This is kinda an old article, but I wanted to share it:
http://www.ew.com/ew/article/0,,20008701,00.html

While I agree that most of the choices were incredible performances, I want to shoot whoever picked the #1 :mad: :mad: :mad: someone needs to show them a video of Clay Aiken's "Bridge Over Troubled Water" or Kelly Clarkson's "Natural Woman".... and then see if they can still say their choice for #1 is better.

this is a pretty messed up list...i mean Jennifer's "Circle of Life" being #5? it was a good performance, but the fifth best ever? i dont think so. and "Summertime" is SO not the best Idol performance ever. if it was that amazing then why isnt Fantasia selling millions now? lol. and Elliott's "A Song For You" being #3? again, a good performance, but not the third best ever.

but the biggest problem is the lack of Carrie's "Alone"...wtf?

if I had to make a top 10 list :p it would be like this

1) Carrie Underwood - Alone
2) Kelly Clarkson - Stuff Like That There
3) Chris Daughtry - Renegade
4) Clay Aiken - Bridge Over Troubled Water
5) Constantine Maroluis - Bohenium Rhapsody
6) David Archuleta - Smoky Mountain Memories (yes, i think it was that good)
7) Jordin Sparks - I Who Have Nothing
8) Bo Bice - In a Dream
9) Kelly Clarkson - Without You
10) Katharine McPhee - Somewhere Over the Rainbow

Yeah that is a messed up list although Chris's Hemmorhage was AWESOME,, Dont know if I have a top 10, but Id agree with Joe's #1 choice

And Constantine's Bohemian Rhapsody was great too.