the black and white Dick York as Darrin first season episode,and the color word for word remake of that episode with Dick Sargent as Darrin titled "No Good Deed Shall Go Unpunished"(or something like that),who do you think was the more caustic Darrin?Dick York or Dick Sargent?I would say Dick Sargent.

the black and white Dick York as Darrin first season episode,and the color word for word remake of that episode with Dick Sargent as Darrin titled "No Good Deed Shall Go Unpunished"(or something like that),who do you think was the more caustic Darrin?Dick York or Dick Sargent?I would say Dick Sargent.

Dick York by far was more caustic, Dick Sargent was actually somewhat differential to Samantha & was looking to avoid a fight & was almost demure in his response to her, while Dick York aggressively attacked Samantha verbally & went off on her so to speak & was much more animated but then he always was.

The other thing is that although a few lines of dialogue in a few scenes were the same the vast majority of the lines as in over 90% of it were new so the word for word comment re the whole episode is not accurate.

Larry Tate :)