View Full Version : What are your top 10 Unsolved Mysteries cases?


1990 UM fan
03-09-2012, 08:35 PM
Here's mine:

- Jody Huisentruit

- Angela Hammond

- Sharon Marshall & Michael Hughes

- Lil Miss Panasoffkee

- I-70 killer

- Tara Breckenridge

- Patricia Meehan

- Morgan Nick

- John & Linda Sohus

- Amy Bradley


These cases remain unsolved (with the exception of the Sohus case). These ones stuck out the most to me. What cases stick to you?

1990 UM fan
03-09-2012, 08:41 PM
If I could add to that, I would say the Cokeville elementary school hostage episode, Tara Breckenridge and the Seattle arsonist episodes stay with me as well.

DALLASTEXAN!!
03-09-2012, 09:01 PM
Blind River Murders

Civil War Ghostsgettysburg/LA ghostsbut ive taken a tour not haunted at all

Black Dhalia

Belgium/Mexico UFOs

Elvis/Tupac/Kurt Cobain deaths

Turino Shroud

East area rapist

New Hampshire serial killer

DB cooper

Bordello Murders

DALLASTEXAN!!
03-09-2012, 09:03 PM
These 10 aren't necessarily the top 10, but ten that standout for me over different genres...

Blind River Murders

Civil War Ghostsgettysburg/LA ghostsbut ive taken a tour not haunted at all

Black Dhalia

Belgium/Mexico UFOs

Elvis/Tupac/Kurt Cobain deaths

Turino Shroud

East area rapist

New Hampshire serial killer

DB cooper

Bordello Murders
my honorable mention would be the ohio whistle blower episode, friends to the end, orange sock murders, eric tamyiasu, circleville letters, ohio truck serial killer, to name a few. too many to list 10 alone. we should do top 10 by genre.

FarinaforBrkfast
03-10-2012, 03:15 AM
My top 10:

Cindy James
Blair Adams
Katherine Korzilius
Patricia Meehan
Charles Morgan
Circleville Letters
The Wackers
The Allagash Abductions
Amy Bradley
and
I forget her name, but the young travel journalist who went missing in Jamaica.

1990 UM fan
03-10-2012, 03:31 AM
My top 10:

Cindy James
Blair Adams
Katherine Korzilius
Patricia Meehan
Charles Morgan
Circleville Letters
The Wackers
The Allagash Abductions
Amy Bradley
and
I forget her name, but the young travel journalist who went missing in Jamaica.

Claudia Kirschhoch is her name

DALLASTEXAN!!
03-10-2012, 02:07 PM
My top 10:

Cindy James
Blair Adams
Katherine Korzilius
Patricia Meehan
Charles Morgan
Circleville Letters
The Wackers
The Allagash Abductions
Amy Bradley
and
I forget her name, but the young travel journalist who went missing in Jamaica.
while it is one of the most classic segments ever profiled by UM, I don't believe the allagash abduction ever happened. i think it is a hoax.

alfiechat
03-11-2012, 12:06 AM
1. Christophe Day disappearance
2. Gord/Jackie Mcalister/Brian Majer shootings
3. Keith warren
4. Georgia Tan adoption scams
5. the reunion of Mitchell and the American GI who saved him
6. Duncan Gilmore
7. The I 70 killer
8. Wendy Camp
9. the Kennel fires
10. Gordon Page

jojo_D
03-11-2012, 08:36 AM
Orange Sock Murders
Cindy James
Kathy Hobbs
Jody Huisentruit
Joyce McLain
The Circleville Letters
Crystal Spencer
Angela Hammond
Ayleen Conway
Patricia Meehan

jetsfanmatt
03-12-2012, 03:08 PM
Las Cruzes Bowling Masacare

Blair Adams

DB Cooper

Anthonette Cayedito

Devin Williams

Ohio Prostitute Killer

I 70 Killer

Wallace Thrasher

Wadada

Kristi Krebs

DALLASTEXAN!!
03-12-2012, 08:54 PM
Las Cruzes Bowling Masacare

Blair Adams

DB Cooper

Anthonette Cayedito

Devin Williams

Ohio Prostitute Killer

I 70 Killer

Wallace Thrasher

Wadada

Kristi Krebs
Devin Williams was a weird case that's for sure. Wallace Thrasher too. You picked some good ones, just goes to show it is hard to pick just 10..

