Growing up in the 80's and having mad crushes on both of the girls, my friends and I would often debate which was hotter. The consensus was almost always Nicole Eggert (which I couldn't disagree with). But for some reason I had the hots more for Josie Davis. I never had an explanation why. It just was what it was. I think cause I was a quiet, dorky kid I fit better with the personality.
Now as adults, if you see pictures of them now Josie is gorgeous. (And of course Nicole is too). Both still hot.
So anyway... which did you think was hotter? Now or then.. or Now and then.

Lets make this the modern Ginger Vs Mary Ann! :P

Kosie Davis

Josie Davis of course. Sarah Powell was nice and sweet. Kind of kid that I would love to have for a friend or a sister. Yeah I was kind of a dorky kid too when I was in school. So I think I would of had a better chance for a date with Sarah over Jamie.

Nicole Eggert and its not even close.

As a kid I thought Josie was far cuter.

Nicole would only win out in seasons 2 & 3 because she had already reached physical maturity when she started the series. However, by season 4 Josie pulled far ahead in the "Mega Hottie Race"! :notworthy

Josie is sweet but Nicole Eggert wins by a thousand mile :cool: :wave:

Nicole Eggert and its not even close.

I'm guessing that Nicole was considered the "hot Powell sister" because unless you were closer to Josie's age at the time, you didn't feel as awkward crushing (Jamie Powell was kind of in the holy trinity of "hot young sitcom women in the late '80s-early '90s" along with Kelly Kapowski on Saved by the Bell and Kelly Bundy on Married...with Chlidren) on her since Nicole was more "mature". Plus, Josie while on CIC still had some baby-fat on her. Sarah Powell (at least as she got older) was more in the vein of "she's cute but not intimidatingly attractive".