Is Walker innocent or guilty?



And please, lets not turn this into Talk Back Live.

Can I ask a dumb question? Who's John Walker? I'm obviously slow.

Hes that American Fighting for the Taliban(Was)

How can he possibly be innocent when he was caught fighting with the Taliban?

He's guilty and I hope he dies a VERY painful death!

(Sorry if this sounds harsh, but this has affected both my family and friends.)

D

I saw that he's not going to be tried for treason: he's going to be tried for some lesser "assisting terrorists" law.

Originally posted by MLB
I saw that he's not going to be tried for treason: he's going to be tried for some lesser "assisting terrorists" law.

That isn't right. He should be charged for treason.

Originally posted by Jenny


That isn't right. He should be charged for treason.

You may be right. But he IS being tried for SOMETHING. Atleast he's being punished. Besides, the Government has bigger fish to fry. Don't forget that!

He is a pretty smart cookie, I'm hoping and praying they catch him and punish him. It's gonna take a lot of smart minds though to find him. Do you guys think they'll be able to find him, and I'm talking a time fram of by the end of January or earlier to find him?

Originally posted by Jenny
He is a pretty smart cookie, I'm hoping and praying they catch him and punish him. It's gonna take a lot of smart minds though to find him. Do you guys think they'll be able to find him, and I'm talking a time fram of by the end of January or earlier to find him?

He's clever,but not to smart. He would put his cleverness to good use solving world problems instead of creating them if he were truly intelligent. But because he is clever, it will be a bear trying to find him. Using your time frame,Jenny, I'd say January would be far to soon. Assuming he is still alive, he is most likely on the move. And he has friends. We'd probably find him dead, I doubt he'll allow us to take him any other way.

I can't guess when he may be captured(dead or alive) but I do know he WILL pay for his crimes, one way or another.

Originally posted by Jenny
...I'm hoping and praying they catch him and punish him...

I'm hoping they catch him and KILL him. I'm not usually this.. um.. harsh but still. I want him to pay for everything he did to us and all the pain he caused the rest of the world, especially the U.S. But well, what do I know. I'm only 12 :rolleyes:

He is Guilty.