To me, this is one of the saddest and most perplexing cases ever profiled on UM. I thought of a possible scenario, but I don't think it holds much water. The gallon of milk A.J. bought the night of his disappearance was never found. Could it be he bought the milk for someone else? Maybe a young mother he met through the store or at an AA meeting. He was portrayed on UM as the kind of guy who would help anyone out, and it certainly seems like something he might do. Maybe there was an altercation with a boyfriend or ex-husband when A.J. arrived at the house unexpectedly. This theory falls apart, though, if you consider the sightings of him the day after he went missing. I wish there would be a resolution to this case so his family and friends would finally know what happened.

To me, this is one of the saddest and most perplexing cases ever profiled on UM. I thought of a possible scenario, but I don't think it holds much water. The gallon of milk A.J. bought the night of his disappearance was never found. Could it be he bought the milk for someone else? Maybe a young mother he met through the store or at an AA meeting. He was portrayed on UM as the kind of guy who would help anyone out, and it certainly seems like something he might do. Maybe there was an altercation with a boyfriend or ex-husband when A.J. arrived at the house unexpectedly. This theory falls apart, though, if you consider the sightings of him the day after he went missing. I wish there would be a resolution to this case so his family and friends would finally know what happened.


I think AJ just got mixed up with the wrong crowd(drug dealers). I found it strange that as soon as his daughters found his car they were convinced he was going to be in the trunk. I think AJ is deceased and was probably killed a few days after he went missing. I hope they can at least find his remains to bring his family some kind of closure!