NFC

5.Jake Delhomme
4.Tavaris Jackson
3. Marc Bulger
2.Eli Manning
1.Tony Romo

AFC
5.Chad Pennington
4.Bills QB
3.Kerry Collins
2.Derek Anderson
1.Jay Cutler



Talk to me

Highly disagree. There's no reason Delhomme and Eli belong up there. And you don't even know the Bills' Quarterback's name... so why should we take this serious?

Highly disagree. There's no reason Delhomme and Eli belong up there. And you don't even know the Bills' Quarterback's name... so why should we take this serious?


That should tell you something if I don't know his name. And both Eli and Jake are BU<BLNG IDIOTS who are FRIGHTENED By defensive players and throw picks so they won;t get hit

How you left out the QB's for the Lions, Chiefs, and Bengals is beyond me.

both Eli and Jake are BU<BLNG IDIOTS who are FRIGHTENED By defensive players and throw picks so they won;t get hit

Eli has a SUPER BOWL ring and MVP.

Regardless of what happened against Philly, that can't be taken away.

Every QB who wins a Super Bowl has a bad playoff game or two- nobody's perfect.

NFC

5.Jake Delhomme
4.Tavaris Jackson
3. Marc Bulger
2.Eli Manning
1.Tony Romo
You just resent Eli Manning because he played poorly against the Eagles. Guess what? A bad player doesn't win a Super Bowl MVP.

You just resent Eli Manning because he played poorly against the Eagles.

He resents anyone who plays badly against the Iggles.

If Kurt Warner has a bad game, then he'll shoot to #1 on Sol's lisr.

I think you are basing this on some of their performance that determined their season. Jay Cutler and Derek Anderson are good. Cutler passed for over 4000 yards this season. Tony Romo and Eli manning are decent too, they turn the ball over, but who doesn't?

BTW, the Bills QB name is Trent Edwards. He started out good, but he faded like the Bills.

That should tell you something if I don't know his name. And both Eli and Jake are BU<BLNG IDIOTS who are FRIGHTENED By defensive players and throw picks so they won;t get hit

That's because the media don't talk about a market like Buffalo in a Philly market.

I think you are basing this on some of their performance that determined their season. Jay Cutler and Derek Anderson are good. Cutler passed for over 4000 yards this season. Tony Romo and Eli manning are decent too, they turn the ball over, but who doesn't?

BTW, the Bills QB name is Trent Edwards. He started out good, but he faded like the Bills.


Jay Cutler I'm sorry is not good QB. Mike Shanahan should have stuck with Jake Plummer

Jay Cutler I'm sorry is not good QB. Mike Shanahan should have stuck with Jake Plummer

You don't know how to rate players, and I think you are doing this just for the effect.

I agree with Eli. He's not bad but not great. He won a superbowl, but so did the whole team. I looked up his stats and I expected better. Delomme isn't bad as Jackson but isn't reliable or good. I think Romo is good as far as arm strength and pocket presence, but can't withstand pressure, is stupid and doesn't take repsonsibility for his losses or mistakes, and just throws it up, and expects the WR to make the catch, instead of being smart, and reliable and sometimes throwing it deep but not where the safety can grab it on the other team. I don't think you need a top 10, I think a top 5 worst of the NFL is fine

I would say

Tavaris Jackson
Where is Sage Rosenfels or Orlovsky?
Rex Grossman

those 4 are the worst, not these guys. Manning won a superbowl, and Orlovsky is a loser on a 0-16 horrible team, and doesn't know where the Out of bounds line is, Grossman is an idiot and is horrible & rosenfels or w/e the hell his name is, sucks and lost the game up 3 TDs vs. the Colts this year.

I think Romo is good as far as arm strength and pocket presence, but can't withstand pressure, is stupid and doesn't take repsonsibility for his losses or mistakes, and just throws it up, and expects the WR to make the catch, instead of being smart, and reliable and sometimes throwing it deep but not where the safety can grab it on the other team

My take on Romo:

He has good tools, is athletic, can throw, but has a tendency to make bad decisions and, when faced by a pass rush or heavy blitz, can make a boneheaded decision.

Look at the 44-6 game- two of those fumbles came on play when he held on to the ball too long. The safe thing to do is just throw the ball away.

Yeah. I think he doesn't have the brain power to know what to do, when pressured, or to just take the sack. He trys to be Whoodini, when theirs pressure in the pocket, and throw it up, but that'll never work. Instead of trying to be flawless, he makes mountains into mole hills, if you get my drift. I can't really stand his attitude either. People think he's a nice guy or whatever, but if you watch and read his post game interviews, or interviews on the sidelines after a big game or loss, and he doesn't seem phased, like it wasn't his fault. He's not angry in these interviews I speak of, but he has that T.O. look, like he's never supposed to be sacked and that the offensive line should do a better job protecting him. I remember in the Indy-Pittsburgh game at the RCA Dome, in the playoffs, coincidentally, Mike Vanderjagt's last game as a Colt. Manning got mad after the loss, and blamed the loss on the o line, and didn't take responsibility. Point is, that's what makes a bad QB from a smart or good one and that is what Romo is.

I remember in the Indy-Pittsburgh game at the RCA Dome, in the playoffs, coincidentally, Mike Vanderjagt's last game as a Colt. Manning got mad after the loss, and blamed the loss on the o line, and didn't take responsibility.

Of course, Manning got his act together and went on to win a Super Bowl the next season.

That's the difference betweena guy like Peyton and a guy liked Romo- Manning learned his lesson from defeat; Romo still hasn't.

(The next post will be my 2,000th, so I plan on creating a separate thread on top 5 players in another position- either RB or WR)

Of course, Manning got his act together and went on to win a Super Bowl the next season.

That's the difference betweena guy like Peyton and a guy liked Romo- Manning learned his lesson from defeat; Romo still hasn't.

(The next post will be my 2,000th, so I plan on creating a separate thread on top 5 players in another position- either RB or WR)

Congrats on 2k, but I do agree with that, but still think Manning is a little irked with being the pin pointed problem if his team loses. Tony Dungy just retired, but Manning hasn't blamed anybody for the SD loss, so hopefully he is doing what you mentioned, and maturing. Yet I must say, nobody can complain about a superbowl ring/championship.

Romo chokes under pressure and he looks like Gomer Pyle.

Romo chokes under pressure and he looks like Gomer Pyle.

:lol: yeah lol