View Full Version : Cast Your Vote For Chicago Tribune's Top 25 Worst TV Shows Ever


Zoneboy
10-30-2007, 05:04 AM
Link (http://www.chicagotribune.com/chi-071024worst_tv,0,1040095.story?coll=chi-leisure-utl)


This week, CBS canceled its bankrupt casino drama "Viva Laughlin," which some have called one of the worst TV shows ever. Which got us to thinking. Here, then, is our list of The 25 Worst TV Shows Ever. Let the debate begin.

"You're in the Picture" (1961). Jackie Gleason appeared in a prime time quiz show, but it was so bad the quiz format was dropped after one airing and it became instead a short-lived talk show. Even Gleason knew it was bad: "I've seen bombs in my day, but this one made the H-bomb look like a 2-inch salute."

"Petticoat Junction" (1963-'70). Some shows from that era hold up remarkably well -- either as sweet nostalgia or entertaining camp. Not this one, set in Hooterville.

"My Mother the Car" (1965-66). In it, Jerry Van Dyke's mother was reincarnated as a talking automobile, the voice supplied by Ann Sothern. Actually made it through one season.

"Turn-On" (1969). Illegitimate son of "Laugh-In." Lasted one episode.

"Ernest Angley Hour" (1973-present). Broadcast from Cuyahoga Falls, Ohio, Angley's Southern rural lisp deliveries are syndicated worldwide. While he doesn't claim to be a faith healer, his trademark palm-of-the-hand to the forehead is accompanied by his high-pitched shout "Be heeeeaaaalllled!" as the healee drops to the floor, to be caught by an assistant.

"B.J. and the Bear" (1979-81). Comedy/adventure about an itinerant trucker who traveled the nation's highways with his pet chimpanzee.

"When Things Were Rotten" (1975). Created by Mel Brooks. Hoo boy. Lasted a half season. Brooks used the same Robin Hood theme in the 1993 movie "Men in Tights."

"Mr. T. and Tina" (1976). Starring Pat Morita (who also played Arnold on "Happy Days"). Canceled after five episodes.

"The Ropers" (1979-80). An entire show built around the landlords from the nearly as awful "Three's Company."

"Joanie Loves Chachi" (1982-83). Scott Baio's addition to "Happy Days" was a classic jump-the-shark moment; here the shark goes belly up and begins to smell.

"Mama's Family" (1983-90). The Vickie Lawrence skit was the weak link on "The Carol Burnett Show." So, naturally, it got a weekly half-hour.

"Manimal" (1983). NYU prof could change into any animal to help fight crimes. Show turned into a turkey.

"Mr. Belvedere" (1985-90). Starred Bob Uecker -- need we say more?

"Small Wonder" (1985-89): Robot scientist builds robot in the shape of a 10-year-old girl, then tries to hide her amid his family. Theme-song quote: "She's fantastic/Made of plastic."

"Life With Lucy" (1986). Lucille Ball's final, disastrous short-lived series. It lasted only a few months but still tarnished the TV icon's legacy.

"Beauty and the Beast" (1987-90). The pretty gal and ugly critter didn't just love each other; they solved crimes!

"Cop Rock" (1990). Steven Bochco, apparently bored with making legitimate cop series ("Hill Street Blues"), decided it would be fun to have cops sing, and it would be even more fun to have them performing legit, hard-core cop work while they did it.

"Pink Lady and Jeff" (1980): Quite possibly the most demented variety show of all time, this bizarre offering paired two Japanese pop singers who spoke almost no English with comedian Jeff Altman. Hilarity did not ensue

"The 100 Lives of Black Jack Savage" (1991). A 17th Century pirate trans-whatevered to modern times has to save a life for every one he's taken. Which, come to think of it, is the same plot as "My Name Is Earl."

"The Jerry Springer Show" (1991 to present). His aim is low.

"Barney & Friends" (1992-present). Yes, some little kids love it. But parents helped compile this list, and it annoys the heck out of us.

"Homeboys from Outer Space" (1996-97). The name was a tip-off.

"The Secret Diary of Desmond Pfeiffer" (1998). A black British gentleman run out of England for cheating takes a job as a butler to Abraham Lincoln. And it was a comedy. And it made fun of slavery.

XFL (2001). NBC and Pro wrestling decide football isn't entertaining enough the way it is. They are wrong.

"Cavemen" (2007): We'll take this insurance commercial, see, only we'll make it 30 times as long! No, not the one with the lizard.

comedyfreak
10-30-2007, 07:55 AM
I disagree with their choice of Petticoat Junction, it lasted 7 seasons and did good in the ratings. They don't know what they're talking about!:mad:

JulieSomoski
10-30-2007, 04:16 PM
yeah, Petticoat Junction should definitely not be up there. As much as I hate mama's Family, I don't think it should be up there either, since it was actually reincarnated in syndication. Same for The Ropers. Even though it lasted a season and 6 episodes, it wasn't nearly as bad as Three's a Crowd.

dawsongirl
10-30-2007, 08:55 PM
Agreed with all posters about Petticoat Junction. Wasn't the greatest show ever, but far from the worst.

