View Full Version : Oxnard school shooting called a hate crime


ABlairican Pie
02-17-2008, 01:45 PM
Los Angeles Times

Oxnard school shooting called a hate crime


Phil McCarten / Associated Press

http://www.latimes.com/media/photo/2008-02/35640897.jpg
Students pass by a makeshift memorial honoring fifteen-year-old Lawrence King which lies beneath the flagpole at E.O. Green School Thursday, Feb. 14, 2008.

14-year-old is charged in shooting of Oxnard classmate

By Catherine Saillant and Amanda Covarrubias, Los Angeles Times Staff Writers
February 15, 2008

Ventura County prosecutors charged a 14-year-old boy with the shooting death of a classmate Thursday and said the killing in an Oxnard classroom was a premeditated hate crime.

Senior Deputy Dist. Atty. Maeve Fox declined to discuss a motive in the shooting or why prosecutors added the special allegation of a hate crime against Brandon McInerney, who was charged as an adult.


BRANDON McINERNEY
click to enlarge



Photo Gallery
Oxnard school shooting



Map


Related Stories
- Student shot in Oxnard
- Oxnard student declared brain dead

But classmates of the slain boy, Lawrence King, said he recently had started to wear makeup and jewelry and had proclaimed himself gay. Several students said King and a group of boys, including the defendant, had a verbal confrontation concerning King's sexual orientation a day before the killing.

King, 15, was declared brain-dead and was expected to be taken off a ventilator late Thursday so organs could be removed for donation, said Craig Stevens, senior county deputy medical examiner.

King was shot in the head early Tuesday in a classroom full of students at E.O. Green Junior High School. Police said the suspect fled and was apprehended a few blocks away.

McInerney's family was in a Ventura courtroom Thursday as the adolescent was brought into a holding chamber to face charges.

His arraignment was delayed to give his attorney time to review the police investigation before entering a plea.

McInerney was charged with premeditated murder with enhancements of use of a firearm and a hate crime.

Because he is a minor, McInerney will remain in Juvenile Hall and be taken to the Ventura courtroom for court appearances, Fox said. He is being held in lieu of $770,000 bail.

If convicted, McInerney could face 50 years to life. The hate crime enhancement would add another one to three years to his sentence.

"In Ventura County, we've never had a violent shooting like this," Fox said. "It's very tragic."

The defendant's family declined to talk to reporters, rushing out of the courthouse after a short hearing. But his attorney, Brian Vogel, said McInerney and the boy's family also were hurting.

"Both Brandon and the family are terribly sad to learn [King] is brain-dead," he said.

Vogel declined to discuss the case but said he would ask the court to move it back into the juvenile system. McInerney had no criminal history and was generally a good student at E.O. Green, where he was an eighth-grader.

Vogel said the boy turned 14, the legal cutoff for charging an adolescent as an adult, on Jan. 24. Voters gave prosecutors the option of charging teenage suspects as adults under 2002's Proposition 21.

Details on the backgrounds of both boys began to emerge Thursday. King was a foster child living at Casa Pacifica, a shelter for abused and troubled children in Camarillo.

Steven Elson, executive director at Casa Pacifica, said he could not discuss how long King had lived there or the circumstances involving his removal from his family.

But Elson said King had made many friends on the sprawling residential campus and that many of the children were grieving his loss.

"It's been a sad couple of days here," Elson said.

King's father, who lives in Oxnard, declined to comment.

Student Averi Laskey, 13, said she had known King since grammar school and liked him. She said that only in the last two weeks had he begun dressing in a feminine manner.

"Even if he was different, he didn't deserve it," she said.


BRANDON McINERNEY
click to enlarge



Photo Gallery
Oxnard school shooting



Map


Related Stories
- Student shot in Oxnard
- Oxnard student declared brain dead

Laskey said King was happy at Casa Pacifica, although he had to take a long bus ride to and from school every day. He said he grew up in a troubled home, she said.

"He never felt like he had a family, but he told me when he got to Casa Pacifica that he had one there," Laskey said.

Laskey said she also knew McInerney and had shared an English honors class with him.

