View Full Version : 5 Minute Rule
PartyOfOne 05-12-2010, 10:15 PM Was there ever a period in this show's entire 5 year run when you did not see Gomer or Sgt. Carter or both? I doubt it. In contrast despite 150 episodes the only other character to evolve at all was Duke. And except for the 2 guys in the theme song and Col. Gray you can go whole seaons without seeing any of the so called "main characters." A record for an American primetime, non-cartoon sitcom show a 3 digit episode run? Just a thought.
Zoneboy 05-13-2010, 01:26 AM Which so-called main characters are you speaking of?
treky 05-14-2010, 01:33 AM yes, what main characters?
biffbronson 05-18-2010, 04:46 PM Col. Gray actually appeared less often than Corporal Boyle, who was played by Roy Stuart, once Boyle was introduced. I don't think all of Roy's appearances have been documented yet.
Other regulars at times were played by Ted Bessell, Allan Melvin, and William Christopher. Then there were the girlfriends, who appeared regularly later: Barbara Stuart and Elizabeth McRae. A pretty impressive cast.
Zoneboy 05-18-2010, 04:56 PM Col. Gray actually appeared less often than Corporal Boyle, who was played by Roy Stuart, once Boyle was introduced. I don't think all of Roy's appearances have been documented yet.
Other regulars at times were played by Ted Bessell, Allan Melvin, and William Christopher. Then there were the girlfriends, who appeared regularly later: Barbara Stuart and Elizabeth McRae. A pretty impressive cast.
Thanks but I'd like to know who PartyOfOne considers to be main characters. Of the ones you mentioned, I would consider all to qualify as main characters except the one's played by Ted Bessell ( Frankie Lombardi - 4 episodes) & William Christopher (Lester Hummel - 8 episodes.)
TeeVeeCloset 05-18-2010, 07:47 PM I don't even get the point of the post or the question? The shows stars from the opening and only credited were Jim Nabors & Frank Sutton....everyone else was on a episode by episode non-contract player. As for the character of Duke, Ronnie Schell left during the middle of the series run to do the one season series "Good Morning World". When it was cancelled they let him return. again I just don't understand your question, it's like asking during "I Love Lucy" was there ever a time for 5 minutes where you didn't see Lucille Ball or Desi Arnaz, Vivian Vance & William Frawley hardly had scenes alone, yet were considered co-stars.
1960'sTVfan 05-18-2010, 08:10 PM I've always considered Gomer Pyle USMC as basically a two man show, Jim Nabors and Frank Sutton. There was a fine cast of supporting players, but aside from Gomer and Sgt. Carter the characters most memorable are Duke and Corporal Boyle.
biffbronson 05-28-2010, 04:04 PM Thanks but I'd like to know who PartyOfOne considers to be main characters. Of the ones you mentioned, I would consider all to qualify as main characters except the one's played by Ted Bessell ( Frankie Lombardi - 4 episodes) & William Christopher (Lester Hummel - 8 episodes.)
Frankie's and Lester's appearances have not all been documented -- yet.
Ted Bessel was a regular in Season 2 and had significantly more appearances than just 4. For example, he played Frankie in the "Little Girl Blue" episode, yet is not credited at IMDb. Currently I think they have him at 8 appearances, which is still far too low.
As far as Wm. Christopher, I personally added some of the current IMDb credits and I suspect that once again, the number of appearances was far higher than he's been credited for.
PartyOfOne 06-15-2010, 10:03 PM I don't even get the point of the post or the question? The shows stars from the opening and only credited were Jim Nabors & Frank Sutton....everyone else was on a episode by episode non-contract player. As for the character of Duke, Ronnie Schell left during the middle of the series run to do the one season series "Good Morning World". When it was cancelled they let him return. again I just don't understand your question, it's like asking during "I Love Lucy" was there ever a time for 5 minutes where you didn't see Lucille Ball or Desi Arnaz, Vivian Vance & William Frawley hardly had scenes alone, yet were considered co-stars.
Well, it was slightly random and not written in the best manner. The person who said it was a two-man show was correct. You learned a lot more about Fred and Ethel in I Love Lucy than you learned about any 3rd character in GP. Where was Cpl. Boyle from? Nobody knows. Did you ever meet any family members of his? Friends? You did not. And this was a star? Plus that was 4 main characters which is twice as many as 2. I too would like an accurate count of the other "stars" on GP.
showfan 12-14-2010, 11:38 AM I don't recall specific episode titles, but there were a few episodes where Carter did not appear , it was all Gomer.
Jack Gomez 12-23-2010, 05:50 PM I just watched Dynamite Diner today and Frank Sutton doesn't appear in that one. The whole episode took place off base with Gomer and Lou Ann attempting to help two guys (crooks) start a diner business. It's a really funny episode and probably one of my top favorites of the series, which is weird because I really like Sgt. Carter. He's my favorite character on the show, but I didn't miss him this time.
|