He said because Garcia just barley got the Pass off on 4th and 10 and knew that on 4th and 15 he probably wouldn't have had a chance to throw-lol

That is a weak excuse. He cost the Eagles the game with being way too conservative. Now, he has Eagles fans guessing, "What if?"

Excuses....excuses. He had a better chance of making that 4th and 15 then he did with stopping the Saints running game. I remember when he decided to go for it, I started laughing because I said to myself Andy Reid just goofed again. If Marty Schottenheimer is always under a microscope for not reaching the SB then Andy Reid should be too. He always chokes in big games.

He said because Garcia just barley got the Pass off on 4th and 10 and knew that on 4th and 15 he probably wouldn't have had a chance to throw-lol


He should have gone for it, he knows it, I know it & the entire eagle fan base knows it. I would have rather had him go for it, if they fail to get it, so be it. Even if they didn't get it, you give the saints the ball near midfield & who knows maybe they hold them a field goal attempt. If they converted the field goal it would have been 30-24. Who knows how much time they would have had left to do their magic, but the eagles have the ability to score quickly & it is my feeling that reid should have done that. Two possibilites withthis scenario instead of putting all of your eggs in one basket by just giving it back to them. What if, what if.

I think what he is really trying to say is-"We barley made the 4th and 10"-LOL

I think what he is really trying to say is-"We barley made the 4th and 10"-LOL


True, but they still MADE IT. He should've shown some guts on that play.

True, but they still MADE IT. He should've shown some guts on that play.


Wow I agree with you for once.... call mike lupica STOP THe PRESSES

Wow I agree with you for once.... call mike lupica STOP THe PRESSES


:lol:

True, but they still MADE IT. He should've shown some guts on that play.


I was surprised that after a 6 Game winning streak Andy Reid all of a sudden had no confidence in Garcia to convert a 1st down on 4th and 15-lol

I was surprised that after a 6 Game winning streak Andy Reid all of a sudden had no confidence in Garcia to convert a 1st down on 4th and 15-lol


Very good point.