We all know that Jeannie and Samantha never met but what if they did and ended up having a showdown, who would win? I'm going to post this poll on the I Dream of Jeannie board as well. I'll post the results of all the polls put together in 60 days so start voting.

So far Jeannie is winning in both this and the I Dream of Jeannie board, 7 for Jeannie and 0 for Samantha.

Well, although I voted for Jeannie, I don't think it's accurate to say that she's winning. This subject has already been posted here at the Bewitched board ("Witch vs. Jeannie, who would win?) and I think that people just aren't motivated to answer the same question twice.

Also, I don't think you will get unbiased answers by posting these at the Bewitched and Jeannie boards. It's only natural that Samantha fans will vote for her and Jeannie fans will vote for Jeannie. I happen to like them both, so I had to choose.

If you really want to get unbiased opinions from this poll, you might want to post this question at the General Sitcoms board (many people who go to that might not be fans of either, but might be interested in this topic). Just a friendly suggestion :)

Twitching a Nose takes more skill than nodding a head.

Samantha wins, hands down. Just as she did on the same poll on this board recently.
Good point Paula.

Samantha only won cuz she's the best. It's a fact. No, i like Jeanie too, but Samantha is the best!

The twitch may call for more skill, but it's the blink that's the fastest. I definately think Jeannie would win, she and her sister fought all the time on the show, so we know that she would definately be up for the challenge. She wouldnt be new to the whole thing. I also don't believe you guys should be so rude to Jeannie and Dallas. She hasnt been registered here very long and she didn't know that the pole had already been posted. But, Jeannie is winning anyway.

The nose! ANYONE can nod, but how many people can do "the twitch"?? I sure can't - not that I haven't tried enough. :lol:

Samantha would win win only for one reason, and that IS "reason" she is much more intelligent than Jeannie, and would simply outsmart her at every turn!

I'd vote for Samantha too, she just seems tougher, maybe having Endora for a mother has something to do with it. (lol!)

^ Having to put up with parents like Endora and Maurice would make anyone tougher. :lol:

Samantha could also snap her finger which is faster than a nod or a twitch, imo.

Samantha could also snap her finger which is faster than a nod or a twitch, imo.
She would also wave her arms sometimes.