They're taping the performance show on Monday, so we'll probably get spoilers then. Make sure you vote if you can because every vote counts for charity. :D

I'm voting for my Top Three: Phil, Jordin, and Melinda! :D

I hope no one pciks We Are the World that one;s too obviosu for this theme

so it won't be live tuesday sorry i am :confused:

I'm so excited for this episode!! :D

I'm sorry...I drift in and out too much. So is it on Mon and Wed next week indstead of Tue and Wed?

am i the only one not looking foward to this Idol Gives Back thing? the charity part is nice but this season's shows have been drawn out and celebrity-packed enough...im only looking foward to carrie, and maybe kelly.

or maybe im just negative about everything LOLL

I am really looking forward to the Idol Gives Back Event!! I think it's a great idea!!! :)

It is NOT a live show. The performance show is pre-taped but will still be airing on Tuesday.

am i the only one not looking foward to this Idol Gives Back thing? the charity part is nice but this season's shows have been drawn out and celebrity-packed enough...im only looking foward to carrie, and maybe kelly.

or maybe im just negative about everything LOLL

There's no MAYBE about that one.

Actually I have a feeling this is gonna be kinda dumb. :lol: But hey, at least it's for a good cause.

I hope no one pciks We Are the World that one;s too obviosu for this theme

That should be the group song LOL

That should be the group song LOL
Not should, I have a feeling it WILL

I think the group song is gonna be the charity single Quincy Jones wrote for them.

I think the group song is gonna be the charity single Quincy Jones wrote for them.
LOL ok!

I think the group song is gonna be the charity single Quincy Jones wrote for them.

Just shoot down my DREAMS why don't ya?

Just shoot down my DREAMS why don't ya?

It's okay TF, I'm sure when you dream at night they will be singing We Are the World. Especially for you. :mrtarver:

:lol: :lol:

Amd guys just watch the Idol Giives Back thingy anyway, just for Borat,Carrie and kelly :grr:

^ Ummmm okay. I just watch out of habit, LOL.

^ Ummmm okay. I just watch out of habit, LOL.
I know, but in cas esome people might plan to not wnat to..

It's okay TF, I'm sure when you dream at night they will be singing We Are the World. Especially for you. :mrtarver:
Oh, they will...But It'd be better if it actually happened. :(

Has anyone read the spoilers on IDF yet?

Has anyone read the spoilers on IDF yet?
You bet I have.

You bet I have.

I'm trying to stay away from them. :lol: I wanna be surprised.

I did hear though that...

Jordin will be singing You'll Never Walk Alone.

BTW, voting lines are open for FOUR hours tonight and each contestant will have two numbers, so you don't have an excuse to not vote. :p

I'm trying to stay away from them. :lol: I wanna be surprised.

I did hear though that...

Jordin will be singing You'll Never Walk Alone.

BTW, voting lines are open for FOUR hours tonight and each contestant will have two numbers, so you don't have an excuse to not vote. :p

No freaking way I was staying away from spoilers this week. :lol: I'll keep my mouth shut about them though. :p

Everyone should vote because it's for a good cause.

im LATE but heres my reviews anyway.

Chris R - Ehh...not as good as the judges said. I thought it was ok, but not spectacular.

Melinda - VERY VERY good. Possibly my favorite from her yet. Just an awesome performance overall.

Blake - As soon as they said he was singing John Lennon, I knew this would be the song. This wasn't amazing, but it was good enough.

well, everyone has done pretty well so far. tonight feels weird though, doesnt feel like an Idol show (probably cause it was pre-taped).

Chris was good, Melidna was awesome, Blake was pretty good too

LaKisha - probably the worst song choice, um ever. it gets better at the end, but its a pretty bad performance on the whole. i feel mean saying it was so bad cause of theme and all but...erm, it wasnt good. :(

Lakisha was ok, not a good song choice, hwhats next week? Do I Make You Proud? Flying Without Wings?? A Moment Like this?



And Paula should just go to rehab and be replaced.

Phil - A few rough notes in the middle, but overall, a really good performance. He's definitley improving.

Phil was really good, at first I thought Phil would go this week a couple weeks ago, but, if he did, id be surpriised

Jordin - Amazing. Just...amazing. Best performance of the season, IMO.

