I'd love to see a showdown between Michael Johns and David Cook. Both deserve to win.

David Archuleta and one of those other 8 people.

LOlol no seriously. i dont really care who else is in it as long as David is there. but Brooke is my second favorite so i guess i'll go with her. or Carly, or Michael. or anyone but David Cook cause i cant stand him.

David Archuleta & Kristy Lee Cook (yeah, sue me).

David Archuleta & Kristy Lee Cook (yeah, sue me).


As of right now, I'd like to see Syesha & David A. I might change my mind
between now & then, however!

Same with Joe, as usual, although Im partial towards David A and Carly, and them and Brooke should be the top 3

I've said this from the beginning... it will most likely be David A. vs David C.

HOWEVER, I'd love it if it were David A. and Carly!

But I would really like him to win...and I think he could beat any of the other contestants not mentioned above lol so anyone else would be fine too.

I've said this from the beginning... it will most likely be David A. vs David C.

HOWEVER, I'd love it if it were David A. and Carly!

But I would really like him to win...and I think he could beat any of the other contestants not mentioned above lol so anyone else would be fine too.
Ditto, David should win :D

Either Carly and Brooke
Brooke and David C.
or Carly and David C.

Cook and Archuleta in the final two would own. Though Johns is my second fave, I can't see him in the finale. :(

All that matters is that Davey Archuleta is there. The rest should just sit in the audience and clap as he sings the winner's single. :)

All that matters is that Davey Archuleta is there. The rest should just sit in the audience and clap as he sings the winner's single. :)
LOL yeah

I would like to see either
Brooke and David A
Brooke and David C
Brooke and Carly

But I would love if Brooke won. I know she hasn't done her best these past few weeks but she would be perfect for and American Idol. I mean she does well with songs like when she did that Carly Simon one Your so Vain. She needs to do more songs like that. But another reason I want her to win is because she would be a great role model for kids unlike Brittney and Paris Hilton (hopefully now that she is a mom she will be better). She has such a great personality and she comes across as a good girl, we need more celebrities for our kids to look up to like her. That's why I want Brooke to be the next American Idol

i love Brooke, but i just don't think she's good enough to win. plus if she won, she'd be forced to put out a generic pop album that would probably fail. i'd much rather see her get 3rd or 4th so she can stick to her own style on her album.

David Archuleta and one of those other 8 people.

LOlol no seriously. i dont really care who else is in it as long as David is there. but Brooke is my second favorite so i guess i'll go with her. or Carly, or Michael. or anyone but David Cook cause i cant stand him.
Damn Joe, I agree 100%!!! LOL

I WANT Arch and Brooke to be the final two, but sadly, I don't think Brooke will make it all the way to the season finale. I think she'll be in the top 5 though. She better be!