As a rough measure of quality, I counted how many Emmys (best Comedy/Drama/Variety) were won by shows on the Antenna TV and MeTV winter schedules:

MeTV
I Love Lucy (2 comedy)
Make Room for Daddy (1 comedy)
Gunsmoke (1 drama)
Mission Impossible (2 drama)
Get Smart (2 comedy)
Carol Burnett (3 variety)
MASH (1 comedy)
Mary Tyler Moore (3 comedy)
Rockford Files (1 drama)
Taxi (3 comedy)
Cheers (3 comedy)
22 total (15 comedy, 4 drama, 3 variety)

Antenna TV
Jack Benny Program (2 comedy)
Monkees (1 comedy)
All in the Family (4 comedy)
Barney Miller (1 comedy)
8 total (8 comedy)

It's a mismatch this time around, with MeTV way out in front. I'll post Cozi TV if I can find an offical winter schedule. Appreciate any corrections, or additions for other networks.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Primetime_Emmy_Award_winners