Both women had personal issues, but I will say Evelyn was more for him because Donna had other men on her list after Fred, and I didn't think that was respectful. She seemed like she was on borrowed time with Fred. Evelyn seemed a bit lonley and Fred gave her that companionship and personality she needed. She didn't seemed like she would disrespect Fred in anyway.

I find Evelyn to be much more likeable than Donna

Evelyn sure was kinder to Fred than Donna was and she gave him a lot more attention. Donna would turn on him on a dime and was always too busy to give him much TLC.

I'm going with the majority - Evelyn. By the way, did Fred and Donna ever marry? I don't think they did but I'm not sure.

I say Evelyn no Fred and Donna nevery did get Marryied

I vote for Evelyn, she seemed more likeable.

I think Fred and Donna ALMOST got married, but aunt Esther ruined the wedding.