I saw this thread on IDF so I thought it'd be cool to bring it over here. :D So basically just combine your rankings from last season with this one. Here's my list:

red = AI5
blue - AI6

1. Chris Daughtry
2. Elliott Yamin
3. Chris Richardson
4. Gina Glocksen
5. Blake Lewis

6. Taylor Hicks
7. Katharine McPhee
8. Melinda Doolittle
9. Phil Stacey
10. Jordin Sparks

11. Kellie Pickler
12. Chris Sligh

13. Paris Bennett
14. Stephanie Edwards
15. Lisa Tucker

16. Ace Young
17. Mandisa
18. Lakisha Jones
19. Brandon Rogers

20. Bucky Covington
21. Melissa McGhee
22. Sanjaya Malakar
23. Haley Scarnato
24. Kevin Covais

Took me a while to figure it out, BUT I GOT IT NOW. :lol:

1. Kevin
2. Elliott
3. Taylor
4. Ace
5. Blake
6. Chris R.
7. Haley
8. Melinda
9. Jordin
10. Phil
11. Chris S.
12. LaKisha
13. Gina
14. Paris
15. Melissa
16. Stephanie
17. Mandisa
18. Brandon
19. Lisa
20. Sanjaya
21. Bucky
22. Kellie
23. Katharine
24. Chris D.

Its interesting how my favorite favorites are from AI5, along with my most hated lol. Usually Im a lot more passionate with my idols where I either have a strong dislike or love [like AI5 contestants], but this season Im kinda neutral with all of them. Even my favorite [Blake] isnt nearly strong a passion as past favorites I have had.

Took me a while to figure it out, BUT I GOT IT NOW. :lol:

1. Kevin
2. Elliott
3. Taylor
4. Ace
5. Blake
6. Chris R.
7. Haley
8. Melinda
9. Jordin
10. Phil
11. Chris S.
12. LaKisha
13. Gina
14. Paris
15. Melissa
16. Stephanie
17. Mandisa
18. Brandon
19. Lisa
20. Sanjaya
21. Bucky
22. Kellie
23. Katharine
24. Chris D.

Its interesting how my favorite favorites are from AI5, along with my most hated lol. Usually Im a lot more passionate with my idols where I either have a strong dislike or love [like AI5 contestants], but this season Im kinda neutral with all of them. Even my favorite [Blake] isnt nearly strong a passion as past favorites I have had.
Is Chris Daughtry really that horrible to you? :(

Katharine McPhee - Best
Melinda Doolittle
Jordin Sparks
Melissa McGhee - Very Good
Lakisha Jones
Taylor Hicks
Gina Glocksen
Chris Sligh
Mandisa
Kellie Pickler - Good in their own ways
Haley Scarnato
Lisa Tucker
Paris Bennett
Phil Stacey
Stephanie Edwards - Average, usually
Elliott Yamin
Chris Daughtry
Bucky Covington
Brandon Rogers
Chris Richardson - Unoriginal, just plain bad, or boring
Kevin Covais
Ace Young
Blake Lewis
Sanjaya Malakar

Took me a while to figure it out, BUT I GOT IT NOW. :lol:

1. Kevin
2. Elliott
3. Taylor
4. Ace
5. Blake
6. Chris R.
7. Haley
8. Melinda
9. Jordin
10. Phil
11. Chris S.
12. LaKisha
13. Gina
14. Paris
15. Melissa
16. Stephanie
17. Mandisa
18. Brandon
19. Lisa
20. Sanjaya
21. Bucky
22. Kellie
23. Katharine
24. Chris D.

this season Im kinda neutral with all of them. Even my favorite [Blake] isnt nearly strong a passion as past favorites I have had.
yeah, same here...only my favorite is jordin LOL.

im not gonna do a list though...cause im too lazy and it takes too much time :happyface

1. Katharine McPhee
2. Gina Glocksen
3. Melinda Doolittle
4. Blake Lewis
5. Melissa McGee
6. Mandisa
7. Lisa Tucker
8. LaKisha Jones
9. Jordin Sparks
10. Haley Scarnado
11. Kellie Pickler
12. Elliot Yamin
13. Stephanie Edwards
14. Chris Sligh
15. Chris Richardson
16. Bucky Covington
17. Taylor Hicks
18. Paris Bennet
19. Chris Daughtry
20. Kevin Covais
21. Ace Young
22. Phil Stacey
23. Brandon Rogers
24. Sanjaya Malakar

Wow! Doing this list, makes last year feel SO long ago.

