, it's just someone filming the ride they would have taken to get to the blue hole. It can be viewed here (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RdccOQdfFfY).

I've also read several articles which say that Casteel kept a log book of people who trespassed on his property and detailed his interactions with them. They say that Casteel was getting angry about trash being left behind but that he agreed to let people cut through his property to get to the swimming hole as long as they cleaned up their trash. I don't understand what would make the guy go from camping with his wife to murdering 3 guys who simply were riding ATV's to get to the swimming hole. Was there any other motive other than trespassing that was presented?

1990 UM fan
06-07-2019, 09:19 PM
Was there any other motive other than trespassing that was presented?


Makes me wonder if Richard Mason had a run-in with Frank Casteel before, as he and his wife Martha lived nearby.

Hambone2421
06-09-2019, 08:44 AM
You just hate to see it...

MegtheEgg86
06-09-2019, 03:28 PM
I've been doing somewhat of a deep dive into this case recently and it looks like Casteel's son has his own Youtube channel. Just yesterday he uploaded a video (not sure if it's police video, or video for Casteel's defense) of the area that the 3 men would have traversed through (including Casteel's property) to get to the swimming hole they intended to go to. There's nothing graphic, it's just someone filming the ride they would have taken to get to the blue hole. It can be viewed here (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RdccOQdfFfY).

I've also read several articles which say that Casteel kept a log book of people who trespassed on his property and detailed his interactions with them. They say that Casteel was getting angry about trash being left behind but that he agreed to let people cut through his property to get to the swimming hole as long as they cleaned up their trash. I don't understand what would make the guy go from camping with his wife to murdering 3 guys who simply were riding ATV's to get to the swimming hole. Was there any other motive other than trespassing that was presented?

I read lots of trial material on this case several years ago and do remember reading about the "log books". I also remember reading about a man who had approached the gate and was confronted by Casteel with shotgun in hand. The man opted to leave and Casteel let him go on, but it appears Casteel had been aggressive toward others in the past.

Trever Casteel
02-12-2020, 06:22 PM
Coming in April of 2020! Statement of Facts State vs. Casteel. The facts behind the Case.

drew790
02-12-2020, 06:42 PM
No thanks.

Huskerz85
02-13-2020, 12:29 PM
Coming in April of 2020! Statement of Facts State vs. Casteel. The facts behind the Case.

https://66.media.tumblr.com/b7db594289c5978e5b2e7ebf8f366358/tumblr_pz7w9daDIz1vaqoiqo1_500.gifv

5thcorps
02-13-2020, 12:44 PM
Coming in April of 2020! Statement of Facts State vs. Casteel. The facts behind the Case.
Finally gonna admit he's guilty huh?