:confused: ok now i know that this just started and all but do you think that Luke will win at this whole getting April thing?!! i mean i don't know i think he should i mean after all shes Lukes kid too! i think something should be arranged don't you?!

i usually have a pretty good feeling about where the stories are gonna go, but with this i'm at a road block. anything will suprise me. i just hope that april STAYS. I love the relationship between her and Luke. I think it's helped Luke grow up a lot; helped him learn more about relationships.

I hope he is only allowed to see her every so often. April is what tore Luke and Lorelai apart, and if anyone wants them together, well, she's gonna have to go. I still want Luke to be a dad, so that's why I think her coming around every now and then would work.

And remember, Anna won't allow April to become friends with Lorelai, so I think he might have to choose between his kid, or the woman he loves.

yeah but all do respect i don't think thats right i mean shes not being very fair in all of this i don't know that her promblem is with Lor i mean is she STILL mad over the whole b-day party thing or something like that??!! i'm sorry but i do not like that woman one little bit i think shes being wayyyy over reacting over this whole thing! i mean i'm sorry that shes all mad at Luke and all but geez shes just too pig headed i think!

shes just too pig headed i think!

:lol: Right on!

Yeah you guys are right she is being pig headed. Luke is April's dad doesn't that mean anything, Luke has rights he should get some say in his daughters life I mean Ana let April come and be with Luke why take her away now and why can't they writer's let us see April's reaction to this cause I think April would be pretty upset cause she seems to really like Luke. I really hope Luke wins in court (keeping my fingers crossed) cause I really like watching him as a dad I really thought the ep where April was in the hospital was very good Luke really cared for April and it would really hurt if he lost her. I would really hate if Luke lost her cause he has already been through enough loseing Lorelia and then he almost lost his diner and now he has to watch Chris with Lorelia all the time since Chris and her got married poor guy, and I really feel sorry for the way he had to find out that Lorelia and Chris got married I mean Lorelia should of told him instead of him just seeing the ring. But he has gone through enough just let him have one good thing in his life.

yeah i toally agree with you Jo i mean come on poor Luke he has been though enough losing hes love and now maybe even his kid?!! i mean what did Luke ever do to derserve all of this?!! hes a nice and sweet guy (in a tough sweet way that is!) i like Luke and he derserves a lot better than hes been getting lately! and it was kind of a bad way for Luke to see Lors ring i mean geezs the look on his face was like why don't you just rip out whats left of my heart!we should all send him a fan letter saying how sorry we all are!! but i do hope that Luke gets his way in court cause this is just so unfair Aprils hes kid too and i don't like the way that Ana grrrrr! lol has been treating him,she derserved to be yelled at i would have too! i was like yeah Luke i'm proud of ya! i'm sorry but she really she pig headed and i hope she doesn't win!

I dont know I hope that he gets to see her and it is wrong that April is just being taken out of the state like that and halfway across the country and I think that the fact that even though he hasnt been there half of her life its not his fault that he didnt know they do have a tight bond and taking April away like that isnt fair to her or Luke.

I hope he is only allowed to see her every so often. April is what tore Luke and Lorelai apart, and if anyone wants them together, well, she's gonna have to go. I still want Luke to be a dad, so that's why I think her coming around every now and then would work.

And remember, Anna won't allow April to become friends with Lorelai, so I think he might have to choose between his kid, or the woman he loves.
i completely disagree. It was Luke's action in handling the "april situation"... it wasn't April that caused the split, it was a serious communication issue between Luke and Lor, the "April situation" is just what brought that problem to the surface.

I hope they get joint custody, because despite hte fact that Anna is being a jerk, April shoudln't be ripped away from the woman who raised her hte past 10 years.

i completely disagree. It was Luke's action in handling the "april situation"... it wasn't April that caused the split, it was a serious communication issue between Luke and Lor, the "April situation" is just what brought that problem to the surface.

I hope they get joint custody, because despite hte fact that Anna is being a jerk, April shoudln't be ripped away from the woman who raised her hte past 10 years.
Hey, you got me. I actually thought about editing my post, before everyone responded here. :lol:

Anyway, your right. They were having problems that didn't even involve April. It's Luke's!!! All Luke. Thanks for helping me get that now! Damn Luke! It was Luke who always used to "hide" Lorelai when April would come to the diner.

yep, Luke really screwed up in handling the situation. But mistakes happen. He has obviously learned a lot from that mistake. I think before April Luke didn't know what a "relatinoship" really was; romantic or otherwise. Now he knows what a relatinoship that he never wants to see end feels like (the father-daughter relationship) and I think fatherhood has really helped him to mature.

yeah heres to poor Luke! i just hope in some shape or form that this doesn't effect Lor and Lukes "thing" even worse you know! but you know this whole thing could all go away if Aprils mom "pulls her head out of her butt!" sorry lol! but hey i mean what is she the wicked wich or something!

come on guys whats with this maybe or no stuff??!! we're all supposed to be cheering poor Luke on!