I know it's a little early to start one of these threads, but I'm hella bored. :o :lol:

My picks (In order of my faves, I guess :p ):

David Cook
Fave: Billie Jean (top 10)
Least Fave: Happy Together (top 24) [Even I liked that one though]

Michael Johns
Fave: We Will Rock You + We Are the Champions (top 10)
Least Fave: Go Your Own Way (top 20)

Ramiele Malubay
Fave: I Should Have Known Better (top 11)
Least Fave: Alone (top 10) [But LOL, I liked that one too]

Carly Smithson
Fave: Come Together (top 12)
Least Fave: The Show Must Go On (top 8)

David Archuleta
Fave: Angels (top 8)
Least Fave: We Can Work This Out (top 12)

Jason Castro
Fave: Halleujah (top 16)
Least Fave: Michelle (top 11)

David Hernandez
Fave: It's All Coming Back to Me Now (top 16)
Least Fave: I Saw Her Standing There (top 12)

Chikezie
Fave: I Believe to My Soul (top 20)
Least Fave: I Love You More Today than Yesterday (top 24)

Syesha Mercado
Fave: I Believe (top 8)
Least Fave: Got to Get You Into My Life (top 12)

Brooke White
Fave: You're So Vain (top 20)
Least Fave: Here Comes the Sun (top 11)

Amanda Overmyer
Fave: I Hate Myself for Loving You (top 16)
Least Fave: Carry On Wayward Son (top 20)

Kristy Lee Cook
Fave: God Bless the USA (top 10)
Least Fave: Eight Days a Week (top 12)

these threads are awesome. :woohoo:

David Archuleta
Favorite: Smoky Mountain Memories (top 9)
Least Favorite: We Can Work it Out (top 12)

Brooke White
Favorite: Let it Be (top 12)
Least Favorite: Here Comes the Sun (top 11)

Carly Smithson
Favorite: Come Together (top 12)
Least Favorite: The Show Must Go On (top 8)

Michael Johns
Favorite: We Are the Champions (top 10)
Least Favorite: A Day in the Life (top 11)

Ramiele Malubay
Favorite: You Don't Have to Say You Love Me (top 24)
Least Favorite: In My Life (top 12)

Jason Castro
Favorite: Somewhere Over the Rainbow (top 8)
Least Favorite: Michelle (top 11)

Chikezie
Favorite: She's a Woman (top 12)
Least Favorite: whatever he sang top 10 week

David Hernandez
Favorite: Papa Was a Rolling Stone (top 20)
Least Favorite: I Saw Her Standing There (top 12)

David Cook
Favorite: Billie Jean (top 10)
Least Favorite: Always Be My Baby (top 7)

Syesha Mercado
Favorite: I Will Always Love You (top 9)
Least Favorite: I Believe (top 8)

Kristy Lee Cook
Favorite: Anyway (top 8)
Least Favorite: Eight Days a Week (top 12)

Amanda Overmyer
Favorite: I Hate Myself for Loving You (top 16)
Least Favorite: Carry On My Wayward Son (top 20)

i think thats all of them?

I pretty much only remember my faves, so here they are:

David Cook: Eleanor Rigby
Brooke White: Let it Be
Carly Smithson: Come Together

Brooke's definitely takes the gold, though. At least with "Let it Be".

eh right now I'm too lazy to think about what my least favorite for everyone is :lol: so i'm just doing favorites.

David Arch - The Long and Winding Road
David Cook - Day Tripper
Jason - Michelle (okay, NOT the performance on the show, but listen to the studio recording.. incredible)
Michael - We Will Rock You/We Are the Champions
Ramiele - You Don't Have to Say You Love Me
Carly - Come Together
Brooke - Let it Be
Kristy - God Bless the USA
Chikezie - I've Just Seen a Face
David H - In the Midnight Hour
Amanda - I Hate Myself for Loving You
Syesha - to be honest, I don't think any were really that memorable to me... MAYYYYBE if I had to choose, then Yesterday

My favorites so far:

David Archuleta - The Long & Winding Road (Top 11)
Kristy Lee Cook - God Bless the USA (Top 10)
Michael Johns - We Are The Champions (Top 10)
Ramiele Malubay - You Don't Have To Say You Love Me (Top 24)
Amanda Overmyer - I Hate Myself For Loving You (Top 16)
Carly Smithson - Come Together (Top 12)

I EDITED MINE. :)

I edited a couple of mine too, LOL.

David Archuleta
Favorite: Angels
Least Fav: We Can Work It Out


Brooke White:
Fav: Let It Be
Least Fav : Here Comes the Sun


Carly Smithson:
Fav: Come Together
Least Fav : The Show Must Go On


Michael Johns
Fav: We Will Rock You/ We Are the Champions
Least Fav:Go Your Own Way



David Cook
Fav: Billie Jean
Least Fav: Happy Together , shoulda done My Generation or something that week

Ramiele Malubay
Fav : You Don't Have to Say You Love Me
Leats Fav: In My Life

Jason Castro :
Fav : Over the Rainbow
Least Fav: Michelle


Syesha Mercado :
Fav: Yesterday
Least Fav : I Believe, though it was heaps better than fantasia's version, and she snag it originally


Chikeze
Fav: She's a Woman
Least Fav : His top 11 and 10 weeks ones


Kristy Lee Cook

Fav: Anyway
Least Fav : Eight Days a Week


Amanda Overmyer
Fav: I Hate myself For loving you
Least Fav: Carry On Wayward Son


David Hernandez
Fav : Papa Was a Rolling Stone
Least Fav: I Saw Her Standing There