View Full Version : Would James Evans have been LESS funny if the Evans were like the Huxtables?


TVFactFan
07-08-2007, 04:35 PM
Family who was financially comfortable and not struggling and not in he projects. Would putting James Evans in that kind of situation have made him boring?

Ireneparalegal
07-08-2007, 04:49 PM
I think so merely because what reason would there be for him to be so angry, grouchy, etc? Look at the show you watch, House of Payne. You yourself said that guy on the show is angry all the time...FOR WHAT REASON? Nothing it seems. Unless I have a good reason why someone is angry a lot of the time, it makes no sense.

TVFactFan
07-08-2007, 04:56 PM
I think so merely because what reason would there be for him to be so angry, grouchy, etc? Look at the show you watch, House of Payne. You yourself said that guy on the show is angry all the time...FOR WHAT REASON? Nothing it seems. Unless I have a good reason why someone is angry a lot of the time, it makes no sense.


Yeah I think if the Evans had moved up I would have lost interest in watching the James Evans character

GARFIELDKOOL
07-08-2007, 05:17 PM
I think James would have been a strong black father still, no hypertension, but he wouldn't have been as silly as Cliff. Remember, John Amos played a very down-to-earth rich father in Coming To America, so it would have worked out.

catlover79
07-08-2007, 05:22 PM
Yeah I think if the Evans had moved up I would have lost interest in watching the James Evans character
I second that.

TVFactFan
07-08-2007, 05:29 PM
I think James would have been a strong black father still, no hypertension, but he wouldn't have been as silly as Cliff. Remember, John Amos played a very down-to-earth rich father in Coming To America, so it would have worked out.


He also played a doctor on the Cosby Show and his character was kind of DRY

GARFIELDKOOL
07-08-2007, 05:37 PM
He also played a doctor on the Cosby Show and his character was kind of DRY

Did Bernadette Stanis guest star on the Cosby Show the same season John Amos did?

TVFactFan
07-08-2007, 05:40 PM
Did Bernadette Stanis guest star on the Cosby Show the same season John Amos did?


I'm not sure. But I wonder if John Amos had the skills to play a PLEASANT TV character in a funny way. I know on Fresh Prince he kind of played more of irritable character which made him funny like on Good times

GARFIELDKOOL
07-08-2007, 05:48 PM
I'm not sure. But I wonder if John Amos had the skills to play a PLEASANT TV character in a funny way. I know on Fresh Prince he kind of played more of irritable character which made him funny like on Good times


He acted like he was Will's boyfriend which did make him funny. He did almost go James on Uncle Phil when Phil kept throwing paying for Will and Lisa's wedding in his face. That was funny! :lol:

sugamama
07-08-2007, 10:58 PM
Wasn't he the dad in All about the Andersons?? I know the show was short lived but I think that he did a pretty good job as a middle class family man although he was a bit grouchy.

catlover79
07-08-2007, 11:00 PM
Wasn't he the dad in All about the Andersons?? I know the show was short lived but I think that he did a pretty good job as a middle class family man although he was a bit grouchy.
That was him!! :nod: