...'ve gotten?


I think she woulda been runner up or winner

i dunno...that was a really, really great bunch. she probably would make top 5 or so but i dont think she'd win. i mean, if Chris Daughtry and Kat's crazy McPhans couldn't stop the Soul Patrol, i don't think ANYONE could.

i dunno...that was a really, really great bunch. she probably would make top 5 or so but i dont think she'd win. i mean, if Chris Daughtry and Kat's crazy McPhans couldn't stop the Soul Patrol, i don't think ANYONE could.
That's true!!!! Well if Taylor didnt act like a spazzed monkey hopped up on coke every week, which he shoudln't have, he wouldnt have won. He was the rich man's JPL LOL

Maybe top 3, but I dunno about winner... I mean, Taylor was never in the bottom 3... for reasons that still bewilder me.

Maybe top 3, but I dunno about winner... I mean, Taylor was never in the bottom 3... for reasons that still bewilder me.
I think its for the exact reason I said in my first post in here

I dunno, but she wouldn't have won. the Soul Patrol was unstoppable.

Wow, Carly could have been on in Season 5? Well, I think she would have gotten sixth place.

Wow, Carly could have been on in Season 5? Well, I think she would have gotten sixth place.
yeah, she auditioned but was disqualified because her Visa expired or something.