Can't sleep tonight and just for fun I googled Glenn Consagra's name and I actually managed to stumble upon the homepage for the private investigator who was featured in the segment: Steve Milwee

Milwee has written a little blurb about Consagra on his page mentioning it was featured on UM and that Consagra was released from prison in the early 1990s and died in 1996.

I know we know all this information already but Millwee also lists his email address at the bottom of the page. I know many are interested in this case, so I thought I'd list his page here in case anyone wanted to contact him to get more details on Consagra's case and perhaps some of Millwee's theories on who in fact committed the "Honeymoon Island" murders:

http://www.securtest.com/forensichypnosis.htm

Very interesting DD! Well, this guy seems pretty good from what I have seen on his webpage. However he did make one error, where he mentioned that Unsolved Mysteries was hosted by the late Karl Malden, I am assuming he meant Robert Stack as Karl Malden is still alive, Malden turns 96 this year.

Very interesting DD! Well, this guy seems pretty good from what I have seen on his webpage. However he did make one error, where he mentioned that Unsolved Mysteries was hosted by the late Karl Malden, I am assuming he meant Robert Stack as Karl Malden is still alive, Malden turns 96 this year.

He must have said that because Glen Consagra was profiled on one of the Pre-Stack Specials that Karl Malden hosted. :)

I emailed Millwee a year or so ago just asking some basic questions about the outcome of the case and I never received a response. I have spoken with members of Consagra's family and I can assure you that despite what the website implies, his name was never officially cleared. Consagra was paroled in 1992.

I just sent him an email with a link to our board so maybe he'll post.