I do agree with Life with Lucy. God...half the cast couldn't even act. That blond who played her daughter was the worst. Small Wonder was pretty badly acted as well. I've seen better HS plays.

eltonfan80
10-30-2007, 09:09 PM
what about homes and yo yos

Ireneparalegal
10-30-2007, 09:12 PM
How can they say The Ropers and then say "nearly as awful as Three's Company"? Three's Company was a hit and a great show. It was the original FRIENDS.

Mama's Family was a hit and lasted a great deal of time on the air for a reason: it was funny.

Mr. Belvedere I thoroughly enjoyed.

Petticoat Junction is right up there with Green Acres and Andy Griffith. What the hell is wrong with these people????

The rest of the list is what belongs in that other thread YOUR 25 WORST SHOWS OF ALL TIME.

Zoneboy
10-30-2007, 09:23 PM
One thing they failed to mention was that even though When Things were Rotten only lasted half a season, It was loved by most critics. This was one show that I looked forward each week to watching when I was a kid. Comedy Central aired reruns several years ago and they were just as enjoyable as I remembered them so along with the others already mentioned, This one has no business being on the list.

Mikado
10-30-2007, 09:25 PM
I liked when things were rotten also!

OH Nuts!
10-30-2007, 10:23 PM
yeah, Petticoat Junction should definitely not be up there. As much as I hate mama's Family, I don't think it should be up there either, since it was actually reincarnated in syndication. Same for The Ropers. Even though it lasted a season and 6 episodes, it wasn't nearly as bad as Three's a Crowd.

Well the Tribune has a right to their opinion but I think they're way off about Petticoat Junction. Bea Benederet was a great actress and voice over artist, and to me, Kate Bradley was an endearing character. I also liked Mama's Family thought nowhere's near as much as Petticoat Junction.

And why wasn't the Pruitts of Southampton on the list????

HugeTVFan
10-30-2007, 11:00 PM
I saw the top 10/15 or so in the actual paper. It's funny that everyone says Barney is bad and Jerry Springer. Yes, Jerry Springer is trailer-trash but it's number one on everybody's list. And Petticoat Junction? Wow. And Three's Company is awful? Mama's Family? Who wrote this list? Some of these shows are popular....they probably just should've made it a list of the worst one-year wonders.

bencasey
10-30-2007, 11:44 PM
The Munsters Today was the worst show I've ever seen in my life. Other shows that should be on the list:

Ugliest Girl in Town
It's About Time
Me and the Chimp
Grindl
Tammy Grimes Show

All of those are far worse than My Mother the Car. Petticoat Junction does not belong on the list. Gilligan's Island is a much worse show than PJ is.

Dean Winchester
10-31-2007, 12:12 AM
go Pink Lady!!! worst show ever, I have the DVD too

catlover79
10-31-2007, 12:24 AM
^ I've seen Pink Lady, too, and it IS a clunker. I borrowed the DVDs from my then-boss, who at the time had a side gig hosting a pop-culture radio show.

I can't BELIEVE they did not include My Big Fat Greek Life...EASILY the worst show I've ever seen!! puke: They should've just left the movie alone!!

As a kid, I LOVED Mr. Belvedere - although I haven't seen it in years. Why isn't THAT show on DVD??? :mad: I enjoyed Mama's Family as well.

I am quite familiar with Ernest Angley - his show is taped about an hour south of where I live. I've caught bits and pieces of it flipping past various channels. He is a REALLY creepy guy, imo. *shudders*

I've never seen Manimal, but I'd love to.

XFL...:rofl: :brent

JT
10-31-2007, 06:30 PM
The Chicago Tribune is welcome to their opinion. But I don't see why they think *their* opinion needs to be printed for millions to see. What would be the difference between them printing theirs and me printing mine?

friendsfan77
10-31-2007, 07:30 PM
As a kid, I LOVED Mr. Belvedere - although I haven't seen it in years. Why isn't THAT show on DVD??? :mad:
I agree. Mr. Belvedere was awesome.

Mr. Television
10-31-2007, 07:35 PM
How can they say The Ropers and then say "nearly as awful as Three's Company"? Three's Company was a hit and a great show. It was the original FRIENDS.

Mama's Family was a hit and lasted a great deal of time on the air for a reason: it was funny.

Mr. Belvedere I thoroughly enjoyed.

Petticoat Junction is right up there with Green Acres and Andy Griffith. What the hell is wrong with these people????

The rest of the list is what belongs in that other thread YOUR 25 WORST SHOWS OF ALL TIME.
The critics have never liked Three's Company....one of the many reasons I don't pay much attention to them.


and BJ and the Bear was a great show that needs to be on DVD....Lobo too.