So, In honor of the winter premiere tomorrow, I've had a PLL marathon on Hulu today and something just hit me, I think Spencer may have killed Ali. I know this sounds completely insane but hear me out, Spencer had a thing with Ian, we learned at the end of the summer that Ali was seeing Ian. And the night that Ali disappeared like in the first two minutes of the Pilot, Spencer was the only one gone and was saying that she was gone and had looked everywhere. I could be way off ut this idea just hit me and I wanted to share

So, In honor of the winter premiere tomorrow, I've had a PLL marathon on Hulu today and something just hit me, I think Spencer may have killed Ali. I know this sounds completely insane but hear me out, Spencer had a thing with Ian, we learned at the end of the summer that Ali was seeing Ian. And the night that Ali disappeared like in the first two minutes of the Pilot, Spencer was the only one gone and was saying that she was gone and had looked everywhere. I could be way off ut this idea just hit me and I wanted to share

This show has had so many twists and turns so your theory could be dead on. There are so many questions to be answered though. From the sneak peek it appears maybe Alison isn't dead. But I don't know, she wouldn't have faked her own death and had her parents go through a funeral like that when she was making such a deal about Aria telling her mom that Aria's dad cheated on her so I'm gonna say that was either a Hanna hallucination or dream sequence shown in the ABC Family promos.

I want to find out about who A is though. Because clearly it can't be one of the girls (like Spencer, for example) since not all the girls know every secret such as Aria's affair with Mr. Fitz - who I still think was the one to run over Hanna by accident and sped off so that nobody would realize he was with Aria. Still questions to be answered about Jenna, Toby, and I'm not sure but I'm a little bit suspicious of Maya for some reason. Also, let's not forget that snoopy cop - he could maybe be responsible and trying to throw the blame on one of the girls and then take the credit for solving the crime to up his status as a policeman. But who was in Spencer's closet that time in episode 4 or 5? I hope we get answers to all these little details and that they don't just leave some things unresolved.

I've rambled here but back to your theory - Spencer is clearly the most competitive one and seems to always be the one to tell the girls "okay, this is what we need to do" sort of thing and leading them and explaining everything all the time. But my "under the radar" pick of who may have done it is that guy who works with the yearbook comittee and befriends Hanna - I've forgotten his name because I've only re-watched the first 5. I'll go through the rest by tomorrow night though!

I can't think of his name either. It'll com to me later.

I have no clue who A could be, but I'm pretty sure that Ali is dead, I mean there's a body. Its not like a soap opera where people come back from the dead (I hope so at least or I'll lose respect for the show) But who besides Ali knows all the girls' secrets. Not just being able to be the onlooker to what the girls are doing now but also to know what has happened on the past. Such as Aria's father's affair with the student. So I have no dang clue who A is.

As far as the sneak peak that we've seen from tonight'd premiere it has to be a dream sequence with Ali. I mean the lighting is all weird like it is when they do a flashback.

I don't know I'm just excited for the new episodes so we can see what's going to happen

I can't think of his name either. It'll com to me later.

I have no clue who A could be, but I'm pretty sure that Ali is dead, I mean there's a body. Its not like a soap opera where people come back from the dead (I hope so at least or I'll lose respect for the show) But who besides Ali knows all the girls' secrets. Not just being able to be the onlooker to what the girls are doing now but also to know what has happened on the past. Such as Aria's father's affair with the student. So I have no dang clue who A is.

As far as the sneak peak that we've seen from tonight'd premiere it has to be a dream sequence with Ali. I mean the lighting is all weird like it is when they do a flashback.

I don't know I'm just excited for the new episodes so we can see what's going to happen

Lucas was his name, I remembered. My theory is that A and the killer are NOT the same person. I think the cop is A and maybe found Ali's diary or something that contained all the secrets and is using that to try to get the girls to be scared and admit something about Ali's death - the scene where he questions them and says they have rehearsed what to say and when he looks through Hanna's purse maybe foreshadow this. He's a pretty unconventional cop so I wouldn't be surprised if he was A. As for the killer, no clue but I like your Spencer theory.

Lucas was his name, I remembered. My theory is that A and the killer are NOT the same person. I think the cop is A and maybe found Ali's diary or something that contained all the secrets and is using that to try to get the girls to be scared and admit something about Ali's death - the scene where he questions them and says they have rehearsed what to say and when he looks through Hanna's purse maybe foreshadow this. He's a pretty unconventional cop so I wouldn't be surprised if he was A. As for the killer, no clue but I like your Spencer theory.

The cop being A makes a lot of sense! I like the way you think