I was just thinking this, let's say they had a thing with all 6 winners so far, and they snag and everyone voted on theultimate winner, who would win?

id say it would be between Kelly, Carrie and Jordin, with Kelly or Carrie winning

Kelly... definitely. The only other person who comes close to her is Carrie. All the rest stand no chance :D

Kelly was the most consistent performer on AI ever, so...her.

i think Carrie has a stronger voice though so she might win too.

i'd say it would rank:

6) Taylor
5) Ruben
4) Fantasia
3) Jordin
2) Carrie
1) Kelly

with 1-2 possibly being switched.

CARRIE! Check out the siggy. :D

Carrie Underwood, with Kelly Clarkson a close 2nd.

With the way their careers are currently going...Carrie would win hands down. The girl cannot be stopped.

I would rank:

1. Kelly
2. Carrie
3. Jordin
4. Ruben
5. Taylor
6. Fantasia

Although Kelly and Carrie are the only two that I actually really liked, and only Kelly is the one that I REALLY liked.

I like Taylor the best, but I think Carrie would probably win.