This is a question for the seasoned veterans of the board—what are the most memorable board appearances by people (claiming to have been) on the show?

The ones that come to mind are:

- The coworker from the Mary Morris segment (suspect in her murder)
- Jonathan Bunting (formerly Bobby Baskin—it’s complicated) from the Baskins segment
- Paul Pollis (suspect in his wife Charlotte’s disappearance)
- Keith Warren’s sister/mother (African-American teenager died under mysterious circumtances)

I’m sure there’s a lot more—help me out folks!

I say “claiming to have been on UM” because I don’t know with certainty which were for real or not...but maybe someone else does.

Don Dixon may have made a very memorable post in the Eric Tamiyasu Thread. He posted under the handle "mssamspade." Post #116.

Yeah I suppose that could have been him..."Taco Bell lunches?" lol

Not to get off topic, but I always wonder which perpetrators of crimes come on here...

Nice idea for a thread. ;) Hmm not sure I can think of them all at once.

Sheila Kimmell and Penny Kerstetter has posted quite a bit...not profiled but interviewed on UM.

Keith Warren's sister
Poloma Gibson from that old missing children's segment sent me a pm but not sure if she posted or not.
Charles Horvath's mother (I think)
Linda Sohus' best friend who was interviewed on the segment
Nanette Brana
Either Charles or Christopher Smith (from the dad kidnaps them segment)
Rohrey Wychgel I think (he sent me a pm so he was on here at least)

If I think of more I'll post them.



Did Larry Gibson post?

Crystaldawn, are none of the segments you just mentioned on Amazon? I couldn't find any of them!

Not to get off topic, but I always wonder which perpetrators of crimes come on here...

Not off topic at all! I definitely wonder the same thing--that's why I started this thread. I was mainly referring to perps/suspects/victims.

If Dave Freeman came on here I would personally kick his...butt.

Crystaldawn, are none of the segments you just mentioned on Amazon? I couldn't find any of them!

Hmm not sure. I'm not really up on the segments they've taken out. I would think that Poloma Gibson, Nanette Brana, Charles & Christopher Smith and Rohrey Wychgel were probably removed because they weren't shown that much but I would have guessed they would have kept the others in.

The ones most memorable to me are Paul Pollis trying to disguise himself as a "friend" but then posting in the 1st person, and Don Dixon describing Taco Bell lunches.

I believe Pamela June Ray's daughter posted here. And I also seem to remember Frederick Young's mother (or relative) posting in the main thread about his case.

The ones most memorable to me are Paul Pollis trying to disguise himself as a "friend" but then posting in the 1st person, and Don Dixon describing Taco Bell lunches.

Those are my suspicions of Randall Utterback, or at least a family member of his. The amount of victim blaming and complete lack of logic in regards to Randall's character and actions have me thinking this person hits way closer to home than a random viewer's thoughts.

Whatever the case, I advise anyone to read the "Nerdy possessive boyfriend" thread whenever they feel like they need a good laugh. Because none of us here have ever bought what this person was trying to sell us and there are pages where the thread goes completely off the rails.

I remember Rohrey Wychgel posting here--I remember thinking he seemed super nice.

Doyle Wheeler has posted here. I also remember getting into a pretty tense discussion with someone who I suspect knew Sagon Penn or was involved in his defense.

Jane Boroski - I sent her a pm and she was incredibly nice.

Cliff Davis - Brother of Morris Davis

Melanie Hack - Younger sister of Cindy James. I went to her blog and invited her here. Really nice lady. She sent me a friend request on Facebook.

Cousin of Nyleen Kay Marshall. She gave some interesting notes about what it was like being a kid when Nyleen disappeared. A poster claiming to be Nyleen's brother Nathan created an account just to ask the cousin to pm him but then he never posted again.

The actress who played Rhonda Hinson. She gave some interesting notes about what it was like filming the UM segment, including a scene that was cut. She was a dead ringer for the real Rhonda Hinson so her avatar was her picture and Rhonda's next to each other.

Jane Boroski - I sent her a pm and she was incredibly nice.

Did Jane post in a thread as well? I would love to check that out.

The woman from the Such Is Life segment.

