Last one before they pick the top 12! Rant, rave, discuss, whatever. :happyface

My top 4 were in no particular order:
Chris Sligh
Phil Stacey
Sundance Head
Blake Lewis

Bottom 4

Sanjaya Malakar
Chris Richardson
Jared Cotter
Brandon Rogers

Jordin - good, nothing too special though
Sabrina - great... i liked it a lot
Antonella - not THAT bad.. i mean she's been worse... lol
Haley - i reallllllyyyyy liked her.. i can't believe simon bashed her that badly :( i would have cried if i were her
Stephanie - good
LaKisha - very good
Gina - wtf? I thought she totally yelled and screamed through this whole song. I didn't like it
Melinda - definitely the best of the night... and i like how she genuinely looks like shes enjoying her time there

Goodness, the girls were all good tonight, I think. The real stand-outs for me were Melinda, LaKisha, Stephanie, and Sabrina. Gina's vocals weren't extremely good, but it was so obvious that THAT was who she was, and I really liked her performance.

Oh god. Are you serious? Now I dislike both Sundance and Sanjaya... but as to who should have gotten in....100% SUNDANCE.

Oh god. Are you serious? Now I dislike both Sundance and Sanjaya... but as to who should have gotten in....100% SUNDANCE.
I know!

Who was eliminated?

Who was eliminated?
Jared Cotter
Antonella Barba
Sabrina Sloan
Sundance Head

Sabrina Sloan


I didn't even like her that much, but she SO deserved to be in the Top 12 over Haley. Haley completely ruined the song. She sounded like average karaoke at best.

I didn't even like her that much, but she SO deserved to be in the Top 12 over Haley. Haley completely ruined the song. She sounded like average karaoke at best.

I agree.

I'm glad Antonella was finally voted off. That girl sings terribly and has absolutely no class. I am surprised that Haley got on instead of Sabrina. Sabrina is far more talented. I guess they needed someone in the Top 12 to appease the Britney/Mariah//Simpson sisters/bubblegum pop crowd.

I'm not too surprised that Jared was voted off. I am disgusted that Sundance was sent home instead of Sanjaya :mad: Sundance at his worst still sounds better than Sanjaya.

honestly, i feel happy that Haley made top 12. the judges basically told her she was worthless to the show, constantly ripped her apart, and crisisized her HORRIBLY. shes not a great singer, but she totally owned the judges, and that makes me like her. :nod:

oh, and Sundance getting cut. *-* Antonella getting cut was shocking but not sad.

oh, and as for the performances, i thought the guys and the girls both sucked really badly. NO ONE was really all that good for the guys, and for the girls, Jordin and Melinda were the only good ones for me. i actually thought LaKisha didn't really do well with I Have Nothing, but its probably because that song is the most overdone song EVER.

I am surprised that Haley got on instead of Sabrina. Sabrina is far more talented. I guess they needed someone in the Top 12 to appease the Britney/Mariah//Simpson sisters/bubblegum pop crowd.



Mariah really should not be grouped together with those people, and Haley could never pull off one of her songs. The only ones who possibly could are Melinda and LaKisha.