"Everyone knows this was wrong," she said of the shooting. "You don't think of your friend as being a killer. You don't think of your friend as a hater. That's what's weird about this. . . . I don't think he quite knew what he was doing."

Authorities said McInerney sneaked a handgun into school on the day of the shooting, but they have not disclosed how he got the firearm.

McInerney's family lives in the south Oxnard neighborhood near E.O. Green school. Court records show that his father, Bill McInerney, has had brushes with the law in recent years.

In 2000, he pleaded no contest to disturbing the peace in July, and a few months later to a single count of domestic abuse. McInerney was given 10 days in jail and 36 months' probation for the abuse conviction, records show.

In 2002, he pleaded guilty to drunk driving and being an unlicensed driver. He served five days in jail and was fined.

The case is drawing attention from a growing number of gay rights groups, which said they would be watching developments closely.

"In the 15-year history of this organization, this is the first time we've seen the district attorney act this swiftly and clearly to say 'This will not be tolerated,' " said Jay Smith, executive director of the Ventura County Rainbow Alliance, a nonprofit group that advocates for gay, lesbian, bisexual and transgender rights.

"We're assuming that the hate crime component has to do with [King's] sexuality," Smith said. "Because of that, we are very eager to see the district attorney follow through."

Smith said King had participated in Friday night rap sessions at the alliance's offices in Ventura. The sessions are for youths ages 13 to 23 regardless of their sexual orientation, Smith said.

Smith said the middle school and the district must go beyond providing general and vague lessons on diversity. "It's more than just education; it's about acceptance, not just tolerance," he said.

"The big question I have is: Was the school equipped to have a student like Larry in attendance?" Smith said.

Hueneme School District officials said they were aware of friction between the two boys and had offered counseling to both.

catherine.saillant

@latimes.com

amanda.covarrubias

@latimes.com

Times staff writers Paul Pringle and Gregory W. Griggs contributed to this report.

Penny Lane
02-17-2008, 04:09 PM
Words cannot express.

How tragic!:(

InspectorExstead
02-17-2008, 10:33 PM
so sad...
and the boy was only 14. to have his life taken away from him when he was so young is such a tragedy.

waichingliu81
02-18-2008, 03:23 PM
this incident goes to show that society has a long way to go in tackling hate crimes, such as racism and homophobia. as for 50 years in jail, it's not enough. how about life instead, or the electric chair? this bigot is a disgrace to mankind. never mind homosexuality being sick, homophobia is sick, no make that sicker :mad:

TripperFan
02-18-2008, 03:40 PM
It kills me that the media use this term now "Hate Crime". Sorry, but to me, when is a crime ever friendly?!?!

You go on a shooting spree because you're happy, carefree and love the world? Crime = Hate - period. duh :rolleyes:

friendsfan77
02-18-2008, 05:06 PM
this incident goes to show that society has a long way to go in tackling hate crimes, such as racism and homophobia. as for 50 years in jail, it's not enough. how about life instead, or the electric chair? this bigot is a disgrace to mankind. never mind homosexuality being sick, homophobia is sick, no make that sicker :mad:
that guy never deserves to walk the streets again :mad:

Ireneparalegal
02-18-2008, 05:09 PM
This occurred in my city. :(

You cannot imagine the grief that has taken over the city and the anger at this so-called kid who did this.

Let me let you in on some information. My daughter's co-worker is related to the shooter's family (second cousin's) and she told my daughter that the murderer had SHOT A GUN AT A FAMILY MEMBER BEFORE, BUT NO ONE REPORTED IT. The father and grandfather have guns in the home and they also have some hatred towards non-whites and gays. :mad:

As I would pass by the hospital where this child lay, I would say a prayer and hope to God he would survive. Unfortunately he didn't.