1. Elliott
2. Phil
3. LaKisha
4. Melinda
5. Mandisa
6. Paris
7. Lisa
8. Chris Sligh
9. Taylor
10. Chris Richardson
11. Blake
12. Gina
13. Haley
14. Brandon
15. Stephanie
16. Jordin
17. Kellie
18. Bucky
19. Chris Daughtry
20. Katharine
21. Ace
22. Melissa
23. Kevin
24. Sanjaya

Bored and my mind changed a little bit after the season, so ranking this again.

1. Chris Daughtry
2. Chris Richardson
3. Blake Lewis
4. Elliott Yamin
5. Gina Glocksen
6. Melinda Doolittle
7. Phil Stacey
8. Taylor Hicks
9. Jordin Sparks
10. Katharine McPhee
11. Chris Sligh
12. Kellie Pickler
13. Paris Bennett
14. Stephanie Edwards
15. Lisa Tucker
16. Ace Young
17. Mandisa
18. Lakisha Jones
19. Sanjaya Malakar
20. Brandon Rogers
21. Bucky Covington
22. Haley Scarnato
23. Melissa McGhee
24. Kevin Covais

#1-4 = AMAZING. :heart:

#5-6 are amongst my top 10 all-time fave Idols, but I don't like them as much as #1-4 who pretty much OWN me.

Generally I like #7-10, but I'm on-and-off about those people.

#11-17 I'm sort of neutral about, even though I mostly like them.

Same with #18-20 even though I have more of a negative leaning towards them.

I really disliked #21-24, even though I like them more now than I did during their respective seasons. These were the people I really wanted out first.

No one that I can't stand though. They're all awesome in their own ways. <3

ohh why not. im bored.


1. Chris Daughtry (AI5)
2. Kellie Pickler (AI5)
3. Jordin Sparks (AI6)
4. Katharine McPhee (AI5)
5. Kevin Covais (AI5)
6. Mandisa (AI5)
7. Lisa Tucker (AI5)
8. Ace Young (AI5)
9. Elliott Yamin (AI5)
10. Gina Glockson (AI6)
11. Taylor Hicks (AI5)
12. Paris Bennett (AI5)
13. Phil Stacey (AI6)
14. Blake Lewis (AI6)
15. Melinda Doolittle (AI6)
16. Bucky Covington (AI5)
17. Sanjaya Malakar (AI6)
18. Haley Scrantato (AI6)
19. LaKisha Jones (AI6)
20. Chris Richardson (AI6)
21. Stephanie Edwards (AI6)
22. Melissa McGhee (AI5)
23. Brandon Rogers (AI6)
24. Chris Sligh (AI6)

#1-#3 completely own everyone else and also completely rock. :)

#4 -#10 are also awesome, but they aren't qutie at the "ownage" level like #1 -#3 are.

#11 - #15 i was really up-and-down about, there were times i hated them and times i really liked them during their respective seasons. but, now that both seasons are over, my final decision is that i pretty much like all of them...they aren't AWESOME like my top 10, but they are pretty cool in their own ways.

#16 - #17 are kind of funny to me. both of them suck singing-wise but they have funny personalities that makes me like them.

#18 - #21 i dont really like, but i can admit they have some good points. C-Rich, "Geek in the Pink" is still one of the best performances of AI6.

#22 - #24 = the bottom three. i dont like them at all. Melissa always irritated me ever since she made it in before Ayla as i think her voice is really weak and she didnt do anything. Brandon did NOTHING, and Chris Sligh is arrogant and his performances always struck me as erm, suck-ish.


BTW, everyone in my top 10 except for Jordin and Gina is from AI5. this shows how much more i enjoyed AI5 then AI6 :happyface