Why did it take so long to do this theme again? Hmm

I dont know what theyll do, but Adam will probably do Iris

Allison - i really liked this! i think i like this softer side of her better. better than Cook's version of it last year for sure :) good job overall. i still say she's the most marketable...

Anoop - he's singing like one of my favorite songs ever. i actually thought he did pretty well with it, surprisingly. i liked it. one of his best performances. that being said i still see no post-Idol potential in him at all.

Allison - Quite good. She's growing on me.

Anoop - OH EM GEE. Incredible!

Adam - LOL that was terrible...so glad Simon finally critisized him for once cause that was really bad. :x

Adam - My godddd he does the same damn thing every week -_-. I loved him at first... used to be my favorite contestant... now his routine is just getting old.

Matt - not as good as last week, pretty weak vocally. there were nice moments but it was just okay overall.

Matt - Blahhh that was way out of tune. Soooo much better last week.

Allison-Loved it

Anoop-LOVED IT

Adam-Quit ruining my fav songs, you were just growing on me

Matt-Eh

Danny - he is starting to get really boring. he has a decent voice but thats it...this is a good performance vocally but he brings nothing new to the table. he's one of the weaker ones left IMO.

Danny-vocally great, but kinda boring

Kris - pretty good but a little boring. weird song but not bad overall.

Danny - Really good. I liked it.

Kris - Boring but vocally pretty good I guess

Kris-pretty good!

Lil - it's her time to go...she started off with potential, but this was pretty terrible. she tried to create a "moment" and it failed. she is clearly the weakest one left.

Lil - Meh.

RANKINGS!!!!!!

1. ANOOP. Surprisingly.
2. Allison
3. Danny
4. Kris
5. Adam
6. Matt
7. Lil

rankings:

1. Allison
2. Anoop
-gap-
3. Kris
4. Adam (hey, it was entertaining i guess)
5. Danny
6. Matt
7. Lil

Danny, Matt, and Lil should be the bottom 3 but it will probably be Matt, Lill, and either Anoop or Kris. only Allison & Anoop were really good, everyone else was bad, blah, or average.

1. ANOOP
2.Allison
3.Kris
4. Adam ( for entertainment factor)
5. Matt
6. Danny
7. Lil

Jennifer Hudson will be there tomorrow night


Anyone smell IRONY?

1. Danny- bravo
2. Allison
3. Kris
4. Anoop- surprisingly good
5. Adam- doesn't compare to last week
6. Matt
7. Lil

I don't get what was so bad about Lil - I thought it was much better than last week. Paula loved it, Simon still hated it. I really think the judges have confused her so much to the point where she's gone out of her mind and doesn't know what to do anymore-LOL. I thought Kris was the worst of the night - he was off pitch the entires song. I can't believe no one else heard this. The first note was wayy off. He had one good performance, but I'd like to see him go now.

My favorites: Allison and Matt. Still good: Danny. I have no opinion on Anoop at all. Kris and Lil deserve the bottom 2, but not sure about the third. And Adam - he annoys me more than Sanjaya annoyed me. Watching the recaps at the end, I have no idea what people see him. He screamed the entire song, and butchered it. Any chance he'd be in the bottom 3? :lol:

I think the judges are too harsh this season than any other about originality and youthfulness. Something that judges don't see in the performances of Lil' Rounds, but other than that Lil' Rounds has been consistently AMAZING. I have a bad feeling that this diva will be gone when the diva of season 3 returns tomorrow.

My rankings:

1. Anoop
2. Kris
3. Matt
4. Allison
5. Adam
7. Lil
8. Gokey

1. Allison- Clearly the best girl this season. She totally blew me away.
2. Danny- Much, much better than last week.
3. Kris- Not his best, but he really has come a long way.
4. Anoop- I like how he made that song his own.
5. Lil- Should have gone home last week instead of Scoot.
6. Matt- See #5. I'm sick of his nasally voive.
7. Adam- Ugh! What do people see in him?

I'm barely watching this season, but I do watch a performance every now and again. I just have to say that Lil was awful last night (and most nights...). With the way she started the song, I thought it might actually be good for once, but no. I don't know what it is about her, weird pronunciations of words or something. It's really her time to go.

I think the judges are too harsh this season than any other about originality and youthfulness. Something that judges don't see in the performances of Lil' Rounds, but other than that Lil' Rounds has been consistently AMAZING. I have a bad feeling that this diva will be gone when the diva of season 3 returns tomorrow.
well good, originality and youthfulness is what it takes to make it in the record industry. the style Lil has been trying to imitate is tired and old at this point....if she tried doing a more contemporary R&B style like the judges tell her to she'd still be a front-runner. whether or not you can sing 20-year old ballads isn't going to mean anything once the show ends.

I don't get what was so bad about Lil - I thought it was much better than last week. Paula loved it, Simon still hated it. I really think the judges have confused her so much to the point where she's gone out of her mind and doesn't know what to do anymore-LOL. I thought Kris was the worst of the night - he was off pitch the entires song. I can't believe no one else heard this. The first note was wayy off. He had one good performance, but I'd like to see him go now.
actually i thought the judges have been pretty clear with Lil. they want her to sing contemporary R&B, instead she chooses to sing outdated R&B which doesn't prove she can become a successful recording artist. instead of imitating divas she should just follow the judges advice (for once, it's actually good).

not to mention her performance was vocally off.