Though not a game show, does anyone remember a syndicated talent show titled Your All American College Show? It ran in syndication from 1968 to 1970 and was hosted by Dennis James and Arthur Godfrey. College students showcased their talents. It was also the show when Karen and Richard Carpenter made their TV debut, performing under the name "The Dick Carpenter Trio."

I remember the show airing in New York on WPIX-TV the first season and moved over to WNBC-TV for the second. The TV Guide always listed the show as "College Talent."