Ok, you die and your creator, be he God, Allah, Brahma, Richard Dawkins, whoever, tells you that you can have the definitive truth behind one case shown on UM before ascending to the afterlife (or the next life, at which point you will conveniently forget what you were just told).

Which Unsolved Mystery would you want the answer to?

I'll go for the Circleville Writer, with Cindy James a close second - seriously weird and mysterious cases where so many possibilities are geninely open.

Pamela June Ray and JB Beasley/Tracie Hawlett. Its a tie. I think they would have been on UM if if had stayed on a few more years.

Ok, you die and your creator, be he God, Allah, Brahma, Richard Dawkins, whoever, tells you that you can have the definitive truth behind one case shown on UM before ascending to the afterlife (or the next life, at which point you will conveniently forget what you were just told).

Which Unsolved Mystery would you want the answer to?

I'll go for the Circleville Writer, with Cindy James a close second - seriously weird and mysterious cases where so many possibilities are geninely open.

Great question! For me, it’d be a tie between what happened to Dale Kersetter or what really happened to Dave Bocks. Although the Cindy James mystery is also intriguing!

I created this topic here a few years back. Although in my version, I think it was a magic genie that gives you a box with a picture of Robert Stack on it. Inside the box has every answer to the one single segment that you have always wanted to know. But that was the catch, you could only choose one.

I'd find the thread if I could but it's probably 50 pages back.

As I recall, there were a lot of votes for Kurt Sova, Cindy James, Tammy Leppert and the whereabouts of the Baskin children, seeing that they had not been found yet. But most of the respondents couldn't narrow their choices to just one segment.

I would have a conversation with Robert Stack and hopefully have him "update" them all for me. If he feels up to it. ;)

Mine will probably be pretty common...

What happened to:

Angela Hammond

and

Cindy Anderson

I love that question!

I wanna know what happened to danny Casolaro
or the two teenagers who were asleep on the railroad (i can't remenber their name).

^ Best username of all time.

Though I doubt UM would be on my mind at that particular time what I would be interested in knowing if I were ever granted (as mentioned on UM) to ask any question and get the absolute, unequivocal answer in return, I'd be most interested in most of the "Final Appeal" cases that were profiled.

I'm guessing like most people I have my lists of innocents versus guilty already in my head but given that I consider myself to be a decent judge of character I'd like to know if the faith that I placed in those I deemed innocent was rewarded.

^ Best username of all time.
This times infinity! :nod:


I would have to go with Amy Billig.

Only ONE? Man...

With so many to choose from, I'll eliminate some where I can draw SOME sort of conclusion but are tempting (Blair Adams, Elizabeth Campbell, Jeremy Bright, and Jody Huisentruit) and go with one where I have no idea.

Nyleen Kay Marshall.

The Billy the Kid/Brushy Bill Roberts case.

Do I have the ability to haunt people? Because that'd totally change my answer. :)

Assuming I cannot haunt people, I think I'd go with William L. Toomey.

If I can haunt people, Frs. Rivera and Kerrigan.

Have we ever had a thread about which mysteries we don't want to ever know the answer to?

I'd like to know what became of Dottie Caylor, whether she really did leave or that Jule did away with her. I'd also like to know what happened to Jeremy Bright, Angela Hammond, Selena Edon, etc.

I can't decide on only 1case. Who was Sharon Marshall?

I had to think about this one for a while before I gave my answer.

It's a toss-up between Kevin Ives and Don Henry, and Rhonda Hinson.

There are a lot of cases for me, but I'd have to say Blair Adams. Such a strange case.

I'd like to know what became of Dottie Caylor, whether she really did leave or that Jule did away with her. I'd also like to know what happened to Jeremy Bright, Angela Hammond, Selena Edon, etc.


Yes I agree with you. I'd like to know what REALLY happened to Dottie. I'm not sure why so many would waste their answer on the Kurt Sova case. It's pretty clear what happened - He drank far too much of that Everclear stuff thus leading to his death by alcoholic poisoning. The Teenagers at the party freaked out and probably thought they were all going to jail (or something!). Then dumped his body after keeping it stored in the basement.