DALLASTEXAN!!
03-12-2012, 08:56 PM
Here's mine:

- Jody Huisentruit

- Angela Hammond

- Sharon Marshall & Michael Hughes

- Lil Miss Panasoffkee

- I-70 killer

- Tara Breckenridge

- Patricia Meehan

- Morgan Nick

- John & Linda Sohus

- Amy Bradley


These cases remain unsolved (with the exception of the Sohus case). These ones stuck out the most to me. What cases stick to you?
I saw amy bradley profiled on the disappeard(ID) show I believe..can't remember the name of the show. that one was very interesting. I love seeing the unsolved cases that were on UM because we get to see the updates and other aspects that may have been left off of UM. I think I've seen Molly Bish on there as well. I would really like to see the Bordello Murders profiled on the ID channel or a show that it may fit into the plot.

jetsfanmatt
03-12-2012, 09:29 PM
Devin Williams was a weird case that's for sure. Wallace Thrasher too. You picked some good ones, just goes to show it is hard to pick just 10..

Everything people listed was good too, those were the ones that have stuck out to me the most for a long time. I always still wonder though as much as I read on the internet and as much as I watch on TV I still imagine that there is a bunch of **** that we are not being fully told.

A lot of these cases if the mob or something like that is involved that they dont tell us they will probably never be solved.

detective batman
03-13-2012, 12:52 AM
Here's a few names of people whose cases have left me with suspicions.

1. Justin Burgwinkle

2. Geoffry Digman

3. David Cox

4. Chad Langford

5. Bryan Nisefeld

6. Jeremy Bright

7. Scott Johnson and Angel

8. Natasha Jennings

9. Lee Young

10. Michael Carmichael and Willy Hargrove

Jediknight1823
03-13-2012, 09:26 AM
1. Son of Sam
2. Tallman Ghost
3. Tommy Zeigler
4. Kurt Sova
5. Bentwaters UFO
6. Friends Till the End
7. Mothman
8. Flight 19
9. Ellender double homicide
10. Kurt McFall

TracyLynnS
03-13-2012, 09:48 AM
My top ten seem to change from time to time. Segments I've been interested in for the last few years:

1. Michael Hughes (Sharon Marshall, Franklin Floyd)

2. Wendy Camp, Cynthia Britto, Lisa Kregear (and the crazy Noe family)

3. Gordon Page, Jr.

4. Lisa Marie Kimmel

5. Keith Warren

6. Angela Hammond

7. Dale Kerstetter

8. Dave Bocks

9. Monika Rizzo

10. Frank Olson



Segments I was sort of obsessed with for a while when they first aired:

1. Mahfuz Huq, Christie Mutzfeld, Todd Kelly

2. Nancy Daddysman

3. Jessica Keen

4. Liz Carmichael

5. Edward Harold Bell (Larry Dickens)

6. Tami Leppert

7. Gelatinous Goo/Oakville Blobs

8. Frank Olson

9. Matt Flores

10. Spontaneous Human Combustion

Statispro1
03-13-2012, 07:03 PM
Hard to narrow it down to ten but off the top of my head I will say in random order:

1. Orange sock murders
2. Dale Kerstetter
3. Dave Bocks
4. The Wackers
5. Boys on the tracks
6. Dexter Stefonek
7. Dorothy Donovan
8. The Circleville Letters
9. The Queen Mary
10. Tallman's Ghost

I am sure I am leaving some out. I base this list on those stories I watch over and over and never tire of them.

SheRaaa
03-22-2012, 09:27 PM
For epitomizing the creepy, sad, nostalgic 80s vibe the show did so well:

-Ayleen Conway
-Tammy Leppert
-Don Kemp
-Orange Sock Murders
-Keith Reinhardt
-Kurt Sova

For an extremely baffling mystery:

-Blair Adams
-Katherine Korzilius

For humor:

-Sammy Wheeler
-The Wackers

buckeyeblogger
01-31-2013, 07:10 PM
EAR-ONS
Zodiac Killer
I-70 Killer
Ohio Truck Prostitute Killer
The Springfield Three
New Hampshire Serial Killer
The Circleville Letters
Cleveland Torso Murderer
Las Cruzes Bowling Massacre
D.B. Cooper

Necco
01-31-2013, 10:31 PM
Jeremy Bright
Little Miss Panosofkee
Sharita Harding
Jet's husband who was looking for her family (I tried to find her name on the Wiki, but failed to find her case.)
LaDonna Alfano
Mia Zapata
Loreto Chapel
The Sara Jo
William Toomey
The exploding church

idol
05-04-2015, 11:15 AM
in no particular order.

Clarence Roberts

Joe Owens

Wackers

Kurt Sova

Dorothy Donovan

Bonnie Wilder

Dave Bocks

Perm Gilbert

Dexter Stefonek

Adam Emery