One of the survivors of the road rage incident posted here too (the black guys who were run off the road)

And most recently Arthur Paul Beale's relative

Those are my suspicions of Randall Utterback, or at least a family member of his. The amount of victim blaming and complete lack of logic in regards to Randall's character and actions have me thinking this person hits way closer to home than a random viewer's thoughts.

Whatever the case, I advise anyone to read the "Nerdy possessive boyfriend" thread whenever they feel like they need a good laugh. Because none of us here have ever bought what this person was trying to sell us and there are pages where the thread goes completely off the rails.

^^^^^ this

I forgot about Paul Beal's ex-wife posting here. She PM'ed me years ago before posting on the boards.

Did Jane post in a thread as well? I would love to check that out.

She made 5 responses in this thread. Screen name is jaynie.

http://www.sitcomsonline.com/boards/showthread.php?t=180576&highlight=jane+boroski

The ones most memorable to me are Paul Pollis trying to disguise himself as a "friend" but then posting in the 1st person, and Don Dixon describing Taco Bell lunches.

I believe Pamela June Ray's daughter posted here. And I also seem to remember Frederick Young's mother (or relative) posting in the main thread about his case.

Can someone please let me know where I can find the comments allegedly made by Paul Pollis? I would like to read. Please and thank you.

Totally nuts:

http://www.sitcomsonline.com/boards/showthread.php?t=159581&page=5

Cousin of Nyleen Kay Marshall. She gave some interesting notes about what it was like being a kid when Nyleen disappeared. A poster claiming to be Nyleen's brother Nathan created an account just to ask the cousin to pm him but then he never posted again.

Didn't she also reveal that Nyleen's mother was murdered in Mexico and the family thought it was set up by the step father? Or was that a different thread?

A poster claiming to be Nyleen's brother Nathan created an account just to ask the cousin to pm him but then he never posted again.

NPM12 posted two more times in 2016, but they were short. One showed his gratitude for our ongoing dedication to his sister's case and his mother's murder. The last was when he responded to my "I know who that cousin is."

Didn't she also reveal that Nyleen's mother was murdered in Mexico and the family thought it was set up by the step father? Or was that a different thread?

Nope, that was Nyleen's estranged, paternal half-sister Kena. Someone claiming to be the child of Nancy's friend posted similar accusations on the step-father.

It needs to be noted, we've never heard the family's views―and I mean Nancy's side of the family―on Kim. They still seem to be on good terms.

^^^^^ this

I remember I was online and on the board at the very moment some of those more memorable posts went up. I was SCREAMING laughing. I just kept refreshing the page and it was a new nugget of gold like every other minute.

I forgot about Paul Beal's ex-wife posting here. She PM'ed me years ago before posting on the boards.

What did she say?

What did she say?

That she went to a Cars concert back in the 80's, and that basically Paul was faking his amnesia, deserted her and their kids, and thought it was odd that people were still talking about it all these years later.

Didn't know this thread idea already existed:

http://www.sitcomsonline.com/boards/showthread.php?t=200468

Looks like Koala (the Mary Morris coworker) posted on there as well.

I'm about 80% sure one of those posts on the Randall Utterback thread were from him.

I'm about 80% sure one of those posts on the Randall Utterback thread were from him.
is that the nerdy possessive boyfriend thread? just joking. anytime I can say that I am going to get it in. I am 81% sure....:)

Wait Michaela Garhets actress posted here?

Didn't we have Nathan Kneesmith's daughter here once??

I remember I was online and on the board at the very moment some of those more memorable posts went up. I was SCREAMING laughing. I just kept refreshing the page and it was a new nugget of gold like every other minute.
Yeah I think you are speaking of a few years back when we had a lengthy debate with a poster over victim blaming? Then we had another very interesting poster join and came out guns blazing and got banned straight away? I remember that. for me that thread is a UM Sitcoms Online pilgrimage. you have to read from start to finish at least once.

for me that thread is a UM Sitcoms Online pilgrimage. you have to read from start to finish at least once.

Noted!

When I am having a bad day, I think of both the Randall Utterback and the Paul Pollis thread and I just laugh... :)