This is what happened back then:

Ruben - 1st
Clay - 2nd
Kimberley - 3rd

I don't understand why Ruben had the most votes and would win when his voice and singing style is more horrible than both Kimberley and Clay? Ruben cheated, IMO!

This is correct standing:

1) Ruben should have been eliminated and put in third place.

2) Kimberley and Clay should be the Top 2 because both their singing styles are precise.

3) Since Clay's voice is more higher than Kimberley, Clay should have won and Kimberley should be put as a runner-up.

1st - Clay
2nd - Kimberley
3rd - Ruben

They should have recount the votes on all three remaining contestants!

Any questions?