Mikado
02-18-2008, 07:08 PM
I can just imagine how this tragedy has hit your town Irene; has any group come out to defend the actions of the shooter? (I'm certainly not on his side but, I'm just curious as to whether it's been a decisive issue there)

Ireneparalegal
02-18-2008, 07:19 PM
So far there has been NO ONE to defend the shooter. I am so proud of my city for pouring their hearts out, supporting the victim's family and for the overall attitude of "We won't tolerate this in our schools or city." There is a trust fund set up in one of the banks and we donated to that. I am sure the medical bills and the funeral costs are the first thing that will be paid with the help of that trust fund. Over the weekend there were vigils and there was a peace march that took place and they stopped at our local park where we have our war veterans memorial. Everyone held hands and this large group circled the entire park. People of all races, kids carrying signs, it was a powerful presence. Too bad I was sick or else I would have been there with my kids. This really hits close to home since I have a daughter who is gay and she dresses like a guy. How do I know my daughter is safe? Who the hell is anyone to decide what is normal and what is not? Who the hell is anyone to pick who shall die because they are "different"?

The shooter had told a fellow student the day this occurred that Larry (the victim) was "having his last day." She had no idea what he meant and now is dealing with the guilt. She feels she could have prevented this.

Ireneparalegal
02-22-2008, 09:22 PM
Lawrence King was laid to rest a few days ago. Before he was taken off of life support, his parents donated all of his major organs.

Today there was a memorial held at one of the local churches. The media is out there in droves. This murder has really stunned everyone and yet, the outpouring of love and compassion doesn't shock me. People are upset, angry and disgusted at this. There have been several memorials and peace marches taking place all over California in memory of Lawrence King. There was one in San Francisco.
Here is one article abt one march that took place here last week:

1,000 hit Oxnard streets to remember Larry King
Calling for peace
By Kathleen Wilson (Contact)
Sunday, February 17, 2008


Marchers comfort each other during Saturday's event, held in memory of 15-year-old Larry King, who died after he was shot during class at E.O. Green School in Oxnard. A 14-year-old student has been charged in the slaying.

Close to 1,000 people, many of them schoolmates of slain student Larry King, marched in Oxnard on Saturday to honor the eighth-grader who was shot last week in his junior high classroom.

The Hueneme High students who organized the march were overjoyed at the turnout.

"I'm so happy," said Courtney La Forest, 16, who spearheaded the 3-mile march along with Hueneme student Melissa Crutcher, 16. "We were expecting a big turnout but nothing compared to this."

The march started from a park behind E.O. Green School, the campus where the 15-year-old was shot in the head Tuesday, allegedly by another student in his class. King was declared brain dead the next day and removed from life support Thursday after his family donated his organs.

Prosecutors have charged 14-year-old Brandon McInerney with murder and a hate crime against King, who told friends he was teased because he was gay. McInerney, who is being tried as an adult, has not yet entered a plea and remains in custody in lieu of $770,000 bail.

Authorities have not released details on a motive, and prosecutors have declined to elaborate on the hate crime charge.

Crutcher said she began planning the march the day King was shot at the Oxnard junior high in the hopes of sending a message of acceptance.

The teens spread the word through fliers, word of mouth and MySpace. Crutcher hoped to influence at least one person with the event.

"I want to have at least one person be tolerant of other people and not be scared to be themselves," Crutcher said after the event concluded at Plaza Park in downtown Oxnard.

The marchers lined the sidewalk along C Street for more than a mile as they walked to the park, drawing honks from motorists on the street.

Several wore T-shirts emblazoned with the smiling boy's picture from the school yearbook. Some carried roses, held balloons aloft or wore clothing promoting acceptance of varying sexual orientations.

After arriving downtown on the brisk sunny day, the crowd formed a circle around Plaza Park. They yelled "Larry, Larry, Larry," then observed a moment of silence.

Along with students, the marchers included parents, board members of Parents of Murdered Children, and elected officials.

But most were youths, moved by what had happened to the boy their age and hoping to make the world a more tolerant place.

"I hope we can affect it," said Yvette Diaz, 15, a student at Oxnard High. "That's pretty messed up — what happened to him. It's not right."

Ireneparalegal
02-22-2008, 09:34 PM
Here is a website set up by a friend of the family. There are pictures and you can post your comments for the family:

http://www.rememberlarry.com/