View Full Version : If Bea hadn't left the show in 1992....


browneyes106
05-01-2009, 04:58 PM
How much longer do you think show would have lasted if Bea didn't leave in 1992?

I think it would lasted another year or two.

Mr. Television
05-01-2009, 05:00 PM
Probably one more year. The show finally fell out of the top 20 during it's last season and NBC's Saturday lineup was falling apart.

sodalake
05-02-2009, 12:46 AM
I think it would have lasted at least another year or two because Empty Nest was still running (and ran until 1995) and Golden Girls usually topped it in the ratings.

Part of the reason Golden Girls fell out of the top 20 in its last season was because NBC moved it out of its longtime 9pm/8pm CT timeslot and moved it an hour earlier at 8pm/7pm CT.

I think it would have been better to continue Golden Girls without Bea and adding a new roommate than to have done Golden Palace. Does anyone know why Golden Palace wasn't on NBC on Saturday nights instead of it being on CBS?

Mr. Television
05-02-2009, 12:51 AM
I think it would have lasted at least another year or two because Empty Nest was still running (and ran until 1995) and Golden Girls usually topped it in the ratings.

Part of the reason Golden Girls fell out of the top 20 in its last season was because NBC moved it out of its longtime 9pm/8pm CT timeslot and moved it an hour earlier at 8pm/7pm CT.

I think it would have been better to continue Golden Girls without Bea and adding a new roommate than to have done Golden Palace. Does anyone know why Golden Palace wasn't on NBC on Saturday nights instead of it being on CBS?
I'm not 100% sure but I think I read that CBS guaranteed it a full season of 22 episodes.

FBH75
05-02-2009, 12:18 PM
I would have loved to seen it run another couple of years. I think it would still have been a very popular show even in seasons 8 & 9 if it had continued to air.

80sTrivia
05-03-2009, 07:50 AM
I would say it could have gone on at least three more seasons. The show had a lot of life left in it and didn't jump the shark when Bea decided to leave the show...

browneyes106
05-04-2009, 12:01 AM
I think it would have lasted at least another year or two because Empty Nest was still running (and ran until 1995) and Golden Girls usually topped it in the ratings.

Part of the reason Golden Girls fell out of the top 20 in its last season was because NBC moved it out of its longtime 9pm/8pm CT timeslot and moved it an hour earlier at 8pm/7pm CT.

I think it would have been better to continue Golden Girls without Bea and adding a new roommate than to have done Golden Palace. Does anyone know why Golden Palace wasn't on NBC on Saturday nights instead of it being on CBS?

I agree the show could have gone with a new roommate or maybe just Blanche, Rose and Sophia living together.

HuntingtonM15
05-04-2009, 01:56 AM
I think the show had the potential to go on for at least another two seasons. I wish it would have happened.

Scoobiedoo30
05-04-2009, 02:40 AM
I say the show would have Lasted 1995

kravitzfan12
05-04-2009, 02:46 PM
Creatively, I think the show could have lasted a few more years. But in terms of ratings, I feel like it could have survived only one more year.

I'm glad that the remaining cast chose to do a spin-off versus continuing the series... I wouldn't feel right calling the show The Golden Girls without having all four of the same women there...

If they kept it just the three of them that would have been a fine continuation... but I think it was smart the way they ended the show and continued in a spin-off.

PunkyP0WER
06-27-2009, 07:20 AM
Creatively speaking, I'd say one more year. I think the quality was still there and there was still a story left to tell. However, even if Bea had stayed on the series was doomed anyway. By the time GG entered its last season NBC was undergoing a major overhaul in regards to their shows that were targeted to an older audience(*cough* 50 and up *cough*) and they wanted to shed their image as the "old" network. If you'll remember at this time NBC also canceled 'Matlock' in 1992 (which ABC picked up) and 'In The Heat of The Night' in 1992(which CBS picked up) and is also why they passed on 'The Golden Palace' and let CBS have it.

The only reason 'Empty Nest' was spared at this time was because there was some younger cast members on the show, like Dinah Manoff, Park Overall and Marsha Warfield whom they added to help retool it. They also moved them out of the hospital setting and into a "hip" inner city clinic. The initial premise of the show changed as well, originally it was about Harry adjusting to life as a widower however by the last couple seasons he seemed to become just the sounding board for Carol and Laverne's problems, whom the shows focus seemed to move on.

This was really the start of the 'Friends' era of NBC. Though it would be another 2 years before 'Friends' debuted, that is the direction the network was moving in. Johnny Carson ending his 'Tonight Show' tenure seemed to usher in a new, younger, hipper era at the peacock network. Jay Leno took over in 1992 and with 'Seinfield' hitting its stride at this time, NBC saw the opportunity for change. So you see 1992 was a year of change at NBC and Bea's departure was just a formality for GG

McGillicuddy
06-27-2009, 09:30 PM
I'm just curious, though I bought this up earlier, when they brought in Debbie Reynolds 2 years previously to replace Dorothy when she was about to remarry Stan, were they testing the idea of another actress coming on board, and why wasn't she considered to come on board later for an 8th season of GG when Bea Arthur actually did leave?

GoldenGirlsFan92
06-28-2009, 01:41 AM
I think it would have lasted one more year.

mrcashmanmiller
11-08-2009, 11:39 AM
Bea Arthur did the right thing by leaving the show after the seventh season. So many times shows drag on an on and plots are beaten to death. Like Frasier which lasted eleven seasons. Way too long. Remember Bea wanted to leave after the fifth season. But thankfully she signed on for seasons six and seven. Five seasons wouldn't have been enough, however seven was plenty. If you're a fan of a show that lasted as long as Frasier (11 seasons), Cheers (11 seasons), Friends (10 seasons), etc. didn't the plots and story lines seem more desperate and beaten to death after a while. Trust me what more could have been written for this show after seven seasons. And as stated before in 1992 NBC was undergoing a major face-lift. Now we're in 2009 and it still hasn't recovered from that move. So, basically I feel that seven golden seasons was plenty, not too many, not too few, but just right!

disdam
05-01-2010, 04:25 PM
i think 7 seasons was enough, look at the simpsons its been on since 1989 (ok 1990, first epsiode was in december 89) and seriously its time to can the simpsons, and this is coming from a long time fan of it. some times its good for a show to leave at the top of its game before the storylines get dumb, the problem with the simpsons its too popular for fox to cancel it, its their cash cow pretty much. but it cant go on forever its already been on for 20 years, the storylines started going downhill 10 years ago.

Rezny@gmail.com
05-01-2010, 05:57 PM
It could have lasted another season,if NBC had moved it back to its ORIGINAL time slot,and gone out on top-sort of-if Rose and Miles had married,Blanche had remarried,and Sophia had gone to live with an elderly man friend.That would have been a classy way to end "The Golden Girls."But,it wasn't to be.

djhsolara
05-01-2010, 06:30 PM
They did the right thing by going out the way that they did. Do I wish it would have lasted longer...certainly...but I do a comparison to another favorite of mine...Designing Women. After the "original" cast started to leave the show just wasn't the same...and finally by the last season it had truly run so far off track that it was really time to go and almost painful to watch. So I'm glad that they handled the "Girls" the way that they did.

SueAnn_Rose
05-05-2010, 10:16 AM
I think if they lasted another season or two it would have still been a hit. Shows usually drift away after a few seasons but this show was so good that I think it would have had atleast another season or two. So, I would say that the show would have gone on another year or two, like 8 or 9 seasons. But I think it ended good and it ended when it was still popular.