I respect both of them. Depp is the better character actor, but best all around is Del Toro.

eah, they're both incredible... it's a tough call though... depp is one of the best actors of all time as far as im concerned. up ther with brando and sellers... but del toro is pretty great as well. i think i'd go with depp though, overall. character acting is really what it all comes down to. if you can create characters and mannerisms and voices and tics then you can create anything you want, thus giving you the upper hand.

Johnny Depp

johnny depp all the way

I'm going with Johnny Depp on this one.

Johnny depp! :D

Johnny Depp!