Jordin - Amazing. Just...amazing. Best performance of the season, IMO.
DITTO!

sorry that show was boring

I thought everyone was great tonight!!!

I have now revised my top 6 list:

1) Blake
2) Chris
3) Melinda/Jordin
4) Phil
5) LaKisha

Jordin - Amazing. Just...amazing. Best performance of the season, IMO.
DITTO!
Right on, my friends. Right on.

Jordin's performance was overrated. I'm sorry. I know you guys love her and all, but when you LISTEN to it...vocally there was some rough patches. I still say it was the best performance of the night though just because she delivered it with lots of emotion. It was a very believable performance, I'll give it that.

Chris was amazing. Not a perfect vocal (Though that run in the end was freaking awesome), but definitely one of his personal best performances, and one of the best of the night.

Melinda...always consistent, always the emotive interpreter. Loved it.

Blake had some rough patches in vocal terms and it was kind of a boring performance, but like the judges said it was genuinely sensitive. Plus major points to him for singing a song I quoted as my senior yearbook quote last year. ;)

Lakisha...just ewwwww. Stay away from songs sung by other Idols.

Phil was alright, but bland.

I voted the entire four hours for Chris tonight but I'm EXTREMELY worried that he's going to leave next. :crying:

I thought Phil, Melinda, and Jordin were all excellent. Blake, LaKisha, and Chris did nothing for me. I really hope Chris goes tonight. I'm sorry, I know he has a lot of fans around here, but I do not find him pleasant to listen to.

And Paula should just go to rehab and be replaced.


:lol: :lol: :lol: So true! I'm tired of her inane comments and silly behavior. I think the contestants deserve to be judged by someone who can act like an adult, not get all teary-eyed, and be able to give constructive criticism.

sorry that show was boring
it was...but since every show this season is boring, this one at least had some good performances.

Chris - I thought he did a pretty good job. Probably not the best I've heard from him but it was good.

Melinda - Awesome job, like always.

Blake - I thought he did a really good job--awesome. I'm surprised the judges didn't really like it that much.

LaKisha - I thought it was pretty good. Not her best but not her worst.

Phil - Awesome job. One of his best performances.

Jordin - An ok job. It sounded pretty good towards the end but the beginning was bad. I agree with The Girl Next Door with the fact that Jordin is really overrated. Her voice isn't that great, IMO and the judges always praise her even when her performances aren't very good. Sorry, JMO.

Chris, LaKisha and Phil are in trouble tonight. I don't know which one of them will be leaving.

Jordin's performance was overrated. I'm sorry. I know you guys love her and all, but when you LISTEN to it...vocally there was some rough patches.

Melinda...always consistent, always the emotive interpreter. Loved it.

Blake had some rough patches in vocal terms and it was kind of a boring performance


Phil was ... bland.

I agree with all this...mind that it is edited.

so, i'm pretty sure no one is leaving. is it me, or is that kind of cruel? people voted for their favorites, and they basically lied to them and didnt even have anyone leave.

i guess we'll see, but im pretty sure no ones going.

Im pretty sure no one;s going too.

no one left. :lol: why didn't they just make a seperate show for Idol Gives Back? there was no need combining it with a "results" show.

Well, that was strange, LOL.

Odd show.

I'm glad nobody went home!

I'm glad nobody went home!
im not, really...waste of 2 hours of my life. the segments they showed were all mostly recycled, and the only good performance was Kelly (and Carrie, but she hardly performed).

Jordin - An ok job. It sounded pretty good towards the end but the beginning was bad. I agree with The Girl Next Door with the fact that Jordin is really overrated. Her voice isn't that great, IMO and the judges always praise her even when her performances aren't very good. Sorry, JMO.


I don't think the beginning was bad. Just because it wasn't powerful doesn't mean it was weak. And it's fine to not be a fan of an Idol, but to say Jordin's voice isn't great is a far stretch. I don't like LaKisha much but there's no doubt she's a great singer.

I don't think the beginning was bad. Just because it wasn't powerful doesn't mean it was weak. And it's fine to not be a fan of an Idol, but to say Jordin's voice isn't great is a far stretch. I don't like LaKisha much but there's no doubt she's a great singer.

