http://i1331.photobucket.com/albums/w594/JamesGrec3/american-idol-season-15-poster_zpsor5on8xz.png

It has to be all past runner-ups and some past 3rd placers, and NO past winners, this time.

Why? Because you say so?

Ed.

Why? Because you say so?

Ed.

Not really, Edward216...

First, there was a bad powerdialing accident occurring between this show's 1st and 2nd seasons.

Secondly, there was nonstoppable brawl started between fans and critics between this show's 2nd and 3rd seasons and it resumed until now.

The only way to end this nonstoppable brawl and fix this powerdialing accident is to bring back only the runner-ups and 3rd placers in this final season. Otherwise, this show is permanently trashed for the rest of its life and it will no longer be on television air anymore!