Who is prettiest? You decide.

Barbara Eden (I dream of Jeanne)

Elizabeth Montgomery (Bewitched)

Marlo Thomas (That girl)

Mary Tyler Moore (Mary)

This is a hard one! It's between Jeannie and Samantha I voted for Jeannie as the prettiest but I like Samantha better.:)

Mary! By far...Mary! :happyface

I think Elizabeth Montgomery was the prettiest.

Mary

Mary, no contest. ;)

Barbara. I mean, she STILL looks good in her 60's!

Barbara.

I think Barbra Eden is the most prettiest of them all because of those big blue eyes and that nice long blonde hair. She looks fabulous!

No contest:
Elizabeth! I think she is sooo pretty!

nooooooo!!!!!!!!!! c'mon people! let's not let Mary fall behind here! Don't be lazy, vote for Mary! lol, that kinda rhymed. o well, I tried

Mary, by far.

Marlo Marlo Marlo!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Look at her!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

OK that didn't work right.
Now look at her:

OK how do you attach an image?
I put in the URL and clicked Submit Reply but it doesn't show up.I guess I just use vb codes.
http://www.timstvshowcase.com/thatgirl.jpg

All of them were pretty, but I went with Marlo Thomas, because:

1) She has that girl next door look.
2) "That Girl" was great"
3) "Free to Be..You and Me" was great.
4)Her dad's sitcom was great.

yay!! Mary's out in front again!! Go Mary Go! Go Mary Go!! :D

Barbara!:)

Definitely Elizabeth.

First of all, I am judging all of them when they were young and in their prime. I never found Barbara Eden particularly attractive, but the other three certainly were very beautiful. I did not consider any criterion except physical beauty. I had an extremely hard time choosing between MTM and EM. Mary won by a hair, but it could have gone the other way too. There was this old "Twilight Zone" that EM was in in which she played a Russian soldier who is one of two survivors of a nuclear war. She was very young when she made it and is as beautiful in that as any woman I've ever seen. I guess I averaged MTM's appearance when she was on the Dick Van Dyke show, and EM's appearance on and prior to "Bewitched." I understand that EM used to appear on her father's TV show, but I have only seen a few clips of that.

Barbara Eden! She was just so beautiful and she still is.

Then...
Mary Tyler Moore
Elizabeth Montgomery
Marlo Thomas. (Who looks very much like Joyce DeWitt.)

ELIZABETH MONTGOMERY!!

I think that Elizabeth is the prettiest out of all of them.

thats hard they are all pretty but i went with Elizabeth Monthgomery

then its be

1.Barbara Eden
2.Mary Tyler Moore
3.Marlo Thomas

Elizabeth. Barbara was a close second! :)

Marlo Thomas

Originally posted by BrandonS
I never found Barbara Eden particularly attractive, but the other three certainly were very beautiful
You've obviously never seen her in the episode of The Andy Griffith Show that she did before "Jeannie". I'll tell you, she was stunning!:faint:
I never really thought that she was very attractive in that Jeannie hairstyle and costume, then I saw that TAGS episode and found that she is really quite beautiful, and that's why I voted for her.

Mary Tyler Moore!

Barbara Eden, but Elizabeth Montgomery is a very close second. They're both very beautiful.

I voted for Elizabeth Montgomery.

This was hard because I had crushes on all of them when I was a kid.

Originally posted by Sterling Holobyte
You've obviously never seen her in the episode of The Andy Griffith Show that she did before "Jeannie". I'll tell you, she was stunning!:faint:
I never really thought that she was very attractive in that Jeannie hairstyle and costume, then I saw that TAGS episode and found that she is really quite beautiful, and that's why I voted for her.
Interesting. Maybe one day I'll see something she was in before "Jeannie" and change my mind.

Tough question. I think all four women are beautiful.
Based on beauty alone, my votes goes to Barbara Eden. I think she had more sex appeal.
Elizabeth Montgomery is a very close second. With that said, I enjoy Bewitched and the MTM show more than IDOJ. I'm also a bigger fan of Elizabeth Montgomery and Mary Tyler Moore than I am of Barbara Eden.

Marlo

I pick Elizabeth Montgomery

I voted for my woman, because she is just too damn hot. ;)

Originally posted by BrandonS
Interesting. Maybe one day I'll see something she was in before "Jeannie" and change my mind.

I also remember seeing her in an episode of I Love Lucy, if you ever watch that. She played a girl who Lucy and Ethel were envious of.

Originally posted by .:mads:.
I think that Elizabeth is the prettiest out of all of them.

Aww, Mads I didn't realize you picked my woman. :D :bighug:

I think that all the actresses in the poll are beautiful, but i think Elizabeth Montgomery was one of the most beautiful ladies that ever graced the television screen:) :)

Originally posted by foxyhonky1975
I think that all the actresses in the poll are beautiful, but i think Elizabeth Montgomery was one of the most beautiful ladies that ever graced the television screen:) :)

Yes, she was. Thank you, for your kind vote. :D

Just kidding, I really don't care about this poll. I KNOW Liz is the most gorgeous, enchanting, bewitching, sexy, and beautiful woman to ever grace the earth with her presence.

Originally posted by pandora_spocks
Aww, Mads I didn't realize you picked my woman. :D :bighug:

:D :bighug:

Originally posted by .:mads:.
:D :bighug:

:bighug: Right back at ya! :bouncers hehe