Yeah, I think everyone in the top 6 are great singers and they all deserve to be there. I just prefer some over others.

BTW, how is the original You'll Never Walk Alone supposed to sound? (Yeah, I never heard it before :o ) Because in the live performance she was really belting it out but in the studio version she sounds so subdued. I found that to be kinda strange.

I don't think the beginning was bad. Just because it wasn't powerful doesn't mean it was weak. And it's fine to not be a fan of an Idol, but to say Jordin's voice isn't great is a far stretch. I don't like LaKisha much but there's no doubt she's a great singer.
yeah, even if you dont like Jordin, there really is no denying she has a really good voice.

I don't think the beginning was bad. Just because it wasn't powerful doesn't mean it was weak. And it's fine to not be a fan of an Idol, but to say Jordin's voice isn't great is a far stretch. I don't like LaKisha much but there's no doubt she's a great singer.

That's not why I thought the beginning was bad. I thought it was bad because it sounded out of tune, in my opinion. The ending was good and was in tune.

Different people have different tastes. I don't think Jordin's voice is all that great, but it's just my opinion. I know there are many people that think she has a great voice, and I respect that. It's just like how I like Phil. I like his voice and I think he's a great singer, but that's just my opinion. I know there are others who think his voice isn't great, and I respect that too.

yeah, even if you dont like Jordin, there really is no denying she has a really good voice.

It's not that I don't like her. She has a good personality and seems to be a nice person. I just personally do not like her voice. That's all.

yeah, even if you dont like Jordin, there really is no denying she has a really good voice.

Unless you have bad taste. That's one excuse. :p

Unless you have bad taste. That's one excuse. :p
LOL yup

Unless you have bad taste. That's one excuse. :p

I hope you and Jack are kidding. Not everyone is going to like your favorite and just because they don't doesn't mean they have bad taste. As a Chris Richardson fan, I know. :lol:

I agree and disagree with I Love John Ritter. I disagree with her opinion saying that Jordin's not a great singer, because I think she is a great singer. She has amazing range and shows good control of her voice on some songs...just listen to If We Hold on Together and I Who Have Nothing, they're almost flawless.

But I also can see why she doesn't think she's great. I feel like sometimes Jordin has breath management problems (On a Clear Day). Also the judges have been overpimping her performances. A Broken Wing and You'll Never Walk Alone had pitch problems yet the judges didn't say anything about it.

Honestly, as much I like Jordin and would like to see her get far, I've already seen her in the likes of Kelly Clarkson, Diana DeGarmo, and Katharine McPhee - pretty pop singer with a big voice and versatile in the songs she chooses.

Oh and before people start hating on my favorite, I felt like the judges overpimped Chris's Change the World performance too. It was good but I did notice a rift in the vocal aspect of it.

I hope you and Jack are kidding. Not everyone is going to like your favorite and just because they don't doesn't mean they have bad taste. As a Justin Timberfake fan, I know. :lol:

Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah.

Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah.

Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah.

Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah Blah blah.

Just because you don't agree with me doesn't mean I'm wrong. :D

Just because you don't agree with me doesn't mean I'm wrong. :D

Whatevs. This is why I ended up disliking Katharine McPhee last season - her fans were shoving her down my damn throat. It's already started with Jordin this season and out of all people, I don't need you to do it to me, TF.

Whatevs. This is why I ended up disliking Katharine McPhee last season - her fans were shoving her down my damn throat. It's already started with Jordin this season and out of all people, I don't need you to do it to me, TF.
sar·casm (sär'kăz'əm)
n.

1. A cutting, often ironic remark intended to wound.
2. A form of wit that is marked by the use of sarcastic language and is intended to make its victim the butt of contempt or ridicule.
3. The use of sarcasm.

sar·casm (sär'kăz'əm)
n.

1. A cutting, often ironic remark intended to wound.
2. A form of wit that is marked by the use of sarcastic language and is intended to make its victim the butt of contempt or ridicule.
3. The use of sarcasm.
:rotflmao: OWNED!

:rotflmao: OWNED!
Ok man...That's kind of mean. *Hypocrite*

http://img244.imageshack.us/img244/640/chrisidiotsmileytl1.jpg

Ok man...That's kind of mean. *Hypocrite*
Sorry, s didnt mean you though