If anyone remembers one of the earliest UM cases...about the little chior girl that seemingly vanished into thin air one night...I stumbeled upon an update on a website recently. Perhaps my memory is just fuzzy but I dont recall them even having a theory "back then"...here's the link.
http://charleyproject.org/cases/m/matthews_jonelle.html

No, I don't remember that case. That seems suspicious that the last person she spoke to was her father's acquaintance on the phone and disappeared an hour or less later--as if maybe he came over when he learned she was alone, or was checking whether she was alone for someone else to abduct. Just one theory which has probably been looked into.

I remember the case mainly because I was about the same age as her when the case aired and it scared me. I also remember it b/c they played Lionel Richie's "Hello' during the airing b/c it was the missing girl and her fathers special song. I too thought it was odd that it wasnt even mentioned wether they have inquired about the fathers friend. I mean, if he was questioned and cleared I wish they would say so so we dont have linguring suspisions!

Hey,

Are you sure this was on Unsolved Mysteries? I don't remember it. Any idea when it might have aired?